saddles
No More "Bullpen Failure"
I was only using Scherzer as an example, not that we would specifically trade Elvis and then use that exact amount of money to sign Scherzer. But for Elvis money + a little extra we could absolutely sign a top 2 caliber starter.
As for the whole "can't take a gamble on Profar" reasoning, there are other SS out there who could play the position for us at a fraction of the cost of Elvis should Profar not pan out. There are several from just last season alone who had better numbers than Elvis at a far lower salary hit. Look at the offensive and defensive numbers and then tell me that Elvis is worth tens of millions more than a Brandon Crawford or a Kolten Wong or even a Jed Lowrie.
If it is that easy to find a good SS then does that mean the Rangers philosophy of loading up on middle infielder prospects due to their being valuable is a bad philosophy? Why don't the Dodgers simply go get one of those guys if they are better options than Elvis?
We have tried throwing money at top 2 pitchers before and we haven't had success.