So where does Peyton rank now?

[Desean12345]

After this sorry performance, he drops to 5th for me, behind Montana, Brady, Elway and Marino.

Seahawks were obviously the better team, and it wasn't just his fault but he has to take the majority of the blame for this one.

 

[Desean12345]

Bump

 

[michaeljordan_fan]

You win in the NFL based off of 2 things: Getting to the QB, and Protecting the QB. Seattle did both, Denver did neither.

 

[BF4L]

You win in the NFL based off of 2 things: Getting to the QB, and Protecting the QB. Seattle did both, Denver did neither.

but but but Manning is elite

 

[cwood]

Same place he ranked yesterday.

 

[Clayton]

Montana is the clutch QB
Peyton is the high IQ QB
Brady is a half n half of both
Unitas is the godfather

Thats your top tier atm, imo. Elway had the best playoff running back of all time, right?

 

[Desean12345]

Montana is the clutch QB
Peyton is the high IQ QB
Brady is a half n half of both
Unitas is the godfather

Thats your top tier atm, imo. Elway had the best playoff running back of all time, right?

Elway carried shitty teams to super bowls. Once he finally got a good team, he won back 2 back super bowls.

 

[Jakology]

I know I'm about to get flamed for this, but I'm going to make my stance anyway:

Peyton just broke the record for most completions in a Super Bowl against one of, if not the greatest defense of all time. I'd say he did everything he possibly could. He had one bad pass that went high and got picked. Other than that, the rest wasn't really on him, and he played a great game. Say I'm just making excuses, but I'm just saying how I saw the game. I saw the Broncos defense completely fold after the 1st quarter, and the Broncos offensive line could not block anything tonight. To say that Peyton choked would just be proving how little you know about football.

 

[BF4L]

I know I'm about to get flamed for this, but I'm going to make my stance anyway:

Peyton just broke the record for most completions in a Super Bowl against one of, if not the greatest defense of all time. I'd say he did everything he possibly could. He had one bad pass that went high and got picked. Other than that, the rest wasn't really on him, and he played a great game. Say I'm just making excuses, but I'm just saying how I saw the game. I saw the Broncos defense completely fold after the 1st quarter, and the Broncos offensive line could not block anything tonight. To say that Peyton choked would just be proving how little you know about football.

but but but if he had a team he would have won it all

 

[Desean12345]

I know I'm about to get flamed for this, but I'm going to make my stance anyway:

Peyton just broke the record for most completions in a Super Bowl against one of, if not the greatest defense of all time. I'd say he did everything he possibly could. He had one bad pass that went high and got picked. Other than that, the rest wasn't really on him, and he played a great game. Say I'm just making excuses, but I'm just saying how I saw the game. I saw the Broncos defense completely fold after the 1st quarter, and the Broncos offensive line could not block anything tonight. To say that Peyton choked would just be proving how little you know about football.

He sucked, deal with it.

 

[Jakology]

but but but if he had a team he would have won it all

He had the team this time. But they ran into a better team. No excuses here. Just saying how I think the game went. I don't see how you can say Peyton choked here.

 

[Jakology]

He sucked, deal with it.

Explain how he sucked? Give me insight from the game like I did in my argument?

 

[JDM]

I know I'm about to get flamed for this, but I'm going to make my stance anyway:

Peyton just broke the record for most completions in a Super Bowl against one of, if not the greatest defense of all time. I'd say he did everything he possibly could. He had one bad pass that went high and got picked. Other than that, the rest wasn't really on him, and he played a great game. Say I'm just making excuses, but I'm just saying how I saw the game. I saw the Broncos defense completely fold after the 1st quarter, and the Broncos offensive line could not block anything tonight. To say that Peyton choked would just be proving how little you know about football.

After he put the game out of reach, though.

There were things out of his control, but Peyton's first half was bad and some short completions in the second half after the game was over doesn't undo that.

 

[Midnightangel]

After this sorry performance, he drops to 5th for me, behind Montana, Brady, Elway and Marino.

Seahawks were obviously the better team, and it wasn't just his fault but he has to take the majority of the blame for this one.

Agreed.

 

[Clayton]

Elway carried shitty teams to super bowls. Once he finally got a good team, he won back 2 back super bowls.

56% completion, 300 TDs, 226 INT.

 

[Jakology]

After he put the game out of reach, though.

There were things out of his control, but Peyton's first half was bad and some short completions in the second half after the game was over doesn't undo that.

How did he put the game out of reach? I really don't understand this. I hate how people blame QBs. I know its fun to troll and all, but come on. I respect all QBs, and give them blame and credit when they deserve it. I always give credit to Brady.

 

[LogicMan]

Manning lacked composure from the start. He tried to adjust the snap count and yell Omaha. He needed to settle his team down, he needed to throw and not panic. The Pats lost cause they could not make Peyton move. You make Peyton move, he is very average.

My guess is the Manning era at the SB is over.

 

[Jakology]

Manning lacked composure from the start. He tried to adjust the snap count and yell Omaha. He needed to settle his team down, he needed to throw and not panic. The Pats lost cause they could not make Peyton move. You make Peyton move, he is very average.

My guess is the Manning era at the SB is over.

Nothing but spewed out BS that you have no facts to back it up with. Can you give us a real argument?

 

[JDM]

How did he put the game out of reach? I really don't understand this. I hate how people blame QBs. I know its fun to troll and all, but come on. I respect all QBs, and give them blame and credit when they deserve it. I always give credit to Brady.

His first interception was awful and the pick 6 was a terrible decision to try to force a ball when he clearly wasn't getting it out. His first half as a whole was embarrassing.

 

[LogicMan]

Yes, its called tonights super bowl. he was ill prepared for the game. The score is all the evidence you need, plus the turnovers he handed out, and I do blame him for the touch back