Badger
New Member
Ok, I can see the argument for Matthews. It's at least debatable. But Hayward? Seriously? You can't be arguing that he is better than Tillman or Melton, can you?
You're right, Melton is more valuable. He's been out so long that I forgot about him. But any GM would rather have Hayward than Peanut at this stage of his career. A closer argument could be made for Jennings than for Tillman.