7 HOF, CY or MVP Players MLB Draft QF2 : Milk vs Shane

[Nosferatu]

MILK

LINEUP vs RHSP
1. Kenny Lofton (L) - CF
2. *Ted Williams (L) - LF
3. *Mike Schmidt (R) - 3B
4. *Reggie Jackson (L) - RF
5. *Yogi Berra (L) - C
6. Fred McGriff (L) - 1B
7. *Ernie Banks (R) - SS
8. Al Oliver (L) - DH
9. Buddy Myer (L) - 2B

LINEUP vs LHSP
1. Chuck Knoblauch (R) - 2B
2. *Ted Williams (L) - LF :
3. *Mike Schmidt (R) - 3B
4. Mark McGwire (R) - 1B
5.*Ernie Banks (R) - SS
6. Bob Johnson (R) - DH
7. *Yogi Berra (L) - C
8. Dwight Evans (R) - RF
9. Wally Berger (R) - CF

ROTATION
1. *Pedro Martinez (R)
2. *Carl Hubbell (L)
3. Kevin Brown (R)
4. Hippo Vaughn (L)
5. Urban Shocker (R)

BULLPEN
Joe Nathan (R)
John Hiller (L)
Doug Jones (R)
Billy O'Dell (L)
Roy Face (R)

VS

SHANE

LINEUP vs RHSP
1. *Tris Speaker (L) - CF
2. *Rogers Hornsby (R) - 2B
3. Manny Ramirez (R) - DH
4. *Willie McCovey (L) - 1B
5. *Johnny Bench (R) - C
6. Lance Berkman (B) - RF
7. Charlie Keller (L) - LF
8. Robin Ventura (L) - 3B
9. Omar Vizquel (B) - SS

LINEUP vs LHSP
1. *Tris Speaker (L) - CF
2. *Rogers Hornsby (R) - 2B
3. Manny Ramirez (R) - DH
4. *Jeff Bagwell (R) - 1B
5. *Johnny Bench (R) - C
6. Tim Salmon (R) - RF
7. Troy Glaus (R) - 3B
8. Minnie Minoso (R) - LF
9. John Valentin (R) - SS

ROTATION
1. *Randy Johnson (L)
2. *Warren Spahn (L)
3. Smoky Joe Wood (R)
4. Billy Pierce (L)
5. Ed Reulbach (R)

BULLPEN
Ron Perranoski (L)
Gary Lavelle (L)
Jeff Montgomery (R)
Firpo Marberry (R)
Roberto Hernandez (R)

 

[Nosferatu]

MILK - 5
SHANE - 6

VOTED - UK, Shane, Ritzy, Milk, Ducey, Mookie, Femur, Stakes, 500, Sushi, Hall

Race to 6

 

[UK Cowboy]

Shane

 

[Shanemansj13]

I have edge in rotation and lineup slightly. He has edge in BP, pretty easily.

I got me

 

[Ritzarmy]

Shane

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I have edge in rotation and lineup slightly. He has edge in BP, pretty easily.

I got me

i disagree with everything you wrote... and think my team is better all around...

 

[Nosferatu]

i disagree with everything you wrote... and think my team is better all around...

You think his pen is better?

 

[MilkSpiller22]

You think his pen is better?

except for that... But i said i am better all around, so that encompassed that...

 

[Nosferatu]

except for that... But i said i am better all around, so that encompassed that...

Nope

 

[Shanemansj13]

i disagree with everything you wrote... and think my team is better all around...

I said your pen was much better...

 

[Shanemansj13]

If there is a huge knock on my team it is the pen. They went quick and only having 2 HOF pitchers is tough bc most of the great RP’s were in the HOF

 

[Mookie]

I'll go Milk. Coin flip

 

[Shanemansj13]

i disagree with everything you wrote... and think my team is better all around...

So your rotation is better???

 

[MilkSpiller22]

So your rotation is better???

I think it is close... But i like my non HOFers better... Kevin Brown, i thought was the second best Non HOFer/MVP in this mock next to schilling...

But yea, i would take your HOFer SPs over mine... But i think it hurts having both being lefties.. Moreso, i think Having 2 HOFer Lefties plus Pierce is just too much lefty going on... its like phil mickelson had a baby...

 

[Shanemansj13]

I think it is close... But i like my non HOFers better... Kevin Brown, i thought was the second best Non HOFer/MVP in this mock next to schilling...

But yea, i would take your HOFer SPs over mine... But i think it hurts having both being lefties.. Moreso, i think Having 2 HOFer Lefties plus Pierce is just too much lefty going on... its like phil mickelson had a baby...

Nah it is still balanced, whether it is 3 lefties or 2 lefties. Not a big deal.

I think what hurts you is having so many SO guys in the middle of your orders. Like top SO guys ever. That’s part of the reason I like my lineup more plus having my edge with my rotation also gives me an edge. Eithee way it’s close.

Smokey Joe is no slouch as well.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Nah it is still balanced, whether it is 3 lefties or 2 lefties. Not a big deal.

I think what hurts you is having so many SO guys in the middle of your orders. Like top SO guys ever. That’s part of the reason I like my lineup more plus having my edge with my rotation also gives me an edge. Eithee way it’s close.

Smokey Joe is no slouch as well.

he gets over-rated around here based on his career numbers... But he had a short career, only had 200+ innings twice in his career... and pitched when everyone had an ERA below 2.5...


and sure my 3-4 hitters are strike out kings... but they are also legit 3-4 hitters...

 

[tducey]

Milk

 

[Shanemansj13]

he gets over-rated around here based on his career numbers... But he had a short career, only had 200+ innings twice in his career... and pitched when everyone had an ERA below 2.5...


and sure my 3-4 hitters are strike out kings... but they are also legit 3-4 hitters...

Reggie and Yogi have always been overrated imo. You definitely have some pop in your lineups just a lot of swing and miss guys

 

[femurov]

Shane

 

[Stakesarehigh]

Shane