Difference in QB eras

[RaZon]

60 minute man for 6 of those seasons, so yes.

Dude, we all played both ways in high school ball, no big deal.

 

[RaZon]

So Sammy Baugh gets drafted out of TCU he goes to the Niners who dumped JimmyG.

So (just as he was in his era) how does he do?

 

[RaZon]

Who can name all those studs on defense when Baugh played? Stud pass rushers, backers, cornerbacks, who?

 

[RaZon]

Ok ok bored with it.

How about triplets?
QB/RB/WR

Cowboys....Staubach/Emmitt/Irvin
Giants.....Eli/Tiki/Toomer???
Eagles....McNabb/Montgomery/Carmichael all 6-7 of him
Redskins....Jurgenson/Diesel/Taylor?
Niners....Montana/Gore/Rice
Rams....Warner/Dickerson/Bruce
Cards....Hart/Otis/Fitz
Seahawks....Wilson/Alexander/Largent
Falcons....Ryan/Riggs/Julio
Saints.....Drew/McAlister/Thomas
Panthers....Newton/Williams/Smith
Buc;s.....Testerverede?/Wilder/House?
Packers....Rodgers/Taylor/Lofton
Bears....Luckman/Payton/Marshall???
Lions...Stafford/Barry/Megatron
Vikes....Tarkenton/Peterson/Moss

 

[RaZon]

AFC

Jets...Namath/Martin/Maynard
Bills...Kelly/O.J./Reed
Dolphins....Marino/Csonk/Clayton
Pats.....THE GOAT/Sam BAM/Morgan?
Raiders....The Snake/Allen/Brown
Chargers.....Rivers/LT/Alworth
Chiefs....Mahomes/Charles/Taylor
Broncos....Elway/Davis/Smith
Steelers....Big Ben/Franco/Brown
Browns.....Otto/Brown/Warfield???
Bengals....Boomer/Dillon/Green?
Jags....Brunell/Taylor/Smith
Oilers...Moon/Campbell/Hennighan
Titans....Tannehill/Henry/ah,,,hmmm/
Texans....Watson/Foster/Johnson
Colts.....Peyton/Edgerrin/Harrison

Nothing set in stone up there.

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

So Sammy Baugh gets drafted out of TCU he goes to the Niners who dumped JimmyG.

So (just as he was in his era) how does he do?

Why does his era matter to today

 

[RaZon]

Why does his era matter to today

It will go like this....

With todays nutrition and.....

Well I'm not talking about that, I am talking about just as he was back in the 30;s. Not some modern version.

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

It will go like this....

With todays nutrition and.....

Well I'm not talking about that, I am talking about just as he was back in the 30;s. Not some modern version.

Can't compare.

 

[RaZon]

Can't compare.

I totally agree.

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

I totally agree.

I would also say a lot of these players couldn't hack it back then.

 

[RaZon]

I would also say a lot of these players couldn't hack it back then.

Give me the name of one current NFL player where you doubt he could make it in the 30;s, who?

Imagine this vs 30;s defense

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

Give me the name of one current NFL player where you doubt he could make it in the 30;s, who?

Imagine this vs 30;s defense

Different era of football but since you asked I'll give you Tribs.

 

[RaZon]

Different era of football but since you asked I'll give you Tribs.

Yeah I know, ha!!!

So who is it that couldn't hack the 30;?

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

Yeah I know, ha!!!

With the amount of rules changes, past guys that you talk about could have solid NFL careers.

 

[RaZon]

With the amount of rules changes, past guys that you talk about could have solid NFL careers.

Who from the 30;s other than maybe Don Hutson?

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

Who?

Any player on offense back in the day who was a notch below HoF level probably could have had a chance making the HoF under todays rules.

 

[RaZon]

Any player on offense back in the day who was a notch below HoF level probably could have had a chance making the HoF under todays rules.

And I totally agree back in their era.

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

And I totally agree back in their era.

And in this era with the revamped of rules favoring the offense.

 

[RaZon]

And in this era with the revamped of rules favoring the offense.

Ah, nobody other than maybe Don Hutson from the 30's might make ityoday, regardless of rules.

 

[sonnyblack65]

I would also say a lot of these players couldn't hack it back then.

Yeah Rodgers would run of the field, and into the arms of his man if #58 was looking at him