Lets argue over QB's, Can you name 10 Qb's you'd take over Aaron Rodgers

[Stakesarehigh]

All time we are probably looking at 6-10th overall.

Currently he's backslid quite a bit and this year is kind of a determining factor in whether he's at the end or not.

 

[Used 2 B Hu]

You gonna add Coke McElroy while you're at it, Emmitt?

I don't know who either of those people are

 

[Rex Racer]

I'd take every QB in the NFL except that midget rookie in AZ over Drama Queen Aaron. He'll I'd ask JaCarcass Russel to come out of retirement before I'd hand the reins of my offense over to Rodgers.

 

[PhillyGreen]

I think Rodgers currently is a top 3 QB and has been for most of his career. Historically he is not the GOAT and there are good number of QB's that would go higher than him in all time rankings.

 

[Shanemansj13]

Currently or historically?

Currently:

Brady
Brees
Luck
Wilson
Wentz (age)
Mahommes (age)
Watson (age)
Mayfield (age)
Roethlisberger (coin flip)
Rivers (coin flip)

Historic:

Brady
Peyton
Montana
Elway
Unitas
Marino
Starr
Aikman
Warner
Young

 

[Shanemansj13]

I can, i probably do more......but since hes the GOAT lets stick with 10

QB's I could put ahead of Rodgers that are still playing (take entire career into consideration):

Brady

QB's all-time that I have ahead of Rodgers:

Montana
Brady
Manning
Young
Marino

Favre (an argument can be made but when Rodgers retires he will most likely surpass him. I still have him in front of Favre right now)

 

[Clayton]

His prime was top 10. His stretch from 2009 to 2016 was incredible.

Moving forward? Not sure what he still has left in the tank.


edited the years

 

[SteelersPride]

QB's I could put ahead of Rodgers that are still playing (take entire career into consideration):

Brady

QB's all-time that I have ahead of Rodgers:

Montana
Brady
Manning
Young
Marino

Favre (an argument can be made but when Rodgers retires he will most likely surpass him. I still have him in front of Favre right now)

so you have rodgers at 2 now........ and #6 all time, am i correct?

 

[Shanemansj13]

so you have rodgers at 2 now........ and #6 all time, am i correct?

Yeah. This is career wise. If we are talking currently right now where the past doesn't matter, Mahomes and others would be in front of Rodgers imo.

 

[SteelersPride]

i have yet to post anything legit so here I will go , come after me if you want

Current first

Brady

Then a legit muddled mess for me of

Ben, brees, Rivers, luck, Rodgers



Then
Wilson, Wentz(pre acl and back-TBD), Mahomes(sorry do it more than once)

 

[SteelersPride]

Yeah. This is career wise. If we are talking currently right now where the past doesn't matter, Mahomes and others would be in front of Rodgers imo.

wow , see mahomes isnt ahead of him for me, gotta do it more than once, hell joe flacco was the best qb ever for a playoff run.

 

[SteelersPride]

All time im just gonna rattle off some names
Marino
Peyton(about equal)
brady
steve young
joe montana
kurt warner(yes)
graham
favre
staubach
jergenson
elway
unitas
Jim Kelly
Sammy baugh
tarkenton

im gonna stop there, hes definitely top 30 all time........i dont think thats a huge slight

 

[SteelersPride]

Yeah. This is career wise. If we are talking currently right now where the past doesn't matter, Mahomes and others would be in front of Rodgers imo.

yeah im going career wise.

 

[Shanemansj13]

wow , see mahomes isnt ahead of him for me, gotta do it more than once, hell joe flacco was the best qb ever for a playoff run.

That would be considered "career", doing it more than once. I mean current QB's right now, forget the past lol

 

[SteelersPride]

That would be considered "career", doing it more than once. I mean current QB's right now, forget the past lol

so just based on current form?

Mahomes
Brady
Luck
Ben
Rivers
wilson
ryan
watson
luck

for me

 

[Nosferatu]

All time im just gonna rattle off some names
Marino
Peyton(about equal)
brady
steve young
joe montana
kurt warner(yes)
graham
favre
staubach
jergenson
elway
unitas
Jim Kelly
Sammy baugh
tarkenton

im gonna stop there, hes definitely top 30 all time........i dont think thats a huge slight

So, you're saying all those guys are better than Rodgers? lolzzzz okay Trollee McTrollerson...

 

[SteelersPride]

So, you're saying all those guys are better than Rodgers? lolzzzz okay Trollee McTrollerson...

Well Johnny come
Lately. Who are you saying for sure isn’t? If your gonna call me a troll back it up.

 

[GNG]

yeah creamcitycentral website is a grrrrrrrrrrreat source

Name a better one.

 

[GNG]

Well Johnny come
Lately. Who are you saying for sure isn’t? If your gonna call me a troll back it up.

Does the truth hurt?

 

[GNG]

WRONG
WRONG
WRONG
WRONG