cdumler7
Well-Known Member
The rookie QB contracts are a really nice perk but I don't think teams are picking these guys just because they are on the cheap. If any of the top guys in the league right now hit the market these teams picking these QBs in the draft would be falling over themselves to sign those guys rather than draft a rookie QB.
It just boils down to if you want long term success you need a top guy and the rewards for hitting that lotto ticket in the draft make teams keep playing. The odds are terrible which is why teams clamor to get ahead of everyone else to increase the odds that they do hit on a QB because the more talented the guy is the more likely you are to get a top guy.
Because if you do land your guy and he turns out to be elite you have him for cheap initially but beyond that you're a perennial playoff team and you're set at the position for the next 15ish years. Patrick Mahomes will turn 26 later this year so the Chiefs probably won't start to worry about their QB position until the year 2033 and in the meantime they'll likely win the division or be at least a wildcard team for that timespan. Brady, Peyton Manning, Brees, Big Ben, Wilson, and Rodgers have had their teams in the playoffs for most of the seasons they've been at the helm.
Teams and GMs know the odds are bad but you've gotta keep those slots spinning until they land on 777.
My nightmare situation is using a midround pick on a QB that ends up being an above average talent at the position. Those guys still get paid huge money, but what they do is keep a GM/Coach at that spot where they don't want to take a risk and stick with mediocrity. The Andy Daltons and Derek Carr's of the world. Decent QB's, but the odds of them getting you over the top are very slim and somehow a team sticks with them for like 10 years before they figure out it isn't working.