ITT: Discuss Bama's weak schedule.

[CJH9972]

It's about having fun?

Competition is about determining a winner. Not the best team participating in the competition. Placing and advancing one team over another because it is better as a matter of opinion is an absurd idea.

 

[CJH9972]

Bama has a pretty weak schedule for a top team and P5 team but this is the year if they lose they should not be considered even with the other 1 loss teams for the CFP imo. They will still have to play 2 top 12 teams and likely another one in the SEC Championship if they beat LSU. Win out or go sit at home, that's how I see it. They will still have to earn it.

UCF plays in a non-P5 conference. They will never even be mentioned in the CFP discussion until they move to a P5...that's on them. Grow some balls and move to a P5, build a larger stadium and build your program up if you want respect.

They have a larger stadium than some P5 teams and they can't simply choose to join a P5 league. The discriminatory labels don't even need to exist.

 

[CJH9972]

Not even close to my position.

 

[Rolltide94]

Competition is about determining a winner. Not the best team participating in the competition. Placing and advancing one team over another because it is better as a matter of opinion is an absurd idea.

Having 5 shitty conferences with poor facilities, poor recruiting, poor resources and 5 good conferences with the opposite and pretending they are equal is an absurd idea.

 

[NU_FTW]

Competition is about determining a winner. Not the best team participating in the competition. Placing and advancing one team over another because it is better as a matter of opinion is an absurd idea.

You should stop watching football. Go watch baseball where a series is played.

People who are too stupid to understand that crappy teams with crappy coaching and crappy players and crappy training tables being crappier than those who can afford the best should just stop watching football, or go watch FCS since nobody wants to see their football games yet they have your beloved playoff.


There is a reason big money is on FBS and not FCS

 

[Rolltide94]

Not even close to my position.

I saw your position in the voting thread...when are you publishing your manifesto.

 

[CJH9972]

You should stop watching football. Go watch baseball where a series is played.

People who are too stupid to understand that crappy teams with crappy coaching and crappy players and crappy training tables being crappier than those who can afford the best should just stop watching football, or go watch FCS since nobody wants to see their football games yet they have your beloved playoff.


There is a reason big money is on FBS and not FCS

My post still applies no matter which teams are allowed to compete in any particular division. Your rant has no relevance to my post.

 

[CJH9972]

I saw your position in the voting thread...when are you publishing your manifesto.

What's my position?

 

[NU_FTW]

My post still applies no matter which teams are allowed to compete in any particular division. Your rant has no relevance to my post.

You are of the same retarded mindset that record is more important than who that record is against. You are an absolute moron.

 

[CJH9972]

Having 5 shitty conferences with poor facilities, poor recruiting, poor resources and 5 good conferences with the opposite and pretending they are equal is an absurd idea.

Ensuring they are not equal guarantees the disadvantages you listed. Treating them equal as a matter of rule does not mean equal outcomes. Even under my idea for example, P5 teams dominate.

 

[Bullitt08]

You should stop watching football. Go watch baseball where a series is played.

People who are too stupid to understand that crappy teams with crappy coaching and crappy players and crappy training tables being crappier than those who can afford the best should just stop watching football, or go watch FCS since nobody wants to see their football games yet they have your beloved playoff.


There is a reason big money is on FBS and not FCS

The only reason he is here spouting off this crap is the people at SoundOff basically just ignore him.

 

[CJH9972]

You are of the same retarded mindset that record is more important than who that record is against. You are an absolute moron.

Except I'm not arguing that all. Otherwise, solid point.

 

[CJH9972]

The only reason he is here spouting off this crap is the people at SoundOff basically just ignore him.

While that could true, I haven't even posted as much over there on anything this year.

 

[NU_FTW]

The only reason he is here spouting off this crap is the people at SoundOff basically just ignore him.

LOL.


How fitting that retards like @The Oldtimer @CJH9972 @Neilcar @AlaskaGoober have flocked to @UCFucktard's thread

 

[NU_FTW]

Except I'm not arguing that all. Otherwise, solid point.

Yes you are. It is clear from your posting that you are arguing for that. Eyeballs can easily see teams that execute properly vs teams that execute poorly and squeak out wins, that isnt even subjective you can be very objective with an eye test in that regard but you think it should not be part of determining that the entire AAC is garbage that they are undersized and couldnt stop a P5 RB or run through P5 defenses when size is not on G5's side.... gimmicks and flair work in the G5 not in P5 where real football is played by top athletes. LOL G5 players are the same size as HS players because they dont have any real S&C and cant afford proper nutrition. G5 is there to be a punching bag and get paid better than FCS to do so.

You are arguing FOR the OP who is arguing that Record > who you play.

 

[CJH9972]

Yes you are. It is clear from your posting that you are arguing for that. Eyeballs can easily see teams that execute properly vs teams that execute poorly and squeak out wins, that isnt even subjective you can be very objective with an eye test in that regard but you think it should not be part of determining that the entire AAC is garbage that they are undersized and couldnt stop a P5 RB or run through P5 defenses when size is not on G5's side.... gimmicks and flair work in the G5 not in P5 where real football is played by top athletes. LOL G5 players are the same size as HS players because they dont have any real S&C and cant afford proper nutrition. G5 is there to be a punching bag and get paid better than FCS to do so.

You are arguing FOR the OP who is arguing that Record > who you play.

The things you mention are advantages in an objectively determined competition which is what I want college football to become but I do not a favor best record system.

 

[Rolltide94]

What's my position?

Clearly you think all wins are created equal. You have 3 G5 teams in the top 10 and 8 in the top 25. You claim that results on the field are all the matter, but you have 5 AAC teams ranked, despite the fact that the last time a AAC team beat a ranked P5 team was 2017. As I said, if you'd just provide the release date of your manifesto, we could figure out the rest of your views.

 

[NU_FTW]

The things you mention are advantages in an objectively determined competition which is what I want college football to become but I do not a favor best record system.

You have been arguing you cannot use an eye test, which you most certainly can. Lets say nebraska won all the close games we have had all year we would have a decent record with our only blow out losses being minnesota and ohio state (both unbeaten) if our kicker could have made field goals we would have actually won most those games (this isnt about should woulda i am painting a picture) now nebraska would have be 7-2 not a bad record

If you watched us play there is a reason those games were close, horrible execution and just bad play, this isnt a subjective matter when you see players not do what they are supposed to you can see that penalties and turn overs is horrible for our team though we'd be 7-2 and only have good losses.

Objectively i can say we would not deserve to be ranked not even close, QB doesnt sell the fake, QB doesnt block when he hands the ball off QB doesnt pick up the RB when he gets clobbered behind the LOS Defense isnt executing properly OLine not executing properly yet we'd be 7-2 objectively you can see missed assignments and see that this 7-2 nebraska even with wins over p5's would be garbage regardless of record.


Eye test is very accurate and real and objective and if G5 teams deserved recognition they would look the part objectively (they dont though, and against inferior competition)

 

[Rolltide94]

Ensuring they are not equal guarantees the disadvantages you listed. Treating them equal as a matter of rule does not mean equal outcomes. Even under my idea for example, P5 teams dominate.

They are never going to be equal. The only way the playing field is equal is in your mind. You could count on 1 hand the number of players/coaches who would choose a G5 program over a P5 program. Sure, there are individual players that slip through the cracks to the G5 level and excel...but there are 11 players on the field at a time.

 

[Deep Creek]

You should stop watching football. Go watch baseball where a series is played.

People who are too stupid to understand that crappy teams with crappy coaching and crappy players and crappy training tables being crappier than those who can afford the best should just stop watching football, or go watch FCS since nobody wants to see their football games yet they have your beloved playoff.


There is a reason big money is on FBS and not FCS