Mount Rushmore for.........

[RaZon]

Didn't say there was... But if you think all eras are treated equally you would be wrong.. Also, position matters...

Tunnel may be top 5... but no way is he top 3... and there is a big leap between 3 and 4 for the giants...

Didn't say there was... But if you think all eras are treated equally you would be wrong.. Also, position matters...

Tunnel may be top 5... but no way is he top 3... and there is a big leap between 3 and 4 for the giants...

Tunnell is second all time INT;s, a nine time pro bowler a 4 time All Pro. The first great Giant.

I have him on my Giants MR.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Tunnell is second all time INT;s, a nine time pro bowler a 4 time All Pro. The first great Giant.

I have him on my Giants MR.

that depends on how many players make it onto the mount rushmore… if it is only 3.. .he is not on it... if it is 5... he probably just makes it...

 

[RaZon]

that depends on how many players make it onto the mount rushmore… if it is only 3.. .he is not on it... if it is 5... he probably just makes it...

Assumed we all know there are four busts on a Mount Rushmore.

The NFL's second all time INT man left off their Mount Rushmore, ????

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Assumed we all know there are four busts on a Mount Rushmore.

The NFL's second all time INT man left off their Mount Rushmore, ????

Again, he doesn't get it over LT, Strahan and Eli

the 4th to 8 are all so super close IMO

With Gifford, Tunnell, Hein, and Rosey Brown...

Where all 4 of those players played Pre superbowl era...

If you want to give Tunnel it because he meant more than just his football numbers, then fine... Wont argue against it...

 

[RaZon]

Again, he doesn't get it over LT, Strahan and Eli

the 4th to 8 are all so super close IMO

With Gifford, Tunnell, Hein, and Rosey Brown...

Where all 4 of those players played Pre superbowl era...

If you want to give Tunnel it because he meant more than just his football numbers, then fine... Wont argue against it...

Pro bowls and All pros is what ya look at, that tells us how these guys were perceived in their day.

Gifford gets more attntion than Tunnell, he had 8 pro bowls, Tunnell 9, both having 4 All Pros, yes Tunnell on the same level.

You can't ignore IMPACT, no Giant ever made a bigger IMPACT than Lawrence Taylor, then it's Emlen Tunnell.

 

[Southieinnc]

You actually thought we would indulge you with a response to that bush league troll job?

Admit it - it went over your collective heads!

 

[PhilSimms11]

DAMN, this is fun. (Players only)

Bills
Jim Kelly
Andre Reed
Bruce Smith
Thurman Thomas

Dolphins
Larry Csonka
Larry Little
Dan Marino
Jason Taylor

Patriots
Tom Brady
Rob Gronkowski
John Hannah
Andre Tippett

Jets
Joe Klecko
Curtis Martin
Don Maynard
Joe Namath

Ravens
Ray Lewis
Jon Ogden
Ed Reed
Terrell Suggs

Bengals
Ken Anderson
Boomer Esiason
Anthony Munoz
Ken Riley

Browns
Jim Brown
Otto Graham
Lou Groza
Ozzie Newsome

Steelers
Terry Bradshaw
Joe Greene
Franco Harris
Jack Lambert

Texans
DeAndre Hopkins
Andre Johnson
Deshaun Watson
JJ Watt

Colts (Baltimore)
Raymond Berry
John Mackey
Gino Marchetti
John Unitas

Colts (Indianapolis)
Dwight Freeney
Marvin Harrison
Peyton Manning
Reggie Wayne

Jaguars
Tony Boselli
Mark Brunell
Jimmy Smith
Fred Taylor

Oilers
Elvin Bethea
Earl Campbell
Warren Moon
Mike Munchak

Titans
Eddie George
Derrick Henry
Bruce Matthews
Steve McNair

Broncos
John Elway
Randy Gradishar
Shannon Sharpe
Rod Smith

Chiefs
Bobby Bell
Tony Gonzalez
Willie Lanier
Derrick Thomas

Raiders
Marcus Allen
Fred Biletnikoff
Tim Brown
Jim Otto

Chargers
Lance Alworth
Dan Fouts
Junior Seau
LaDainian Tomlinson

Cowboys
Larry Allen
Bob Lilly
Emmitt Smith
Roger Staubach

Giants
Frank Gifford
Eli Manning
Lawrence Taylor
Emlen Tunnell

Eagles
Chuck Bednarik
Brian Dawkins
Steve Van Buren
Reggie White

Redskins
Sammy Baugh
Darrell Green
Art Monk
John Riggins

Bears
Dick Butkus
Walter Payton
Gale Sayers
Mike Singletary

Lions
Lem Barney
Calvin Johnson
Bobby Layne
Barry Sanders

Packers
Brett Favre
Don Hutson
Curly Lambeau
Bart Starr

Vikings
Paul Krause
Randy Moss
Alan Page
Fran Tarkenton

Falcons
Claude Humphrey
Julio Jones
Matt Ryan
Roddy White

Panthers
Luke Kuechly
Cam Newton
Julius Peppers
Steve Smith

Saints
Drew Brees
Rickey Jackson
Sam Mills
Willie Roaf

Buccaneers
Derrick Brooks
John Lynch
Lee Roy Selmon
Warren Sapp

Cardinals
Dan Dierdorf
Larry Fitzgerald
Jackie Smith
Larry Wilson

Rams
Marshall Faulk
Deacon Jones
Jackie Slater
Jack Youngblood

49ers
Roger Craig
Ronnie Lott
Joe Montana
Jerry Rice

Seahawks
Shaun Alexander
Walter Jones
Cortez Kennedy
Steve Largent

 

[Beaker]

Packers (Quarterback edition)

Bart Starr
Brett Favre
Aaron Rodgers
Jay Cutler

Tell me I'm wrong

 

[RaZon]

Huge Roger Craig fan loved his style, but.....

His stats just don;t compare to Joe Perry. Perry having more yards, more TD;s, better average.

 

[FaCe-LeE-uS]

Admit it - it went over your collective heads!

The look on all of our faces when we read that

 

[CrashDavisSports]

Cincinnati Bengals

Paul Brown
Anthony Munoz
Ken Riley
Geno Atkins

 

[Irish7478]

As an old time Falcon fan, I would look at Jeff Van Note or Tommy Nobis over Roddy White.

 

[PhilSimms11]

As an old time Falcon fan, I would look at Jeff Van Note or Tommy Nobis over Roddy White.

Both are more than worthy.

 

[Battlelyon]

Rams
Marshall Faulk
Deacon Jones
Jackie Slater
Jack Youngblood

There is no way your not including a 3 time Defensive Player of the Year

 

[PhilSimms11]

There is no way your not including a 3 time Defensive Player of the Year

Merlin Olsen never won DPOY.

 

[Irish7478]

Merlin Olsen never won DPOY.

he probably means Aaron Donald.

 

[PhilSimms11]

he probably means Aaron Donald.

 

[jarntt]

Jets

Joe Namath
Curtis Martin
Don Maynard

Joe Klecko one of the most underrated players ever IMO

 

[Sharkonabicycle]

Bucs
Warren Sapp
Derrick Brooks
Lee Roy Selmon
Tom Brady

 

[RaZon]

I always wondered just how many sacks did Deacon Jones have. Back then he was THE passer rusher, what a lot of people don't know is he was a sprinter in college, guessing he had to have been lighter, not sure what times he ran.

On an All Time NFL team he'd have to be on that D.

South Carolina State,yep, HBCU power.