NFL.com's Coaches Rankings

[PDay8810]

u would if garrett was in the top 10

you don't know that, you assume....like other lists, it's one guys opinion and is subjective towards wins. Look no further than where your coach is ranked.

I think garrett has done all he can and is ranked about right. He's restored accountability and effort without the sense of entitlement many player had here wearing the star and having Jerry as the owner. Not many quality know their shit coaches would coach for a jerry team. Garrett isn't good with in game adjustments, and in the last few season has lacked greatly in the creative department with regards to game plans.

 

[SteelersPride]

you don't know that, you assume....like other lists, it's one guys opinion and is subjective towards wins. Look no further than where your coach is ranked.

I think garrett has done all he can and is ranked about right. He's restored accountability and effort without the sense of entitlement many player had here wearing the star and having Jerry as the owner. Not many quality know their shit coaches would coach for a jerry team. Garrett isn't good with in game adjustments, and in the last few season has lacked greatly in the creative department with regards to game plans.

My coach> your coach

 

[PDay8810]

My coach> your coach

looks to be so

congrats on your accomplishment

 

[SteelersPride]

looks to be so

congrats on your accomplishment

Thank you

 

[Bridgeburner]

Does Jason Garrett even coach? I kind of always assumed Jerrah had his hand up his ass working the controls.

 

[PDay8810]

Does Jason Garrett even coach? I kind of always assumed Jerrah had his hand up his ass working the controls.

might explain the game day decisions.
Like I said.....Jason has his team playing hard with effort each Sunday. That wasn't the case before his arrival.

 

[PhillyGreen]

Andy Reid is too high. Yes....he get the Chiefs to the playoffs but they have one only one playoff game and have been offensively inept in all their playoff losses.

Jason Garrett is bottom 10.

 

[megalodon30]

Whoo! Top 30! Go Broncos!

 

[Fountain City Blues]

Not really feeling the Andy Reid hate today.

 

[Roy Munson]

Whoever wrote this list is a retard.



SB Victories:

Doug Pederson: 1
Andy Reid: 0 (in like 10x years coached)

 

[Roy Munson]

Not really feeling the Andy Reid hate today.

I hadn't found this thread yet.

 

[PhillyGreen]

Not really feeling the Andy Reid hate today.

I don't hate Andy Reid. I just don't feel he is a top 10 NFL coach and IMO he has not shown anything to warrant that ranking. The Chiefs have shown flashes but seem to crash and burn often.

 

[Clayton]

The thing about Andy Reid and Jon Gruden is that they are big parts of coaching trees now. They are probably both fringe top 10. I think they've both had issues with roster construction.

Pederson matched Bellichick. I think Carroll is in the same ballpark. Harbaugh is definitely in the elite category especially since he has been working with Flacco and not a real QB. After those names, I think there is some dropoff. I'd probably have Zimmer next but you can make an argument for about five coaches including someone like Reid.

 

[Fountain City Blues]

I'd day bottom 5. He's one of the main reasons that Aaron Rodgers has been to one Superbowl. Fat Elvis has ridden the coat tails of his QB for a decade.

But muh SB

 

[Clayton]

I think the general consensus among KC fans is that the reason Alex Smith is no longer the QB is because guys like Tomlin and Garrett totally shut him down. You gotta blame someone. It was either Alex Smith, Andy Reid or John Dorsey. If its Andy Reid then he is probably going to have the same fate as the other two. I'm not convinced its Andy Reid at this point.

 

[eaglesnut]

Tomlin at #4??

Forced to have a token in the top 5?

 

[eaglesnut]

2018 NFL coach rankings: Bill Belichick and then ...

1) Bill Bellichick - NE
2) Sean Payton - NO
3) Pete Carroll - SEA
4) Mike Tomlin - PIT
5) John Harbaugh - BAL
6) Mike McCarthy - GB
7) Andy Reid - KC
8) Doug Peterson - PHI
9) Jon Gruden - OAK
10) Mike Zimmer - MIN
11) Dan Quinn - ATL
12) Ron Rivera - CAR
13) Sean McVay - LAR
14) Doug Marrone - JAX
15) Jason Garrett - DAL
16) Bill O'Brien - HOU
17) Anthony Lynn - LAC
18) Jay Gruden - WAS
19) Sean McDermott - BUF
20) Marvin Lewis - CIN
21) Adam Gase - MIA
22) Todd Bowles - NYJ
23) Kyle Shanahan - SF
24) Matt Patricia - DET
25) Matt Nagy - CHI
26) Frank Reich - IND
27) Pat Shurmer - NYG
28) Dirk Koetter - TB
29) Mike Vrabel - TEN
30) Vance Joseph - DEN
31) Steve Wilks - ARI
32) Hue Jackson - CLE

Thanks for posting it in full, btw.

 

[Fountain City Blues]

#NotMyQB

 

[Jikkle]

That's a pretty bad list overall.

Tomlin is not a top 5 coach. Good coach but it's pretty evident he's not a great coach.

Not sure how you rate Gruden in the top 10 when he hasn't coached in 10 years. History hasn't been kind to coaches that have had long layoffs between coaching gigs.

Zimmer and Rivera should be higher.

A lot of guys should be lower.

And for my homer complaint I don't see how Kyle Shanahan is at 23. Not saying he's top 10 or anything but I'd have closer a few spots higher.

 

[rmilia1]

A.W.F.U.L