Which Team Is Best?

[Nosferatu]

TEAM 1

OFFENSE
QB - Ben Roethlisberger - Steelers
RB - Barry Sanders - Lions
FB - Franco Harris - Steelers
WR - Isaac Bruce - Rams
WR - James Lofton - Packers
WR - Henry Ellard - Rams
TE - Zach Ertz - Eagles
LT - Andrew Whitworth - Rams
LG - Nate Newton - Cowboys
C - Mark Stepnoski - Cowboys
RG - Will Shields - Chiefs
RT - Jason Peters - Bills

DEFENSE
LDE - Jim Marshall - Browns
LDT - Bryant Young - 49ers
RDT - Warren Sapp - Buccaneers
RDE - Jason Taylor - Dolphins
LLB - London Fletcher - Bills
MLB - Ray Lewis - Ravens
RLB - Bill Romanowski - 49ers
CB1 - Deion Sanders - Cowboys
CB2 - Eric Allen - Eagles
NB - Donnie Shell - Steelers
SS - Eric Weddle - Ravens
FS - Darren Sharper - Packers

TEAM 2

OFFENSE
QB - Tom Brady - Buccaneers
RB - Thurman Thomas - Bills
FB - Larry Centers - Bills
WR - Torry Holt - Rams
WR - John Stallworth - Steelers
WR - Art Monk - Eagles
TE - Tony Gonzalez - Chiefs
LT - Jonathan Ogden - Ravens
LG - Joel Bitonio - Browns
C - Dermontti Dawson - Steelers
RG - Marshal Yanda - Ravens
RT - Erik Williams - Cowboys

DEFENSE
LDE - Jason Pierre-Paul - Buccaneers
LDT - Merlin Olsen - Rams
RDT - Fletcher Cox - Eagles
RDE - Dwight Freeney - Lions
LLB - Bobby Bell - Chiefs
MLB - Willie Lanier - Chiefs
RLB - Isiah Robertson - Bills
CB1 - Stephon Gilmore - Cowboys
CB2 - Chris McAlister - Ravens
NB - Merton Hanks - 49ers
SS - Roy Williams - Cowboys
FS - Ed Reed - Texans

TEAM 3

OFFENSE
QB - Dan Marino - Dolphins
RB - Marshall Faulk - Rams
FB - Kyle Juszczyk - Ravens
WR - Jerry Rice - 49ers
WR - Steve Smith - Ravens
WR - Andre Reed - Bills
TE - George Kittle - 49ers
LT - Tyron Smith - Cowboys
LG - Tom Mack - Rams
C - Jim Ringo - Packers
RG - Gene Hickerson - Browns
RT - Forrest Gregg - Packers

DEFENSE
LDE - Jack Youngblood - Rams
LDT - Mean Joe Greene - Steelers
RDT - Bob Lilly - Cowboys
RDE - Jared Allen - Chiefs
LLB - Chuck Howley - Cowboys
MLB - Fred Warner - 49ers
RLB - Ted Hendricks - Packers
CB1 - Night Train Lane - Lions
CB2 - Patrick Peterson - Steelers
NB - Aqib Talib - Buccaneers
SS - Joey Browner - Buccaneers
FS - Brian Dawkins - Eagles

TEAM 4

OFFENSE
QB - Kurt Warner - Rams
RB - Marcus Allen - Chiefs
RB - Priest Holmes - Ravens
WR - Randy Moss - 49ers
WR - Andre Johnson - Texans
WR - Mike Evans - Buccaneers
TE - Shannon Sharpe - Ravens
LT - Joe Thomas - Browns
LG - Billy Shaw - Bills
C - Dwight Stephenson - Dolphins
RG - Jerry Kramer - Packers
RT - Bob St. Clair - 49ers

DEFENSE
LDE - Lee Roy Selmon - Buccaneers
NT - Haloti Ngata - Lions
RDE - Bruce Smith - Bills
LOLB - Terrell Suggs - Chiefs
LILB - Hardy Nickerson - Steelers
RILB - Roquan Smith - Ravens
ROLB - Derrick Thomas - Chiefs
CB1 - Aeneas Williams - Rams
CB2 - Ronde Barber - Buccaneers
NB - Dick LeBeau - Lions
SS - Troy Polamalu - Steelers
FS - Cliff Harris - Cowboys

TEAM 5

OFFENSE
QB - Brett Favre - Packers
RB - Eric Dickerson - Rams
RB - Adrian Peterson - Lions
WR - Don Hutson - Packers
WR - Cris Carter - Eagles
WR - Michael Irvin - Cowboys
TE - Ozzie Newsome - Browns
LT - Richmond Webb - Dolphins
LG - Logan Mankins - Buccaneers
C - Mike Webster - Chiefs
RG - Joe DeLamielleure - Bills
RT - Jackie Slater - Rams

DEFENSE
LDE - Myles Garrett - Browns
LDT - Alex Karras - Lions
RDT - Randy White - Cowboys
RDE - Chris Doleman - 49ers
LLB - Jack Ham - Steelers
MLB - Jack Lambert - Steelers
RLB - Junior Seau - Dolphins
CB1 - Rod Woodson - Ravens
CB2 - Mel Blount - Steelers
NB - Emmitt Thomas - Chiefs
SS - Darren Woodson - Cowboys
FS - Deron Cherry - Chiefs

TEAM 6

OFFENSE
QB - Steve Young - Buccaneers
RB - Emmitt Smith - Cowboys
RB - LeSean McCoy - Eagles
WR - Calvin Johnson - Lions
WR - Julio Jones - Eagles
WR - Sterling Sharpe - Packers
TE - Jason Witten - Cowboys
LT - Willie Roaf - Chiefs
LG - Ruben Brown - Bills
C - Alex Mack - Browns
RG - Jahri Evans - Packers
RT - Willie Anderson - Ravens

DEFENSE
LDE - Cameron Heyward - Steelers
NT - Ted Washington - Bills
RDE - Aaron Donald - Rams
LOLB - T.J. Watt - Steelers
LILB - Zach Thomas - Dolphins
RILB - Patrick Willis - 49ers
ROLB - Von Miller - Bills
CB1 - Charles Woodson - Packers
CB2 - Darrelle Revis - Buccaneers
NB - Albert Lewis - Chiefs
SS - Eric Berry - Chiefs
FS - Nolan Cromwell - Rams

TEAM 7

OFFENSE
QB - Aaron Rodgers - Packers
RB - O.J. Simpson - Bills
FB - Tony Richardson - Chiefs
WR - Davante Adams - Packers
WR - DeAndre Hopkins - Texans
WR - CeeDee Lamb - Cowboys
TE - Mark Andrews - Ravens
LT - Orlando Pace - Rams
LG - Alan Faneca - Steelers
C - Jim Langer - Dolphins
RG - Zack Martin - Cowboys
RT - Rayfield Wright - Cowboys

DEFENSE
LDE - Reggie White - Eagles
LDT - Ndamukong Suh - Lions
RDT - La'Roi Glover - Rams
RDE - Deacon Jones - Rams
LLB - Dave Wilcox - 49ers
MLB - Ray Nitschke - Packers
RLB - Derrick Brooks - Buccaneers
CB1 - Ty Law - Chiefs
CB2 - Jalen Ramsey - Dolphins
NB - Troy Vincent - Eagles
SS - Ronnie Lott - 49ers
FS - Earl Thomas - Ravens

TEAM 8

OFFENSE
QB - Joe Montana - Chiefs
RB - Roger Craig - 49ers
FB - Jim Brown - Browns
WR - Terrell Owens - 49ers
WR - Antonio Brown - Steelers
WR - Jimmy Smith - Cowboys
TE - Rob Gronkowski - Buccaneers
LT - Lomas Brown - Lions
LG - Larry Allen - Cowboys
C - Jason Kelce - Eagles
RG - Larry Little - Dolphins
RT - Ron Yary - Rams

DEFENSE
LDE - J.J. Watt - Texans
NT - Vince Wilfork - Texans
RDE - Calais Campbell - Ravens
LOLB - Kevin Greene - Steelers
LILB - NaVorro Bowman - 49ers
RILB - Bobby Wagner - Rams
ROLB - DeMarcus Ware - Cowboys
CB1 - Richard Sherman - Buccaneers
CB2 - Herb Adderley - Packers
NB - Everson Walls - Browns
SS - LeRoy Butler - Packers
FS - Tyrann Mathieu - Texans

TEAM 9

OFFENSE
QB - Patrick Mahomes - Chiefs
RB - Christian McCaffrey - 49ers
FB - Lorenzo Neal - Ravens
WR - Tyreek Hill - Dolphins
WR - "Bullet" Bob Hayes - Cowboys
WR - A.J. Brown - Eagles
TE - Travis Kelce - Chiefs
LT - Trent Williams - 49ers
LG - Randall McDaniel - Buccaneers
C - Maurkice Pouncey - Steelers
RG - David DeCastro - Steelers
RT - Lane Johnson - Eagles

DEFENSE
LDE - Nick Bosa - 49ers
LDT - Chris Jones - Chiefs
RDT - Jerome Brown - Eagles
RDE - Julius Peppers - Packers
LLB - Micah Parsons - Cowboys
MLB - Chris Spielman - Bills
RLB - Seth Joyner - Packers
CB1 - Lem Barney - Lions
CB2 - Mel Renfro - Cowboys
NB - Frank Minnifield - Browns
SS - John Lynch - Buccaneers
FS - Minkah Fitzpatrick - Steelers

 

[ducky]

Team #9 might have made it move.

But then I went to team #8 and started out much the same. But then I got to RT and you have Ron Yary listed as a Ram. He played 14 years for the Vikings....and one season as a Ram. That one error was a real boner killer.

 

[Nosferatu]

Team #9 might have made it move.

But then I went to team #8 and started out much the same. But then I got to RT and you have Ron Yary listed as a Ram. He played 14 years for the Vikings....and one season as a Ram. That one error was a real boner killer.

The player just had to have played for the team to be drafted, each team could not use any NFL team more than 3 times. So every player on every team played at least a game for the team they are listed with.

 

[ducky]

A glaring omission of not 1 but 2 Chicago Bear's MLB's (and maybe 3 if you want to go even farther back).

Edit:
.....and I forgot about Urlacher! So 4.

 

[ducky]

I dont understand the rules I guess. I just noticed no Sweetness too.

Literally not a single Bears player on those lists. Chicago Bears fans are going to burn this muthafuka down!

 

[Nosferatu]

I dont understand the rules I guess. I just noticed no Sweetness too.

Literally not a single Bears player on those lists. Chicago Bears fans are going to burn this muthafuka down!

Teams could only draft players from 2024 NFL Playoff teams.

 

[ducky]

Teams could only draft players from 2024 NFL Playoff teams.

Well that makes a ton more sense to me as to why some omissions.

 

[Lake Shore Drive]

I dont understand the rules I guess. I just noticed no Sweetness too.

Literally not a single Bears player on those lists. Chicago Bears fans are going to burn this muthafuka down!

Teams could only draft players from 2024 NFL Playoff teams.

I'm telling ya, as a Bears fan I was indeed ready to burn this muthafuka down,
But now it makes sense.

 

[Battlelyon]

Team 3 is elite

 

[Battlelyon]

Team 7 has the best defense

 

[FaCe-LeE-uS]

Calvin Johnson & Julio Jones (Falcons, not Eagles) on the same offense... Dear Lord.

Side note... I'd rather have Larry Fitzgerald listed over about 5-6 of the WR's on here.

 

[molsaniceman]

Teams could only draft players from 2024 NFL Playoff teams.

jack lambert was in the 2024 playoffs not bad at 71

 

[Thruthefog]

Team 7

Any team with Reggie White, Suh, and Deacon Jones on the DL would be unbeatable.

 

[PDay8810]

team 2 with Roy Williams the safety can't stop anyone. I suggest we add a St Louis Cardinal, Larry Wilson (HOF). He & Reed will work out the who plays closer to the LOS.

Nice job with the teams.

 

[PDay8810]

Team 8's interior OL would hold up against anyone.
Larry Allen
Larry Little
Jason Kelce

pity those guys standing in the way of those pulling guards.

 

[msgkings322]

Team 8's interior OL would hold up against anyone.
Larry Allen
Larry Little
Jason Kelce

pity those guys standing in the way of those pulling guards.

My wife tutored Larry Allen at Sonoma State. They don't even have a football program anymore lol

 

[Nosferatu]

The vote is nearly finished, looks like team 5 is going to win.

 

[FaCe-LeE-uS]

Team 7

 

[Battlelyon]

The vote is nearly finished, looks like team 5 is going to win.

Team 5? They alright.

Nobody is stopping Marino, Faulk and Rice trio

 

[Thruthefog]

The vote is nearly finished, looks like team 5 is going to win.

Team 5?

The only thing team 5 has going for it is that Michael Irvin would be the fall guy.