WizardHawk
Release the Kraken - Fuck the Canucks
There is no format that does what some of you foolishly want. You can't have 120+ teams in a 12 game season and find some kind of utopic all inclusive playoff.I like the 64 team because it encompasses nearly every team with a winning record and says... 'Ok, now if you can win every game from here on out against the best of the best, you can have the title.'
Realistically, we know 99% of the time, the best P5 team will win. But I love those Boise/OU underdog victories and those victories should mean something. It is wrong that G5 teams have practically no shot of winning the title yet play in the 'same division'. There is no excuse for that, everyone should be given the same opportunity.
Problem is that the nay-sayers are not wrong in that P5 schools play significantly tougher competition week in and week out and depending on context, should nearly always make it in over a G5 school even with a loss. But to me, that does not justify shutting 65 schools out before the season begins.
We all know the ball can bounce the other way sometimes. When App St beat #5 Michigan in the Big House, who honestly thought that would happen? No one. Just like no one thought Boise St was going to beat OU. Just like I doubt anyone actually thought Old Dominion was going to beat VaTech last year. Va Tech wasn't very good, but no one thought that. Imagine if a hypothetical #13 seed Wyoming were able to knock out a #4 seed USC.
In my opinion, it is those moments (outside of following your own team) that fans truly live for.
Put 64 in. No one gets a bye, higher seeds can have home field advantage til the Elite 8 or something. Get rid of CCGs as those are basically useless at that point. Obviously it would naturally include all the would-be conference champions anyway. Play a 12 game regular season then go immediately into a 64 team playoff.
Think about how excited people get for the 64 team NCAA basketball tournament bracket... now put it in a sport people actually care about. Talk about a money maker.
I'd settle for 32 just because that still encompasses most winning record teams. You could take the 20 division winners and then 12 at larges.
There is nothing at all stopping the G5's from dropping down to their own tier and creating their own playoff or whatever the hell they want to do to crown their own champion. Hell, have them do theirs first and still let their champ have a shot at the playoff for those years when there isn't a true 4th team worthy. Who cares, but ffs a 64 team playoff is just completely stupid and thankfully won't ever happen.