Why is McCaffery going to New York?

[Tubbs1518]

A comparison vs two top tier defenses in the nation, Its also the only comparison you can make between the 2 using top 25 defenses. Otherwise Henrys resume takes another nmassive jump over McCaffery. He played more top 25s too. in different conference. Makes A lot more sense than claiming Henry isn't on a whole other level from McCaffery. SEC defenses and PAC defenses are not even comparable. If that was the list of top defenses Biever faced than SC was awful this year

They aren't comparable because PAC offenses and SEC offenses aren't comparable. The like 7th PAC offense would be the best SEC offense.

 

[Tubbs1518]

They have no argument, they just laugh. I wouldnt take Bambino too serious, he is a joke.

Oh I take him absolutely 0 seriously.

 

[TheRobotDevil]

The Heisman isn't given to the best player in college football. It's very much a team award and is greatly impacted by things such as media hype, your teammates and other factors outside of how good you really are. He was invited to New York, because he is a contender for the Heisman when all of these things are factored in.

I agree a big part of the reason he is there is media and campaigns. IMO schools shouldn't be able to campaign. Put it on the field. Not in the stanford tech lab. Let them get back to doing something productive and direct some frogs or something

 

[Tubbs1518]

in this scenario putting fournette in the PAC and he triples barry sanders all purpose yards record

Except he wouldn't because he doesn't catch the ball nearly as well and wouldn't return kickoffs or punts. McCaffrey is a team first guy who does everything for his team.

 

[TheRobotDevil]

They aren't comparable because PAC offenses and SEC offenses aren't comparable. The like 7th PAC offense would be the best SEC offense.

The only legit comparison is to remove the PAC and SEC and use an outside comparison. And that is why the BIG defense comparison is the most telling of the stats

 

[Tubbs1518]

The only legit comparison is to remove the PAC and SEC and use an outside comparison. And that is why the BIG defense comparison is the most telling of the stats

Except it isn't because it is 2 different teams, so there really isn't a comparison. Also if PAC defenses are so bad, why hasn't anyone else even came close to Sanders record? McCaffrey is clearly the best player in the PAC then right?

 

[Bamabino]

They have no argument, they just laugh. I wouldnt take Bambino too serious, he is a joke.

The joke was "Henry doesn't belong there." It flew over your head like deer on a buckeye.

 

[TheRobotDevil]

Except he wouldn't because he doesn't catch the ball nearly as well and wouldn't return kickoffs or punts. McCaffrey is a team first guy who does everything for his team.

In this scenario Adoree Jackson should win the heisman. He' would have shattered barry sanders record. But he's so team first he gave up the bulk of his offensive reps to play defense

 

[Tubbs1518]

The joke was "Henry doesn't belong there." It flew over your head like deer on a buckeye.

Henry isn't the best back in the SEC. Why should he be there?

 

[TheRobotDevil]

Except it isn't because it is 2 different teams, so there really isn't a comparison. Also if PAC defenses are so bad, why hasn't anyone else even came close to Sanders record? McCaffrey is clearly the best player in the PAC then right?

two teams in the top 11. And if anything it favors Henry on behalf of he played the stronger defense of the 2. Best comparison by far

 

[uncfan103]

The only legit comparison is to remove the PAC and SEC and use an outside comparison. And that is why the BIG defense comparison is the most telling of the stats

Elijah Hood should probably win the Heisman since he did so good against big ten defenses lol

 

[Tubbs1518]

two teams in the top 11. And if anything it favors Henry on behalf of he played the stronger defense of the 2. Best comparison by far

Ecxept McCaffrey did just as well on a per touch bases as Henry did against top 50 defenses.

 

[TheRobotDevil]

Elijah Hood should probably win the Heisman since he did so good against big ten defenses lol

True true he should also be there ahead of McOverated and Hood was great in the Lord of the rings

 

[TheRobotDevil]

Ecxept McCaffrey did just as well on a per touch bases as Henry did against top 50 defenses.

Im going to have to deny those stats PAC defenses are fictional. They don't actually exist

 

[Tubbs1518]

Im going to have to deny those stats PAC defenses are fictional. They don't actually exist

Rotoworld posted it. Pretty sure it's true.

 

[TexasExes98]

Always keeping the white man down........

 

[uncfan103]

Im going to have to deny those stats PAC defenses are fictional. They don't actually exist

All we know is that the defenses perform better in the SEC and offenses perform better in the PAC. We know quarterback play is better in the PAC. What we don't know is if offenses and quarterbacks are good in the PAC because defenses suck or if the defense is good in the SEC because the SEC offenses are no good.

 

[TheDayMan]

In conclusion, it will be a travesty when McCaffrey is not awarded the heisman trophy.

End thread.

 

[TheRobotDevil]

Rotoworld posted it. Pretty sure it's true.

PAC tackling belongs on ghost hunters. The hobbit Elijah hood would have put up the same numbers. Anyone could have you seen the PAC defenses?They're non existent. Pretty sure I saw a poultrygeist playing linebacker for SC this year but my thermal goggles were broken. McCaffery is a poor mans Toby Gerhart.

 

[7Samurai13]

In this scenario Adoree Jackson should win the heisman. He' would have shattered barry sanders record. But he's so team first he gave up the bulk of his offensive reps to play defense

Fuck, I got tricked into another scenario thread.