NFL MVP Debate

[Tharvot]

1.) Aaron Rodgers
2.) Peyton Manning
3.) Andrew Luck

Tell me I'm wrong.

One of either Tony Romo or Demarco Murray should be up there ahead of Peyton or Andrew Luck IMO.

 

[HammerDown]

There it is. Dallas was supposed to be a 6 wins team at best. But because of the running game, we have had a chance to win more.

Murray is responsible for quite a few wins all by himself.

I'm a big fan and hesitate to diminish what he's accomplished but some would argue that Walter Payton's ghost could get 1000 yards behind that monster OL.

 

[Broncos6482]

So give them their own award. Pitchers are more valuable than any other position in baseball, hence the need for the Cy Young award.

You have it backwards. The pitchers have their own award because it's extremely rare for them to be dominant enough to win MVP. Pitchers are still eligible to win MVP. Clayton Kershaw just won the NL MVP.

 

[night]

There it is. Dallas was supposed to be a 6 wins team at best. But because of the running game, we have had a chance to win more.

Murray is responsible for quite a few wins all by himself.

He owes his offensive line some amazing Christmas presents this year.

 

[Sgt Brutus]

Problem with Watt has to be Houston not being a playoff team..

 

[RobToxin]

Problem with Watt has to be Houston not being a playoff team..

This is what I said a couple weeks ago.

Shameless SportsHoopla Blog Post plug:

WATT??? Burning Out On The JJ Hype | NFL | SportsHoopla.com

 

[Jim Rome is Flaming]

Realistically, there's little chance that Rodgers doesn't get it. From a pure "who is the most valuable" standpoint, it's hard to argue against him. But as a football fan, I think it would be great for a player like Watt or Murray to win it.

 

[geezer]

Wilson beat a-rod and has just as many wins with a lot less in the way of wide receivers. Remember, they are pedestrian. And he lost his top two WR's this season. And his starting tight end. And Seattle has one of the most injury ridden/prone offensive lines in football.

I got some used jocky shorts for you guaranteed to have been worn by a rod. They are a year old but still smell so you will love them. only $89.00 a pair.

 

[darken65]

Realistically, there's little chance that Rodgers doesn't get it. From a pure "who is the most valuable" standpoint, it's hard to argue against him. But as a football fan, I think it would be great for a player like Watt or Murray to win it.

Same here.

 

[Jim Rome is Flaming]

Wilson beat a-rod and has just as many wins with a lot less in the way of wide receivers. Remember, they are pedestrian. And he lost his top two WR's this season. And his starting tight end. And Seattle has one of the most injury ridden/prone offensive lines in football.

I got some used jocky shorts for you guaranteed to have been worn by a rod. They are a year old but still smell so you will love them. only $89.00 a pair.

C'mon man. I love Russell, but he isn't putting up the kind of stats that you need to win an MVP in today's NFL. No doubt he is a very good QB, but there isn't a snowball's chance in hell he wins MVP.

 

[geezer]

C'mon man. I love Russell, but he isn't putting up the kind of stats that you need to win an MVP in today's NFL. No doubt he is a very good QB, but there isn't a snowball's chance in hell he wins MVP.

Thats what is wrong with this BS. Its all about stats, not who is actually the most valuable.

 

[Arizona_Sting]

JJ Watt = Anthony Davis of NFL or vise versa I suppose. Best two individual players and deserve MVP this year, but won't win due to lack of team success.

Rodgers will win it most likely.

 

[Arizona_Sting]

Thats what is wrong with this BS. Its all about stats, not who is actually the most valuable.

Since we're throwing stats out of the picture then Bruce Arians should win MVP.

 

[Jim Rome is Flaming]

Thats what is wrong with this BS. Its all about stats, not who is actually the most valuable.

Don't hold your breath on it changing anytime soon. NFL is a money driven league, and offense pays the bills.

 

[LogicMan]

My vote is Manning . The Broncos are deplete of talent and he is holding them up

 

[sonnyblack65]

Rodgers and then Watt

NFL MVP Power Rankings: J.J. Watt passes up Tom Brady?

 

[HammerDown]

 

[HammerDown]

Since we're throwing stats out of the picture then Bruce Arians should win MVP.

I never thought an NFL coach could be more vastly overhyped based upon nothing but a douchey personality than Jim Harbaugh but Bruce Arians takes the cake.

 

[sonnyblack65]

Off day Sun because Hans and Franz are getting him too jacked. Hope they not injecting him with some Austrian Mother's milk

 

[night]

I would say

1. Rodgers
2. Brady
3. Murray
4. Gronkowski
5. Watt