Soon to be Hall of Famer - Eli Manning

[NEPatsfan]

So you have a problem with every QB that plays well vs the Pats?

This is a shocking development

No, and clearly your reading comp sucks ass.

Flacco is 3-6 vs the Pats, so you should probably read up a bit more before willfully looking dumb.

 

[NEPatsfan]

I'd still say Rivers is above average, although I'm not gonna pull up stats of all the top QB's and make comparisons. He's had some great seasons like 2013 and some stinkers like this season(even with the 33 TD's).

Put Rivers on those two SB winning Giants teams and Rivers has 2 SB titles.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

I'd still say Rivers is above average, although I'm not gonna pull up stats of all the top QB's and make comparisons. He's had some great seasons like 2013 and some stinkers like this season(even with the 33 TD's).

Eli would be getting slaughtered in this city, and most likely long gone if not for the 2 rings, I dont even love the guy as a QB

But what he delivered twice to this city, gives him a free pass for life, and combined with what will be some historic numbers when his career is over, will put him in the HOF

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Put Rivers on those two SB winning Giants teams and Rivers has 2 SB titles.

Swap Drew Brees and Tom Brady and the Saints are 13 time AFC East champs, Brees is a 10 time MVP and 5 time SB champ

Thats just Brees, we can do that with a lot of good QB;s

 

[BrockForBroglio]

Interesting.

E. Manning,

View attachment 153213


Every year except the 1st on he was double digit in INT's. Some years over 20...wow

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Eli Manning is the perfect example why winning 2 Super Bowls doesn't mean you are Hall of Fame quality.

Like all the other examples

 

[NEPatsfan]

Take a deep breath and a bit of a walk

For what? I'm as cool as a cucumber in a bowl of hot sauce.

You seem to be losing it, all over a sports player.

Spend less time living vicariously through little Peyton, you find your blood pressure will go down.

 

[Bolts]

Put Rivers on those two SB winning Giants teams and Rivers has 2 SB titles.

Probably, being out of the SD sports curse would have greatly helped his chances.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

For what? I'm as cool as a cucumber in a bowl of hot sauce.

You seem to be losing it, all over a sports player.

Spend less time living vicariously through little Peyton, you find your blood pressure will go down.

"Vicariously living through"

LOL

New Material

 

[BrockForBroglio]

Meant to say....every year except his 1st he was double digit in INT's, and some years 20+...wow

 

[NEPatsfan]

Eli would be getting slaughtered in this city, and most likely long gone if not for the 2 rings, I dont even love the guy as a QB

But what he delivered twice to this city, gives him a free pass for life, and combined with what will be some historic numbers when his career is over, will put him in the HOF

Historic? He's more than halfway down the list.

 

[CowboyB]

Like all the other examples

That's what makes him perfect. The first. It would be great if he set the standard but I am sure they will water down Canton with his bust because of his last name and rings his D-Line and a fluke catch won him.

 

[NEPatsfan]

"Vicariously living through"

LOL

New Material

It's clearly what you do. It's unhealthy.

Me, I just enjoy the game win or loose.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Historic? He's more than halfway down the list.

Id say anyone in the Top 10 all time in passing yards is pretty historic, and he will be passing Elway and will probably land in 6th all time

As a matter of fact, the only guy in the Top 10 you have OUT of the HOF, is Eli Manning

Whether you like it or not, and you dont seem to like it, voters will not keep him out when you combine that with 2 SB MVP's

 

[Bolts]

Eli would be getting slaughtered in this city, and most likely long gone if not for the 2 rings, I dont even love the guy as a QB

But what he delivered twice to this city, gives him a free pass for life, and combined with what will be some historic numbers when his career is over, will put him in the HOF

Winning 2 SB's and getting named MVP twice will give you a chance at HOF. And although he's got some good overall numbers, if he got in because of them it's more like being rewarded for participation. He was able to stay healthy so even if the game to game stats aren't great they look better when you add them up. After seeing the # of key guys go down for the Chargers this year and in recent years, being able to stay on the field is very fucking important.

 

[NEPatsfan]

Id say anyone in the Top 10 all time in passing yards is pretty historic, and he will be passing Elway and will probably land in 6th all time

As a matter of fact, the only guy in the Top 10 you have OUT of the HOF, is Eli Manning

Whether you like it or not, and you dont seem to like it, voters will not keep him out when you combine that with 2 SB MVP's

Water down the Hall of Fame away!

He's mediocre at best, with flashes of greatness.

He's meh.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

It's clearly what you do. It's unhealthy.

Me, I just enjoy the game win or loose.

Yeah, you just enjoy the games

We believe you

 

[CowboyB]

It's clearly what you do. It's unhealthy.

Me, I just enjoy the game win or loose.

Dirt's emotions aren't just correlated to Yankees and Giants success and failures.

 

[NEPatsfan]

Yeah, you just enjoy the games

We believe you

I don't care if you do.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Water down the Hall of Fame away!

He's mediocre at best, with flashes of greatness.

He's meh.

Tom Brady has one SB win in the past 13 years, and it took the worst play call in the history of the NFL, literally

And you have him as the GOAT

So none of us are perfect