What do you think of this trade?

[ArnoldSwartzanegro]

Standard Scoring (Except 6 pts for passing tds)
Team A gives
Trent Richardson
Larry Fitzgerald

Team B gives
Jamaal Charles
Vincent Jackson

Team A:
RB: Marshawn Lynch, Trent Richardson, Lamar Miller, David Wilson, Eddie Lacy
WR: Calvin Johnson, Larry Fitzgerald, Victor Cruz, Pierre Garcon, Roddy White, Josh Gordon

Team B:
RB: Jamaal Charles, Stevan Ridley, Bilal Powell, Ahmad Bradshaw, Joique Bell, Fred Jackson
WR: Andre Johnson, Marques Colston, Vincent Jackson, Kembrell Thompkins, Brian Hartline.

 

[Sox33OSU]

Any time you can get a guy like Jamaal Charles and only have to give up an RBBC back and an inconsistent WR, jump all over it.

 

[tlance]

You guys are way too low on TRich. I like the Charles side of this deal, but it is close. TRich will be a top 6 RB ROS. Charles is top 3 though.

 

[wilwhite]

TRich will be a top 6 RB ROS.

Ooh... I'm on the anti-TRich bandwagon. Gentlemen's bet, Tlance?

 

[Sox33OSU]

You guys are way too low on TRich. I like the Charles side of this deal, but it is close. TRich will be a top 6 RB ROS. Charles is top 3 though.

I truly don't see anything that would say he is a top 6 ROS player. This last week he faced Jacksonville with no Bradshaw and he produced 12 points with a 3.0 YPC. There are well over 6 RBs I'd take ROS than him.

 

[The Foot]

Yea I think it's time to realize that maybe Cleveland knows a thing or two about how to evaluate RBs. Let's not forget that the great Jim Brown was not impressed with Trich going back to last year.

 

[JDM]

B wins easy. Fantasy wise I take Jackson over Fitz, too, even though Fitz is the best receiver in the NFL.

 

[Sox33OSU]

B wins easy. Fantasy wise I take Jackson over Fitz, too, even though Fitz is the 8th or 9th best receiver in the NFL.

 

[JDM]

No. He is the best. The only one in the conversation is Calvin.

 

[Stomp]

B wins easy. Fantasy wise I take Jackson over Fitz, too, even though Fitz is the best receiver in the NFL.

I think its the other way around I think Team A is getting Charles and Jackson I could be wrong though

 

[Sox33OSU]

No. He is the best. The only one in the conversation is Calvin.

Not trying to start a war here, but do you really think anyone in the league would take Fitz right now over Julio, AJ Green, or Demaryius Thomas, let alone Calvin? I know he hasn't had a great QB recently but he's just been totally off the radar. Hell, last season we saw Josh Gordon and Justin Blackmon put up better numbers than Fitz and they both had pathetic QBs, too.

 

[SmokingMonkey]

let's get this back on track - if you are Team A DO THIS DEAL IMMEDIATELY!!!

after the deal, team A's lineup would be:
Lynch/Charles starting with Miller, Lacy, and Wilson backing up
Calvin, Garcon, Cruz, with VJax, Roddy, Gordon backing up

WOW, looks like a juggernaut if Ive ever seen one

 

[Jonas_steven]

Eric decker for...

Sorry, I meant to start a new thread. Carry on...