- Thread starter
- #2,161
saddles
No More "Bullpen Failure"
You are giving Heaney 126 starts to judge his talent and you are mainly going on the last 14 of them. Give those other three pitchers longer and see what kind of adjustments they can make before comparing talent levels.None of those 3 pitchers have the talent that Heaney does.
Heaney would easily out pitch Ragans to begin 2023, but who knows how much better Ragans will be before Heaney gets half way through a three of 4 year contract. Not saying he gets better, but usually guys pitch better with a few dozen starts under their belt. Who knows how much better he gets.?
I would rather go with either Dunning or Otto to begin 2023 than give Heaney a multiyear deal. I say that not even expecting those two to stay in our rotation more than another year or so even if they were given a chance to begin 2023 in the rotation. We have better guys coming behind them fairly soon.
Again, long term, I am hoping to not to have to depend on either of the three simply because I hope our guys coming up surpass them.