RoboticDreams
JM8CH10
Roethlisberger's had an amazing career, but I don't think he was a bigger part of winning than Eli. Eli played amazingly in the postseason. Like Flacco did last year.
The reason I say that is this: New York was able to rush Brady with their front 4 and pressure him enough to disrupt him. He was still good enough to give his team the lead but the Pats D couldn't stop miracle plays. I've seen flashes where Eli has been very good. I've also seen him be very bad. That's not the indicator that I look for in a hall of famer. At least Ben has been fairly consistent.