Keep Goldschmidt or Stanton

[poprocksncoke]

like the title says, would you keep Goldschmidt or Stanton?

Thanks

 

[MilkSpiller22]

like the title says, would you keep Goldschmidt or Stanton?

Thanks

all are equal?? if so, not even close, Goldy is the clear keeper...

 

[redseat]

Goldy

ESPN (Yes I know booooooo) has him # 5 as there Top 300 players (1st for 1stbaseman)

Stanton is ranked 36th (11th for outfielders)

2017 fantasy baseball rankings

 

[TKOSpikes]

 

[SlinkyRedfoot]

This can't be serious.

 

[SlinkyRedfoot]

Goldy

ESPN (Yes I know booooooo) has him # 5 as there Top 300 players (1st for 1stbaseman)

Stanton is ranked 36th (11th for outfielders)

2017 fantasy baseball rankings

36th is high.

 

[redseat]

36th is high.

Yeah it seems a little bit but he still is a quality player

 

[SlinkyRedfoot]

Yeah it seems a little bit but he still is a quality player

He's too much risk, IMO.

I had him in a keeper league and was so happy that people were thinking he was a top 10 player preseason last year. I traded his ass off. The guy who took him wanted to trade him back to me this offseason. No.

 

[SlinkyRedfoot]

Meanwhile, I just want to pat myself on the back about my keepers. We keep 10 MLB and 5 prospects (rookie eligibility is doubled for our league).

MLB
Sal Perez
Joey Votto
Robinson Cano
Jose Bautista
Bryce Harper
Jose Abreu
Clayton Kershaw
Madison Bumgarner
Yu Darvish
Cole Hamels

MiLB
Joey Gallo
Rafael Devers
Victor Robles
Alex Reyes
AJ Puk


14 team league, H2H w/ point system that favors pitchers. Stacked.

 

[redseat]

Meanwhile, I just want to pat myself on the back about my keepers. We keep 10 MLB and 5 prospects (rookie eligibility is doubled for our league).

MLB
Sal Perez
Joey Votto
Robinson Cano
Jose Bautista
Bryce Harper
Jose Abreu
Clayton Kershaw
Madison Bumgarner
Yu Darvish
Cole Hamels

MiLB
Joey Gallo
Rafael Devers
Victor Robles
Alex Reyes
AJ Puk


14 team league, H2H w/ point system that favors pitchers. Stacked.

in a 14 team league how the hell do you have Harper,Bumgarner AND Kershaw!?!?!

 

[SlinkyRedfoot]

in a 14 team league how the hell do you have Harper,Bumgarner AND Kershaw!?!?!

I drafted them all in their first years in the minor league system and held them ever since.

 

[SlinkyRedfoot]

Kershaw and Bumgarner as prospects fit my Grade-A1A for pitching prospects.

Big framed, lefty, fireballers from NL West farm systems. Gambled on both and they paid off.

 

[redseat]

I drafted them all in their first years in the minor league system and held them ever since.

smart man!

 

[Chef99]

I drafted them all in their first years in the minor league system and held them ever since.

Lol, that to me is awesome; I would never in my wildest dreams have the patience to do that.

And the answer to the topic question is Goldy, of course.

 

[Yellow Fuzzies]

all are equal?? if so, not even close, Goldy is the clear keeper...

Power, average, speed and he is 1B not OF...It's Goldy.