Current HOF players

[broncosmitty]

Yeah

Not gonna be in Canton.

 

[Battlelyon]

u gotta win to get in the HOF, theres jim kelly, marino, moon, jurgensen, one more im forgetting in there without a superbowl everyone else won

plus they dont take 12 qb's from an era

Idk, there is case to make for him and against, not a 1st nor even a 4th ballot, but I can see him getting in eventually

 

[SteelersPride]

Gore is really forcing the issue by playing forever.

Hope he gets there. Hope he has a great year in Buffalo to finish it out.

think he will, dont think hes a talent wise HOF guy, but his stats get him in. Hes 5th in rushing yards, no one whose in the top 10 hasnt gotten in

 

[Battlelyon]

Not gonna be in Canton.

I can see that

 

[SteelersPride]

Idk, there is case to make for him and against, not a 1st nor even a 4th ballot, but I can see him getting in eventually

so they are gonna take brady, brees, ben, rodgers, likely eli, and a few more from this era? i doubt it. He gets a ring, he bumps out eli

 

[jwolt92]

QBs need to win important games.

If I'm not mistaken, there's also 21 other guys who are started in football. Playoff wins aren't the be all, end all for a quarterback. Considering guys like Trent Dilfer, Joe Flacco, and Jim McMahon.. oh and Eli Manning

 

[SteelersPride]

If I'm not mistaken, there's also 21 other guys who are started in football. Playoff wins aren't the be all, end all for a quarterback. Considering guys like Trent Dilfer, Joe Flacco, and Jim McMahon.. oh and Eli Manning

well there arent many HOF qb's who havent won

 

[broncosmitty]

u gotta win to get in the HOF, theres jim kelly, marino, moon, jurgensen, one more im forgetting in there without a superbowl everyone else won

plus they dont take 12 qb's from an era

Tarkenton.

Retired the alltime leading passer and played in I think 3 SBs.

 

[Battlelyon]

Wow! SP, we agree on a lot of stuff but not 1 guy on your list is currently worthy.....

Your nuts on Joe Thomas, 1st ballot player same for Watt

 

[jwolt92]

well there arent many HOF qb's who havent won

Still doesn't make any argument that Rivers isn't a better quarterback than Big Ben or Eli, but I'll wait for your next deflection since according to you.. Dilfer and Flacco > Rivers

 

[broncosmitty]

If I'm not mistaken, there's also 21 other guys who are started in football. Playoff wins aren't the be all, end all for a quarterback. Considering guys like Trent Dilfer, Joe Flacco, and Jim McMahon.. oh and Eli Manning

HOF QBs are winners.


Plain and simple.

Rivers is better than Naimath. Joe Willie shouldn't be a HOFer though. But he won.

 

[jwolt92]

HOF QBs are winners.


Plain and simple.

Rivers is better than Naimath. Joe Willie shouldn't be a HOFer though. But he won.

There are plenty of average quarterbacks who won with a great defense or were excellent game managers with a good running game. I'd take Rivers over 99% of the quarterbacks he played against, therefore in my mind.. a HOFer

 

[Battlelyon]

so they are gonna take brady, brees, ben, rodgers, likely eli, and a few more from this era? i doubt it. He gets a ring, he bumps out eli

Never said I think he should get in only that I can see him getting in

 

[broncosmitty]

I would've said Patrick Peterson a few days ago. Not now.


Not sure I have another name that hasn't been mentioned who won't be total projection. (Zeke, Hopkins, Odell.)

Unless Wilson hasn't been named. Cuz he's in.

 

[rmilia1]

Matt Ryan has a better chance of getting in than Rivers .

Locks right now at QB

Brady
Brees
Big Ben
Rodgers

Guys who will likely get in at QB if their careers maintain .current course

Wilson
Ryan

Guys who may make it

Eli
Rivers

Guys I think will get in but have a ways to go

Luck
Mahomes

 

[PhilSimms11]

Eli Manning
15 seasons
55,981 yards (7)
360 TD (8)
239 INT (14)
60.3% (t-40)
2x Super Bowl Champion

Ben Roethlisberger
15 seasons
56,194 yards (6)
363 TD (7)
190 INT (32)
64.4 % (10)
2x Super Bowl Champion

Philip Rivers
15 seasons
54,656 passing yards (8)
374 TD (6)
178 INT (41)
64.5 % (9)
(all-time rank)

All 3 get in.

 

[broncosmitty]

There are plenty of average quarterbacks who won with a great defense or were excellent game managers with a good running game. I'd take Rivers over 99% of the quarterbacks he played against, therefore in my mind.. a HOFer

99% is all but one or two guys.

Warner and Favre are already in. Brady, Rodgers, Brees are without question better QBs. I'd take Ben well ahead, same with Wilson.


Rivers is somewhere near Romo for me. Very good, not among the greats.

There are 26 HOFs at his position. His odds are very, very slim.

 

[broncosmitty]

Matt Ryan has a better chance of getting in than Rivers .

Locks right now at QB

Brady
Brees
Big Ben
Rodgers

Guys who will likely get in at QB if their careers maintain .current course

Wilson
Ryan

Guys who may make it

Eli
Rivers

Guys I think will get in but have a ways to go

Luck
Mahomes

Matt Ryan would need to win a SB. He's not anywhere near Wilson's level.

 

[broncosmitty]

Matt Stafford is going to top most of those regular season stats.


He won't get in the Michigan Sports HOF without some important wins.

 

[rmilia1]

At WR

Julio
AB
Fitz

TE

Gates
Gronk

RB

AP
Gore


Lots and lots of young guys at each skill position I think have great shots