Former 49ers and How They Are Doing On New Teams

[Pattersonca65]

How is former 49ers All-Pro Aldon Smith performing for the Raiders?

Would still liked to have Aldon Smith on this team because we could use another OLB but it appears he's not playing like the dominant passer rusher of several years ago and not a big difference maker on defense when he was getting double digit sacks.

 

[purguy12]

Yeah he is turning into a 1 year wonder. He needs to have a good front line to do anything. I agree it would be nice to have depth but he isn't a Big loss.

Crabtree Is having a good year.

 

[Pattersonca65]

Yeah he is turning into a 1 year wonder. He needs to have a good front line to do anything. I agree it would be nice to have depth but he isn't a Big loss.

Crabtree Is having a good year.

He is on pace for a record year supposedly

 

[darken65]

He is on pace for a record year supposedly

Crabtree has a QB that can get him the ball. Hopefully get doesn't get injured yet again. I wish him well.

 

[Robotech]

Crabtree has a QB that can get him the ball. Hopefully get doesn't get injured yet again. I wish him well.

He's getting a ton of targets and has 47 catches on 80 targets for 591 yards. Richard Sherman is right. He's just mediocre. Right now he's taking advantage of a high volume of targets and defenses being more worried about Cooper. I'd love to see some team flush money down the toilet by signing him to a big contract.

 

[AU_Fever]

Crabtree has a QB that can get him the ball. Hopefully get doesn't get injured yet again. I wish him well.

It sure makes a difference. He has a QB who can get him the ball accurately and on time.

 

[purguy12]

People are making it seem like Carr is some great QB. He is Avg. Smith and Kap tried to get him the ball he just didn't make plays. Just look at the last series in the super bowl and against seattle in the playoffs.

 

[AU_Fever]

People are making it seem like Carr is some great QB. He is Avg. Smith and Kap tried to get him the ball he just didn't make plays. Just look at the last series in the super bowl and against seattle in the playoffs.

No one on this thread has stated that Carr is a great QB. Carr seems to have more poise and pocket awareness than Kap. There is a reason why he was benched. You make it seem as though it is all the receiver's fault. How about Kap's poor mechanics and inaccuracy. Those also come into play. There is a reason why Crabtree is thriving in Oakland. Part of that equation is QB play. Right now, I think most GM's and coaches would rather have Carr than Kap. If Carr is average, what is Kap??

 

[Pattersonca65]

Crabtree has a QB that can get him the ball. Hopefully get doesn't get injured yet again. I wish him well.

He had over 1,000 yards with that same QB. No doubt some of it has to do with Kap but some of it is on Crabtree. Always getting hurt and lost a lot coming off his Achilles injury. Crabtree did not look good at all last year.