Kelleyman
Former WS Champs. Hope this updates in 2025
With Gomez now back in the fold, here is what I'd like to see:
Trade Jeffress (who the Reds covet for some weird reason) along with 2-3 prospects for DeSclafani and Hamilton. DeSclafani would immediately upgrade the rotation and give them a very legit #3 starter behind Hamels and Darvish. Put Gomez in LF, Hamilton in CF, Mazara in RF, and have Choo DH. Then trade for Matt Szczur from the Cubs (who have a surplus of OF) to serve as the 4th/platoon OF. He's a quality player who had very solid offensive numbers last season and would be able to give our other OF'ers days off without the team suffering much in production (unlike a certain worthless bench outfielder who was just recently released).
Then sign a big power bat to play 1B. There are multiple options available, from Encarnacion to Napoli all the way down to Chris Carter. I know EE is a pipe dream, but I could live with another Napoli reunion. That would yield a lineup of something like this:
CF- Hamilton
DH- Choo
3B- Beltre
1B- Napoli
2B- Odor
C- Lucroy
RF- Mazara
LF- Gomez
SS- Andrus
I could live with that for sure. Basically it's trading Desmond's power for Hamilton's ridiculous speed and defense, Moreland for Napoli, and Hoying for Szczur.
That would still leave question marks regarding the #5 starting pitcher spot (assuming Hamels-Darvish-Disco-Perez makes up the top 4) and what to do with Profar and Gallo (though one of them might have to go in the proposed Reds trade).
Very doable esp getting 2 in trade filling SP role and elite CF or IMO a LF spot to move Mazars to right. Regardless, I like Gomez routes and climbing the wall over Des.
Have to think getting a 1B may come later and even at a discount but have to think regardless we find a way to have Choo mainly at DH. Loce the CReds trade scenario. Also like shot at getting Shelby Miller. There is some upside there