2013 Shanaban thread

[dash]

That looked like it Hertl...

 

[puckhead]

so we're all agreed that Brown is a piece of shit?

 

[Cobiemonster]

That looked like it Hertl...

Tomas should have jumped over a Hertl to avoid Dustin Brown's knee

 

[davnlaguna]

adding video
[youtube]Ib-_2joEe4c[/youtube]

 

[sabresfaninthesouth]

That won't earn him a Shanaban, but it should.

Honestly, can anyone tell me the last time someone got a Shanaban (or a ... Campaban ) for a knee?

 

[forty_three]

so we're all agreed that Brown is a piece of shit?

Obviously

 

[KennyBanyeah]

That won't earn him a Shanaban, but it should.

Honestly, can anyone tell me the last time someone got a Shanaban (or a ... Campaban ) for a knee?

 

[sabresfaninthesouth]

Two things:

1) Touche

2) I think you know what I meant

 

[sabresfaninthesouth]

Hertl looking to be out a month or more:
Report: Sharks' Hertl out for a month or more with injury

I'm sure no Shanaban will be forthcoming despite this being at least the third knee that Brown has thrown in a year and a half.

 

[KennyBanyeah]

Two things:

1) Touche

2) I think you know what I meant

Ted.... I was fucking with you!!

 

[forty_three]

Columbus Blue Jackets' Derek MacKenzie to have hearing Friday - Department of Player Safety News

DMac gets a hearing for knocking the stuffing out of Oliver Ekman-Larsson. No penalty in game, but those refs missed a lot last night

So, who do the Jackets call up to replace him for 5+ games?

 

[mattola]

i think its just a phone hearing Elliot Friedman corrected his tweet saying its phone only

Columbus Blue Jackets' Derek MacKenzie to have hearing Friday - Department of Player Safety News

DMac gets a hearing for knocking the stuffing out of Oliver Ekman-Larsson. No penalty in game, but those refs missed a lot last night

So, who do the Jackets call up to replace him for 5+ games?

 

[forty_three]

i think its just a phone hearing Elliot Friedman corrected his tweet saying its phone only

Yeah, I saw that after I first posted and edited it.

So who replaces him for 3 games? He took out a budding star in the desert.

Oh wait, that's right. The league doesn't own them anymore.

 

[dash]

Not sure it was posted, but Lupul is having an hearing today for his cross-check to the face of Eaves in the Winter Classic.

 

[mattola]

Yeah, I saw that after I first posted and edited it.

So who replaces him for 3 games? He took out a budding star in the desert.

Oh wait, that's right. The league doesn't own them anymore.

is he a repeat offender? 2 seems worthy of that if not

Not sure it was posted, but Lupul is having an hearing today for his cross-check to the face of Eaves in the Winter Classic.

he is now a repeat from last year? should be 4 games

 

[sabresfaninthesouth]

If someone gets a Shanaban that would carry into the timing of the Olympics, do you think the IIHF hono(u)rs that and bans them from the tournament?

Conversely, if someone gets an Olympiban (I'm just making up words as I go here) that carries past the end of the tournament (*ahem* Dustin Brown, I'm looking in the direction of your knees and elbows), do you think the NHL accepts the remainder of the ban?

 

[jstewismybastardson]

If someone gets a Shanaban that would carry into the timing of the Olympics, do you think the IIHF hono(u)rs that and bans them from the tournament?

Conversely, if someone gets an Olympiban (I'm just making up words as I go here) that carries past the end of the tournament (*ahem* Dustin Brown, I'm looking in the direction of your knees and elbows), do you think the NHL accepts the remainder of the ban?

Im saying no to either ... Edler got suspended at the iihf worlds last season for his zombie knee on Eric Staal and it had no bearing in the NHL

 

[sabresfaninthesouth]

Im saying no to either ... Edler got suspended at the iihf worlds last season for his zombie knee on Eric Staal and it had no bearing in the NHL

I see the World's differently though since they're after the season. When it happens in-season and the league is taking a break for this, who knows.

I guess it would depend on severity perhaps. There is precedent for the IIHF honoring an NHL suspension, but the one that comes to mind was Bertuzzi, which was a much different class of incident.

 

[jstewismybastardson]

I see the World's differently though since they're after the season. When it happens in-season and the league is taking a break for this, who knows.

I guess it would depend on severity perhaps. There is precedent for the IIHF honoring an NHL suspension, but the one that comes to mind was Bertuzzi, which was a much different class of incident.

NHL playoffs were going on ...

i dunno ... i seem to remember Chris Simons skate stomp suspension wasnt hono(u)red by the KHL ... but thats Russia lol

 

[pixburgher66]

From a legal standpoint, I don't see how suspensions could carry over to either league...seems like they'd just get a headache of issues from that.