POLL Worst Division for QB's

[Mike A. S.]

Which division has the worst group of starting QB's right now? If someone is out for injury, then count the original starter. So count Garoppolo for Niners, Tannehill for Dolphins, etc. Also, not counting players entire career for this poll, so 2018 Eli Manning is all that matters here, not 2004-2017 Eli, etc.

 

[Iggloo]

Tough one. Seems all have a few good QBs and a few bad ones.

 

[FaCe-LeE-uS]

AFCS or AFCE

 

[Rock Strongo]

tie between the AFC east and NFC east

NFC:
Eli
Smith
Dak
one good one in wentz

AFC:
osweiller/tannehill
darnold
allen/peterman/anderson
one good one in brady

 

[rmilia1]

Currently or for their careers ?

 

[dbldwn711]

tie between the AFC east and NFC east

NFC:
Eli
Smith
Dak
one good one in wentz

AFC:
osweiller/tannehill
darnold
allen/peterman/anderson
one good one in brady

“Did you just call Wentz “good”? TROLL... he’s phenomenal!!!”

- unidentified SH poster

 

[SteelersPride]

Nfc east or afc east

 

[Mike A. S.]

Currently or for their careers ?

I specified in the initial post that it is only for right now, not their careers.

 

[CaptainStubing]

i'm not sure how it could be any other than the AFC East ... 3 of the 4 teams are getting poor/horrible QB play ...

 

[CaptainStubing]

i'm surprised people are voting NFCE over AFCE

Wentz isn't as good as Brady but ...
Smith is better than Osweiler/Tannehill
Dak is better than Darnold
Eli is better than Peterman/Allen

 

[CaptainStubing]

AFCS or AFCE

AFC South? With Watson and Luck? and Mariota isn't awful?

 

[Yo Tee]

Man this is hard.

The AFC East is saved by Tom Brady. The AFC North is saved by Big Ben. The AFC West right now looks really good between Mahomes and Rivers. AFC South has Watson, but Mariota, Bortles and Luck look like crap.

The NFC West has Goff and Wilson, NFC South is probably the best in the league for QBs, NFC North is saved by Aaron Rodgers, NFC East has Foles/Wentz.

I'd say its down to the NFC East and AFC South. For me, it's the AFC South. Bortles is shit, Luck isn't the same as he was, Mariota is hot and cold depending on the defense he plays.

 

[rmilia1]

I specified in the initial post that it is only for right now, not their careers.

My bad .

Right now I'd go

AFC East - only division with 1 above average QB

 

[CaptainStubing]

Man this is hard.

The AFC East is saved by Tom Brady. The AFC North is saved by Big Ben. The AFC West right now looks really good between Mahomes and Rivers. AFC South has Watson, but Mariota, Bortles and Luck look like crap.

The NFC West has Goff and Wilson, NFC South is probably the best in the league for QBs, NFC North is saved by Aaron Rodgers, NFC East has Foles/Wentz.

I'd say its down to the NFC East and AFC South. For me, it's the AFC South. Bortles is shit, Luck isn't the same as he was, Mariota is hot and cold depending on the defense he plays.

Luck looks like crap? huh? he's carrying that team on his shoulders right now IMO ...

 

[Yo Tee]

Luck looks like crap? huh? he's carrying that team on his shoulders right now IMO ...

He's carrying that team on a shoulder that isn't good enough to throw a hail mary pass. He isn't 2014 Andrew Luck. 5 INTs in the last 4 games. Most of the problem is his WRs, but he's not making the best decisions either.

 

[CaptainStubing]

He's carrying that team on a shoulder that isn't good enough to throw a hail mary pass. He isn't 2014 Andrew Luck. 5 INTs in the last 4 games. Most of the problem is his WRs, but he's not making the best decisions either.

wow, i think he's looked pretty good recently all things considered. i think the first few weeks, he was knocking some rust off but the last couple of weeks, albeit against inferior competition, he's starting to look like the old Luck.

I guess we will see how the rest of the season plays out.

 

[molsaniceman]

wow, i think he's looked pretty good recently all things considered. i think the first few weeks, he was knocking some rust off but the last couple of weeks, albeit against inferior competition, he's starting to look like the old Luck.

I guess we will see how the rest of the season plays out.

looks good to me

 

[RP-29]

1) NFCS - Brees, Ryan, Newton, Fitzpatrick
2) NFCN - Rodgers, Stafford, Cousins, Trubisky
3) AFCW - Mahomes, Rivers, Carr, Keenum
4) NFCW - Wilson, Goff, Garoppolo, Rosen
5) AFCN - Roethlisberger, Dalton, Flacco, Mayfield
6) AFCS - Luck, Watson, Mariota, Bortles
7) NFCE - Wentz, Smith, Prescott, Manning
8) AFCE - Brady, Tannehill, Darnold, Allen

 

[rmilia1]

Another interesting debate is which division has the best QBS.

The NFC South has 2 guys performing at MVP level, another former MVP playing well and a guy on the top 5 for QBR

AFC West also has 2 guys performing at MVP level

AFC North has played well this year as well

 

[Used 2 B Hu]

It's the AFC East by a mile:

Shit QB
Shit QB
Shit QB
Sam Darnold