IF Peyton doesn't win a Super Bowl With Denver will he be a "bust"

[Manning2Luck_uJelly]

Manning2LuckuJelly?

 

[GNG]

So who would pick someone else and who would they choose? Jerry and Romo?

The Cowboys probably would trade for Manning but the Packers wouldn't part with Rodgers.

 

[runbch]

Manning is probably top 3-4 in terms of ability but when you factor in age, theres a bunch of qb's I would rather have over him.

 

[HammerDown]

Manning is probably top 3-4 in terms of ability

 

[GNG]

Manning is probably top 3-4 in terms of ability but when you factor in age, theres a bunch of qb's I would rather have over him.

 

[Ricky Roma]

Do you still sleep with your Joe Montana blowup doll?

Was this to negate anything I stated?

 

[HammerDown]

LOL

 

[darken65]

Do you still sleep with your Joe Montana blowup doll?

They make a blowup doll of Montana? I've been trying to get the real thing but they have that silly restraining order against me.

 

[SteveDallas]

Bullshit.

Come on G&G. I have a Blonde '69 Strat and a Nickel plated S&W 44 with the 7 1/2" barrel that says Jerry Jones would swap QB's with Denver in a second if given the opportunity. Call it an avatar bet.

 

[GNG]

Come on G&G. I have a Blonde '69 Strat and a Nickel plated S&W 44 with the 7 1/2" barrel that says Jerry Jones would swap QB's with Denver in a second if given the opportunity. Call it an avatar bet.

I already stated that the Cowboys would trade for Manning but I also said I didn't think Green Bay would part with Rodgers.

 

[darken65]

I can see most posters still gloss past the OP's original post so I give up on that debate. I can truly say that Peyton will be a bust.....presented with him at his HOF induction.

 

[SteveDallas]

I already stated that the Cowboys would trade for manning but I also said I didn't think Green Bay would part with Rodgers.

Sorry, not really paying attention tonight. I still think GB would take the trade. After all Manning has stem cell transplants in his neck. Spine of a twenty year old thanks to modern medicine.

 

[GNG]

Sorry, not really paying attention tonight. I still think GB would take the trade. After all Manning has stem cell transplants in his neck. Spine of a twenty year old thanks to modern medicine.

If Rodgers plays another 10 seasons he most likely would shatter all the passing records. He is just 30 years old and already has a career QB rating of 105.8. He has thrown 18 TDs and only 1 INT this season. Longevity will be the determining factor.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Let me ask this question, does anyone doubt that Peyton team now has the defense to go with all the weapons the Bronco's already had, to win a SB? Is there any excuse short of a run of injuries for Peyton not to win a SB this year?

 

[GNG]

Let me ask this question, does anyone doubt that Peyton team now has the defense to go with all the weapons the Bronco's already had, to win a SB? Is there any excuse short of a run of injuries for Peyton not to win a SB this year?

That's a very good point.

 

[DoobeeDoobeeDoo]

If Peyton doesn't win in Denver, he doesn't deserve to make the HOF, simple as that. Don't tell me about no stupid touchdown records. All that goes out the window. Tebow would've won the Super Bowl for Denver by now.

 

[SteveDallas]

If Peyton doesn't win in Denver, he doesn't deserve to make the HOF, simple as that. Don't tell me about no stupid touchdown records. All that goes out the window. Tebow would've won the Super Bowl for Denver by now.

I can't believe you put that dipshits name in the same sentence with Payton Manning, the HOF and Super Bowl. It would damn well take a Supreme Being to make that happen. If it did you'd have Muslims, Budist, Hindus and Atheist flocking to the church by the million. There's a better chance of Goodell walking on water.

 

[JasonCarrier]

Let me ask this question, does anyone doubt that Peyton team now has the defense to go with all the weapons the Bronco's already had, to win a SB? Is there any excuse short of a run of injuries for Peyton not to win a SB this year?

He could pull another 06 playoff run and they could win (3 tds/7 ints)

Or he could pull another epic meltdown and lose the first playoff game they play in

Or he could wait till the SB (see vs Saints or vs Seattle)

That's the options and the track record shows one of these 3 will happen

 

[JasonCarrier]

Bradyjustlosttheafcchampionshipgame

Anybody see what I did there?

And most of the time Manning can't even get to them.

 

[cwood]

There are exactly 3 types of people who would consider it a choke job if the Broncos don't win the Super Bowl this year.

1. People with Pats avatars
2. People with Michigan avatars
3. People who think Elway is in the discussion for best quarterback of all time.