Is Tom Brady really the greatest QB of all time?

[GNG]

Philip Rivers explains why Tom Brady might not be the greatest quarterback of all time

 

[Irish Springs Body Wash]

“George W. Bush explains why Abraham Lincoln might not be the greatest President of all time”

 

[Sparhawk]

You had me at "You just can't go off Super Bowl wins...."

 

[RP-29]

Philip Rivers explains why Tom Brady might not be the greatest quarterback of all time

Rivers' stance is precisely the stance I've always held. Wins are a TEAM stat, not a player stat - particularly in a sport where one player is 1/53 of the equation (not counting coaches & management). It's asinine to crown a player the "Greatest" because of team accomplishments. And his citation of the SEA-NE Super Bowl is spot-on too.

Brady is one of the best; not necessarily the best.

 

[Dr. Strangelove]

Like I used to say in the old endless Brady/Manning debates. Who the fuck really cares other than dickless fanboys.Great players all. HOFers, all time greats. Should be enough just to have watched some of these guys play the game at such a high level. And no, SB wins are not the end all, be all.

 

[Chewbaccer]

He’s not the best qb ever, but some how, he is far less gay than Aaron Rodgers.

 

[YankeeRebel]

Brady is the greatest QB of all time that shipped has sailed. The question now is he the greatest player of all time?

 

[NWPATSFAN]

Philip Rivers explains why Tom Brady might not be the greatest quarterback of all time

Spoken like a true player that doesn't have a SB ring.

Yeah rings aren't important.


Mr. Angry Rivers would likely trade one of his 12 children for a ring.

 

[Rock Strongo]

“George W. Bush explains why Abraham Lincoln might not be the greatest President of all time”

lol

this

 

[Rock Strongo]

Like I used to say in the old endless Brady/Manning debates. Who the fuck really cares other than dickless fanboys.Great players all. HOFers, all time greats. Should be enough just to have watched some of these guys play the game at such a high level. And no, SB wins are not the end all, be all.

of course, its why jim plunkett isnt in. he has as many as eli, who some say will be in.

but i guarantee you marino would trade his isotoner stock and ace ventura credits for a ring.

 

[NWPATSFAN]

How adorable is that?

The infamous Hoop liar gave me a chill pill

 

[RP-29]

He’s not the best qb ever, but some how, he is far less gay than Aaron Rodgers.

 

[YankeeRebel]

Rivers' stance is precisely the stance I've always held. Wins are a TEAM stat, not a player stat - particularly in a sport where one player is 1/53 of the equation (not counting coaches & management). It's asinine to crown a player the "Greatest" because of team accomplishments. And his citation of the SEA-NE Super Bowl is spot-on too.

Brady is one of the best; not necessarily the best.

So based on this misguided post there can be no greatest of all time at any position. And let's forget all the plays in a season that lead a team to a SB let's focus on the one great defensive play to attempt to undermine all the other successes. Great logic.

 

[RememberTheKoy]

He is and at this point there is no longer a close second.

 

[Ricky Roma]

Rivers, of course, is spot on.

 

[flyingelvis]

Rivers is the anti-Brady.

 

[RP-29]

So based on this misguided post there can be no greatest of all time at any position. And let's forget all the plays in a season that lead a team to a SB let's focus on the one great defensive play to attempt to undermine all the other successes. Great logic.

Attempting to crown someone "greatest of all time" in any sport is strictly opinion. Brady's "crown" has been an on-going fanboy rabble-rousing campaign for over a decade that has finally built enough followers to recently claim "victory" among the media.

And yes, I subscribe to the opinion that there is not and cannot be one clear "greatest of all time" in any position in football primarily because of such a heavy reliance on 52+ other guys doing their job to acquire successes.

And don't forget that one bad play by a 4th string tight end can cost your team a Super Bowl berth, too.

 

[CouchPotato]

Uncle Roark says Tom Brady is really good. So i believe him.

 

[megalodon30]

Brady may be the greatest QB of all time, but the greatest football player of all time is Champ Bailey.

Go Broncos!

 

[LambeauLegs]

No