Division Mount Rushmore

[ducky]

Deacon Jones on the list for NFCW or GTFO.

 

[Ickey Shuffle]

Uhh Joe Thomas. Unless you are 10 years old

An offensive lineman

I know you guys are poverty, but we’re really scraping at the bottom of the jar here

 

[UK Cowboy]

Trent Williams over Steve Young is blasphemy especially since he's only played four seasons in San Fran

As a Cowboys fan for 40 years, Steve Young was right up there with Montana IMO. Super smart and accurate and a great runner. Very hard to defend

 

[broncosmitty]

Bengals
Anthony Munoz
Ken Anderson
Boomer Esiason
Ken Riley (I pick him over OchoCinco)

Honorable mention: OchoCinco, Geno Atkins, Joe Burrow (I would be surprised if he wasn't very soon)

Browns
Jim Brown
Joe Thomas
Otto Graham
Ozzie Newsome

Honorable Mention: Paul Warfield, Myles Garrett (soon, very soon)

Ravens
Ray Lewis
Ed Reed
Jonathan Ogden
Terrell Suggs

Honorable mention: Rod Woodson (only played 4 seasons), Haloti Ngata

Steelers
Big Ben
Jack Lambert
Mean Joe Greene
Rod Woodson

Honorable Mention: Mel Blount, Terry Bradshaw, Troy Polamalu, Jack Ham, Alan Faneca

A top 4 for PIT is tough. You could make this a top 8. Bradshaw or Big Ben? Blount or Woodson?

I’d have Terry on there instead of Big Ben.

Tough to not have the two time MVP Lamar Jackson on there for the Ravens too. But I don’t know who to kick off.

 

[shopson67]

An offensive lineman

I know you guys are poverty, but we’re really scraping at the bottom of the jar here

Glass houses.....

Best Bengal of all time could very well be Anthony Munoz....

 

[shopson67]

I’d have Terry on there instead of Big Ben.

Tough to not have the two time MVP Lamar Jackson on there for the Ravens too. But I don’t know who to kick off.

Maybe the murderer?

 

[broncosmitty]

Maybe the murderer?

He’s was really good though….

 

[shopson67]

He’s was really good though….

Sure, but if you're trying to make a tough decision you could use that as a tie-breaker.

 

[RobToxin]

Does Faulk make the list ahead of Warner? You could also go older school with one of those four (but it's tough to single one out from Van Brocklin, Gabriel, Hirsch, etc).

JJ Watt is on the Cardinals list but not Kurt Warner.....

WTF!

 

[RobToxin]

AFC South. There is no Mount Rushmore unless we include Houston Oilers players as former Titans.

Otherwise it's really just Manning on the monument by himself.

 

[Shanemansj13]

An offensive lineman

I know you guys are poverty, but we’re really scraping at the bottom of the jar here

That is funny coming from a Bengals fan. Their best player was Munoz for a very long time LOL

 

[shopson67]

JJ Watt is on the Cardinals list but not Kurt Warner.....

WTF!

Yeah, plus Dierdorf probably should be in there

 

[Shanemansj13]

I’d have Terry on there instead of Big Ben.

Tough to not have the two time MVP Lamar Jackson on there for the Ravens too. But I don’t know who to kick off.

Yeah most I think would have Terry over Big Ben.

I rarely put RB's on the list...but I guess I could include Lamar in the honorable mention. Probably Suggs would be the guy to kick off and I can't do it

 

[UK Cowboy]

Roger Staubach
Bob Lilly
Emmitt Smith
Troy Aikman

 

[RobToxin]

Need a little more clarification on qualifications.

For example, Bradshaw and Mean Joe, etc.

Can they be listed as part of the AFC North when they never played in the AFC North?

What do we do with AFC and NFC Central players when those divisions no longer exist?

 

[Shanemansj13]

NFC North

Bears
Walter Payton
Mike Singletary
Dick Butkus
Mike Ditka

Honorable mention: Brian Urlacher, Dan Hampton

Feels strange not having a QB on the list. A RB, LB's and a TE though...

Lions
Barry Sanders
Calvin Johnson
Lem Barney
Joe Schmidt

Honorable mention: Stafford, Night Train, Bobby Layne (too old for me), Alex Karras, Jack Christensen

I put Barney over Night Train bc he was a lifetime Lion, it matters imo. I think a lot would argue CJ is not on the list but I disagree. @broncosmitty

Packers
Aaron Rodgers
Reggie White
Bart Starr
Brett Favre

Honorable mention: Don Hutson, Ray Nitschke - could include other old school guys as well

Vikings
Randy Moss
Fran Tarkenton
Alan Page
Adrian Peterson

Honorable mention: John Randle, Cris Carter, Carl Eller, Randall McDaniel, Paul Krause

Another tough one, so many greats.

 

[Shanemansj13]

AFC South

Colts
Peyton Manning
Johnny U
Marvin Harrison
Edge

Honorable mention: Dwight Freeney, Andrew Luck, Reggie Wayne

Jaguars
Tony Boselli
Mark Brunell
Jimmy Smith
Fred Taylor

Honorable mention: MJD, Ramsey

Texans
Matt Schaub
Andre Johnson
JJ Watt
DeAndre Hopkins

Honorable mention: Arian Foster, Mario Williams, Deshaun Watson (I bet most hate him now but including him here)

Titans
Bruce Matthews (Oilers)
King Henry
Warren Moon (Oilers)
Steve McNair

Honorable mention: Eddie George, Kearse, Bulluck

Tough putting Henry over George but I think with his career over now it is fair either way.

 

[FaCe-LeE-uS]

I’d have Terry on there instead of Big Ben.

Not a snowflake's chance in hell

 

[PDay8810]

Great actor as well......

real good guest appearance on the Munsters but Jack Snow stole the scene.

 

[Pure Steel]

Bengals
Anthony Munoz
Ken Anderson
Boomer Esiason
Ken Riley (I pick him over OchoCinco)

Honorable mention: OchoCinco, Geno Atkins, Joe Burrow (I would be surprised if he wasn't very soon)

Browns
Jim Brown
Joe Thomas
Otto Graham
Ozzie Newsome

Honorable Mention: Paul Warfield, Myles Garrett (soon, very soon)

Ravens
Ray Lewis
Ed Reed
Jonathan Ogden
Terrell Suggs

Honorable mention: Lamar, Haloti Ngata

Steelers
Big Ben
Jack Lambert
Mean Joe Greene
Rod Woodson

Honorable Mention: Mel Blount, Terry Bradshaw, Troy Polamalu, Jack Ham, Alan Faneca

A top 4 for PIT is tough. You could make this a top 8. Bradshaw or Big Ben? Blount or Woodson?

Ham, Blount and Troy over Big Ben and Mike Webster over Faneca all day…..