Every NFL Team’s Best & Worst Quarterback of All-Time

[Pattersonca65]

Not sure if you are being serious about Dalton.

What about Akili Smith as worst QB

 

[Robotech]

What about Akili Smith as worst QB

Yeah, that's a good one. I think there should be a minimum number of starts, maybe like a season's worth of starts, and Akili Smith would qualify.

I was thinking that the question of who is the worst QB wasn't really the same as who is the biggest bust, so that's why I was thinking there should be a minimum number of starts before a QB is considered for this most prestigious title of their team's worst QB.

 

[Southieinnc]

pats
best= brady
worst=plunkett

No way freind! Tony Collins was the worst!

 

[rmilia1]

Best for Atlanta is easy as hes the best to ever do it...

Mohamed Sanu.

Career 158.3 qb rating. 29.3 ypc. 50% TD pct. 87.5% completion

 

[Breed]

pats
best= brady
worst=plunkett

That's a little harsh. Plunkett played for some bad Pats teams.

 

[Breed]

Seahawks:
Best - Russell Wilson
Worst - Stan Gelbaugh

I'll raise with Rick Mirer for worst.


I always liked the Hawks. They were a fun team to watch.


Wish they'd go back to their old unis.

 

[Breed]

Skins

Best - Sonny J
Worst - Heath Shuler

 

[Dr. Strangelove]

And I'll go with Unitas as best.

I was kinda thinking the same thing about the Colts. Manning definitely great and deserves credit but I think Unitas is at or near the top of all QBs.

 

[Dr. Strangelove]

Not sure if you are being serious about Dalton.

Oh, she's being totally serious. Thinks he's HOF material. Fwiw, I think Cinci's best is Kenny Anderson by a significant margin, then Boomer. Sadly, after Boomer, Dalton but there is a massive gap.

 

[Anointed One]

I'll raise with Rick Mirer for worst.


I always liked the Hawks. They were a fun team to watch.


Wish they'd go back to their old unis.

No way... Mirer at least had a decent rookie year... Hawks broke an NFL record for the last amount of points scored under Gelbaugh...

Dan McGwire and Kelly Stauffer were much worse than Rick Mirer... Rick doesn't deserve to be mentioned imo... He at least netted us a 1st round pick from the Bears that we used to draft Shawn Springs...

 

[PDay8810]

Skins

Best - Sonny J
Worst - Heath Shuler

No way was Sonny the best QB to play in Washington. This guy never started a playoff game ever, played in only one and threw 3 ints. Worst QB in the HOF, and makes Romo a first ballot HOF'er based on his qualifications.

Best Washington QB remains TCU's finest, Slinging Sammy Baugh.

 

[steelerssb]

Does the Packers say Seneca Wallace?

 

[Dr. Strangelove]

No way... Mirer at least had a decent rookie year... Hawks broke an NFL record for the last amount of points scored under Gelbaugh...

Dan McGwire and Kelly Stauffer were much worse than Rick Mirer... Rick doesn't deserve to be mentioned imo... He at least netted us a 1st round pick from the Bears that we used to draft Shawn Springs...

Yeah, that 92 season, although only 1/2 a season from Gelbaugh was all time awful. I didn't really consider the other guys because they barely played. Mirer did net us that draft pick but fuck, it was horrible watching him play. The dude was a turnover machine. Kinda like Jameis Winston on his bad days without the upside of the good days.

 

[Robotech]

Oh, she's being totally serious. Thinks he's HOF material. Fwiw, I think Cinci's best is Kenny Anderson by a significant margin, then Boomer. Sadly, after Boomer, Dalton but there is a massive gap.

LOL. I didn't know Dalton had diehard fans who thought he was great. I don't think he's terrible, though he's had some terrible games. He lasted long in the starting role, so he gets credit for that, but I've always seen him as an average QB.

 

[Robotech]

Yeah, that 92 season, although only 1/2 a season from Gelbaugh was all time awful. I didn't really consider the other guys because they barely played. Mirer did net us that draft pick but fuck, it was horrible watching him play. The dude was a turnover machine. Kinda like Jameis Winston on his bad days without the upside of the good days.

I thought Mirer was going to be so good. I bought into the Notre Dame hype. Thought he could be the next Montana I was a diehard Irish fan then. I wished the Niners would somehow trade up and draft him so that we could continue the line of great QB's from Montana to Young to Mirer. LOL.

 

[Dr. Strangelove]

LOL. I didn't know Dalton had diehard fans who thought he was great. I don't think he's terrible, though he's had some terrible games. He lasted long in the starting role, so he gets credit for that, but I've always seen him as an average QB.

Yeah, he actually can be good at times and isn't terrible most of the time but he seems to wilt in the spotlight. I think it's all mental with him. But he does turn the ball over way too much when the pressure ramps up.

 

[wazzu31]

No way was Sonny the best QB to play in Washington. This guy never started a playoff game ever, played in only one and threw 3 ints. Worst QB in the HOF, and makes Romo a first ballot HOF'er based on his qualifications.

Best Washington QB remains TCU's finest, Slinging Sammy Baugh.

The Redskins best is either Mark Rypien or Jack Thompson.

 

[TP76]

No way freind! Tony Collins was the worst!

Tony Eason? Tony Collins was a RB, and a damn good one for us.

 

[Southieinnc]

Tony Eason? Tony Collins was a RB, and a damn good one for us.

Bad memory. tried to forget his name. Yes, Tony Eason, now never mention his name again.....

 

[Schmoopy1000]

Bad memory. tried to forget his name. Yes, Tony Eason, now never mention his name again.....

Not a good time to point out he was drafted before marino?