- Thread starter
- #21
WhiteMamba
John: 8:36
Van Halen?
David Lee Roth's? 5 seed.
Haggar's 8 seed... SO a 6 or 7?
Van Halen?
The Who is a lock for a 3 for sure. I cant put them ahead of THe Doors. THey join the next 8 in. Objections?
Which region should I put The Who in? Def not with the loaded Liverpool region. The Beatles, Queen and The Who is BRUTAL!
I think locks for the next 8 spots are
Springsteen
Chuck Berry
Aerosmith
Lynyrd Skynyrd
The Who
Springsteen sucks ass.
Alice in Chains should make the list.
Where is AC/DC?
SRV?
Ok. Here is how I am seeding the 1s and 2s.
and no, you dont have to be from that region to be seeded there.
Liverpool Region
1 Beatles
2 Queen
3 Aerosmith
4 Bruce Springsteen
5 Bob Marley
Nashville Region
1 Led Zepplin
2 Elvis Presley
3 The Eagles
4 Metallica
5 Jerry Lee Lewis
Cleveland Region
1 Pink Floyd
2 The Rolling Stones
3 The Who
4 Alice in Chains
5 Chuck Berry
Whisky a GoGo Region (L.A.)
1 Beach Boys
2 The Doors
3 Jimi Hendrix
4 Lynyrd Skynyrd
5 The Clash
Any changes. Lets stop here and focus on the first 20 in. Any should absolutely NOT be in. Any that ABSOLUTELY should be in?
Tool doesn't get much respect these days but I had to bring them up.
You've got AIC but no Pearl Jam?
I love AIC but I thought Pearl Jam was a better band.
Should be in: CCR
How far back? We including the 50s? If so, Buddy Holly needs to be in there.
WHere should we seed CCR and Holly? All rock and roll.
No pop. Sorry to the great MJ.
Yeah. I think the recent drop off of PJ is evident. AiC lost Staley and they seem to be iconic. I believe the masses go AiC as a higher seeded band. Would you be ok with them as an 7-9 seed? I need the suggestions.