Soon to be Hall of Famer - Eli Manning

[DirtDirtDirt]

Brady is greater than Eli, it's simply a fact. You're starting to look less manly and more like a cry baby.

Not when it counts, he's not

 

[DJ Fieri]

Jim Plunkett has 23,000 less passing yards and almost 200 less career TD's than Eli Manning

Again a different era.

 

[sonnyblack65]

Brady, Eli. Ryan and Rivers would thrive in the old era because they are the only 4 that would survive and in top 10 of consecutive starts. Most of today's QB's would be injured and out in no time, poor Jimmy G lasted 6 Q's. Now some guys like Wilson , time will tell

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Again a different era.

LMAO, thats some funny stuff

 

[NEPatsfan]

Eli Manning absolutely owns Tom Brady when it matters most

You can cry all you want dude, only idiots in this place dont know what your entire agenda is here

Youll get over it one day

How so? You realize they don't play each other right? Do you even watch football?

You are really starting to look like a petulant child. Maybe try living less vicariously through a sports team?

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Brady, Eli and Rivers would thrive in the old era because they are the only 3 that would survive and in top 10 of consecutive starts. Most of today's QB's would be injured and out in no time, poor Jimmy G lasted 6 QB's. Now some guys like Wilson and Ryan, time will tell

Eli never missed a game in his career, you have to be a special brand of stupid to question how he would "tough it out" in a previous era

 

[NEPatsfan]

Not when it counts, he's not

And he will go down as the G.O.A.T., little Peyton, not so much.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

How so? You realize they don't play each other right? Do you even watch football?

You are really starting to look like a petulant child. Maybe try living less vicariously through a sports team?

Yeah, youre on a roll

- Washington had nothing to play for yesterday
- Trent Dilfer has the same career as Eli Manning
- a QB that has never missed a start would have a tough time staying healthy in a previous era


Keep going

 

[NEPatsfan]

Eli never missed a game in his career, you have to be a special brand of stupid to question how he would "tough it out" in a previous era

Hard to say, but he likely would have numerous injuries. The QB was a bit more fair game back then.

 

[DJ Fieri]

It's a special brand of stupid when you're comparing a QB from the 1970's and early to mid 1980's to one who played from 2004 to the present and are using passing TD's as your main argument.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

And he will go down as the G.O.A.T., little Peyton, not so much.

Little and Big Peyton love ending his seasons

 

[sonnyblack65]

Eli never missed a game in his career, you have to be a special brand of stupid to question how he would "tough it out" in a previous era

I had to add Ryan to that list he is in top 10 too Eli, Rivers, Ryan and Brady twice

 

[NEPatsfan]

Yeah, youre on a roll

- Washington had nothing to play for yesterday
- Trent Dilfer has the same career as Eli Manning
- a QB that has never missed a start would have a tough time staying healthy in a previous era


Keep going

Umm are you responding to the correct poster? I never said any of those things.

 

[NEPatsfan]

Little and Big Peyton love ending his seasons

And they will go down as lesser QBs when the dust finally settles on all their careers. Little Petyon will be a footnote on the NFL history books.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

It's a special brand of stupid when you're comparing a QB from the 1970's and early to mid 1980's to one who played from 2004 to the present and are using passing TD's as your main argument.

Yeah, if stats are somewhat comparable, it would be stupid

When you are calling 2 QB;s the same when there are 23 and 25 THOUSAND yards seperating them, and hundreds of TD passes, youre looking pretty stupid

 

[Bolts]

Comparing the games started and TD totals of Rivers and Eli seems dumb when you consider Rivers was Brees' backup for 2 years, he's been a consistent starter every year since. All the other regular season stats(YPG, TD%, INT%, QB Rating) favor Rivers. The only thing Eli has going for him is twice he found himself in the playoffs and had a nice run to win a SB. I'm not trying to say that those postseason stats don't matter, I'm sure Rivers would rather be an average reg. season QB like Eli and win 2 titles, but it's the one edge Eli has over him.

Eli is like Joe Flacco imo, solid regular season stats with some big years in the playoffs. Both have beaten the Pats in the playoffs twice, which makes them even more similar.

 

[DJ Fieri]

LMAO, thats some funny stuff

Facts. Or you don't understand how thew game has evolved and the QB's now are fucking coddled with the rules.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

And they will go down as lesser QBs when the dust finally settles on all their careers. Little Petyon will be a footnote on the NFL history books.

Yes, Peyton, like most NFL record holders, will go down as a much lesser QB

 

[NEPatsfan]

Comparing the games started and TD totals of Rivers and Eli seems dumb when you consider Rivers was Brees' backup for 2 years, he's been a consistent starter every year since. All the other regular season stats(YPG, TD%, INT%, QB Rating) favor Rivers. The only thing Eli has going for him is twice he found himself in the playoffs and had a nice run to win a SB. I'm not trying to say that those postseason stats don't matter, I'm sure Rivers would rather be an average reg. season QB like Eli and win 2 titles, but it's the one edge Eli has over him.

Eli is like Joe Flacco imo, solid regular season stats with some big years in the playoffs. Both have beaten the Pats in the playoffs twice, which makes them even more similar.

Oh Boy! Now you've done it! You have besmirched the reputation of the little Manning.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Facts. Or you don't understand how thew game has evolved and the QB's now are fucking coddled with the rules.

Sure i do, its a point i make when everyone calls Brady the GOAT, when I know guys like Elway, Marino and Montana would be putting up circus like numbers in an era you cant play defense

However, when the discrepancy is so so great, i cant just chalk it up to different eras