Andy Dalton is one of the greatest quarterbacks of all time and should be given serious consideration for the HOF upon retirement

[Battlelyon]

100% and not have Montana in top 2, shows enough

I stopped looking after 30 and Montana wasn't there, seriously?

 

[Schmoopy1000]

Taylor Heinicke is #52!

(I think we all agree that Joe Montana, John Elway and Johnny Unitas are overrated and correctly don't make the top 100. They were all about passes and yards and wins and championships. I'm glad this list recognizes true greatness like #32 Steve DeBerg.)

Poor Steve DeBerg. He was doomed.

Drafted by the Cowboys (had Staubach)
went to the Niners (who drafted Joe Montana)
then went to the Broncos (who drafted John Elway)
then went to the Buccs (who drafted Steve Young)
then went to KC where he did have a couple good years (still remember him playing with a pin sticking out of his pinky)
Then played with Miami who had an injured Dan Marino (the man seen a lot of great QBs)
Even was brought back like 5 years later to back up the Falcons (how the fuck does that happen)

 

[Battlelyon]

All their rankings are terrible, imagine not putting Eric Dickerson in the top 5 of runningbacks.

Top 5

1. Jim Brown
2. Barry Sanders
3. Walter Payton
4. Emmitt Smith
5. Eric Dickerson

 

[Battlelyon]

Their top 10 players of all time

1. L.T.
2. Deion Sanders
3. Barry Sanders
4. Tom Brady
5. Bo Jackson
6. Jerry Rice
7. Randy Moss
8. Jim Brown
9. Walter Payton
10. Joe Greene

 

[Robotech]

Their top 10 players of all time

1. L.T.
2. Deion Sanders
3. Barry Sanders
4. Tom Brady
5. Bo Jackson
6. Jerry Rice
7. Randy Moss
8. Jim Brown
9. Walter Payton
10. Joe Greene

Bo Jackson being number 5 is super silly. All of the other players are legit great, though. However, Reggie White needs to be up there! And Andy Dalton should probably be like number 11. LOL.

 

[Balljim55]

you could start a new Hall of fame with QBs that are not on the list
no Joe Montana
no Drew Breese
no Terry Bradshaw
etc
etc

 

[Battlelyon]

Bo Jackson being number 5 is super silly. All of the other players are legit great, though. However, Reggie White needs to be up there! And Andy Dalton should probably be like number 11. LOL.

Idk some people believe Bo should be in the Hall of Fame, those people are morons, of course.

 

[DJ Fieri]

Just wow.

 

[Robotech]

Idk some people believe Bo should be in the Hall of Fame, those people are morons, of course.

Must be people who think that Bo's performance in Tecmo Bowl should count.

 

[Battlelyon]

Must be people who think that Bo's performance in Tecmo Bowl should count.

He has had 8 games of 100+ yards rushing, and 5 games at least 2 TDs. He was good player whose career was cut short, but hardly on pace for a hall of fame career.

 

[mrschaney]

I meant to post this here:

Why are some of you so hung up on playoffs? Like this should be the only consideration? I don't hear this argument concerning other positions?? This is unfair. If it is to apply to quarterbacks, then we should go ahead and just redo the qualifications to the HOF.
Qualification 1 should be ALL players to be inducted into the HOF must have won at least a Playoff game and apply this to all positions. Other than playoff record, Andy's stats compare favorably or are better than many Hall of Famers. Namath, Baugh, the list could go on.

 

[sonnyblack65]

I have Dalton in the top 64 QB's playing today

 

[PnkPanther]

I meant to post this here:

Why are some of you so hung up on playoffs? Like this should be the only consideration? I don't hear this argument concerning other positions?? This is unfair. If it is to apply to quarterbacks, then we should go ahead and just redo the qualifications to the HOF.
Qualification 1 should be ALL players to be inducted into the HOF must have won at least a Playoff game and apply this to all positions. Other than playoff record, Andy's stats compare favorably or are better than many Hall of Famers. Namath, Baugh, the list could go on.

You can't compare numbers between era's


I'm not sure if you're being serious tbh or if this is just funny bit gone on too long

Dalton will never sniff the HOF

 

[ArlingtonCowboys100]

Lol, Dalton possibly is an average QB HOF?

 

[Schmoopy1000]

Lol, Dalton possibly is an average QB HOF?

Oh! Dalton is getting in.
Its just after Bob Avellini does!

 

[PDay8810]

I meant to post this here:

Andy's stats compare favorably or are better than many Hall of Famers. Namath, Baugh, the list could go on.

ditto
Compare Romo's stats next, he doesn't belong in the hall either

 

[PDay8810]

Lol, Dalton possibly is an average QB HOF?

I'd go with "Almost" and call it a day

 

[redseat]

Most valuable Ginger.



I'll give him that honor

 

[rmilia1]

100% and not have Montana in top 2, shows enough

I quit reading when Rodgers was 2

 

[sonnyblack65]

0-4 in playoffs only 1td to 6int HOS for sure Shame shame shame