Coach of the Year Thread

[Fountain City Blues]

Any names you have in mind? Me personally I have Adam Gase if he can manage the Dolphins into the playoffs.

 

[old1r1sh]

Del Rio or whoever the fuck the HC for Tampa is nowadays

 

[redseat]

Jeff Fisher













Oh, wait

 

[Great Dayne]

Jack Del Rio

booked

 

[Manster7588]

Jim Caldwell (Detroit) and Jason Garrett have to be in the conversation.

 

[NWPATSFAN]

BB. Starting Garappollo, Brisett no Gronk, traded away arguably the two best defenders. Tied for the best record in the NFL. 119 + point differenial. Cyrus Jones fumbling almost every other punt/ko.

 

[bksballer89]

Jeff Fisher is at the top of my list

 

[NEPatsfan]

BB. Starting Garappollo, Brisett no Gronk, traded away arguably the two best defenders. Tied for the best record in the NFL. 119 + point differenial. Cyrus Jones fumbling almost every other punt/ko.

How is this award not named after BB, and handed to him every year before the season starts until his retirement?

 

[Hank Kingsley]

There can be only one.

Bill.

No Brady first 4. Gronk out basically all year. No Chandler Jones, no Jamie Collins, no Amendola, etc.

11-2.

As much as I like Dallas, their 11-2 in no way resembles the NE 11-2 after this past week's games.

I know a fart when I see it and Dallas farted.

I know a shellacking when I see it and that's what the Pats served up to a "good" team.

Do I think Garrett deserves Coach of the Year? Not a chance in hell.

But Bill? Bill über alles......

 

[NWPATSFAN]

How is this award not named after BB, and handed to him every year before the season starts until his retirement?

Because Lord Goddell said so.

 

[cdumler7]

Jason Garrett is at the top of my list. The Patriots were without their starting QB for 4-games. The Cowboys have been without theirs for the entire season. Throw in it seems like half their starting defense has been suspended yet week in and week out they find ways to get it done. Dez Bryant has been hurt and Witten is getting up in years yet with 2 rookies leading the way they have had one of the most efficient offenses in the entire league.

Also to add to it they have played in maybe the 2nd toughest division in football behind the AFC West. 3 teams with winning records and including the Cowboys 2 of the top 3 in wins in the NFC.

 

[NEPatsfan]

Jason Garrett is at the top of my list. The Patriots were without their starting QB for 4-games. The Cowboys have been without theirs for the entire season. Throw in it seems like half their starting defense has been suspended yet week in and week out they find ways to get it done. Dez Bryant has been hurt and Witten is getting up in years yet with 2 rookies leading the way they have had one of the most efficient offenses in the entire league.

Also to add to it they have played in maybe the 2nd toughest division in football behind the AFC West. 3 teams with winning records and including the Cowboys 2 of the top 3 in wins in the NFC.

As far as BB goes, you could save sentences and just state "I hate all things Patriots, therefore he would never get my nod".

Would be so much simpler.

 

[cdumler7]

As far as BB goes, you could save sentences and just state "I hate all things Patriots, therefore he would never get my nod".

Would be so much simpler.

Well if you would read what I write on this board you would see I have a high level of respect for BB. I've said he is the best coach the NFL in NFL history. I just don't think he should win the award this year. He has been hampered in the past because he is just always so successful they usually give it to another coach that has taken a team from worst to first but this year I just think Garrett when you look at the circumstances he is the more deserving of the two.

 

[NEPatsfan]

Well if you would read what I write on this board you would see I have a high level of respect for BB. I've said he is the best coach the NFL in NFL history. I just don't think he should win the award this year. He has been hampered in the past because he is just always so successful they usually give it to another coach that has taken a team from worst to first but this year I just think Garrett when you look at the circumstances he is the more deserving of the two.

So you agree he should just win every year until he retires. Awesome, we found common ground.

 

[GNG]

Jason Garrett...

 

[Fountain City Blues]

Cdumler has always been pretty respectful regardless of affiliation. Saying he's a Pats hater is silly.

 

[cdumler7]

So you agree he should just win every year until he retires. Awesome, we found common ground.

Reading comprehension is a very underappreciated quality these days. Just because I believe he is the best coach in NFL history doesn't mean that I think he does the best coaching job every year. I think Pats fans would agree that some of Belichick's decisions down the stretch last year possibly cost them home field in the playoffs and a much better shot at the Super Bowl. So while he is great he is not perfect. Again I just think Garrett has done the better job especially when you look at the entire picture of both team's seasons.

 

[NEPatsfan]

Reading comprehension is a very underappreciated quality these days. Just because I believe he is the best coach in NFL history doesn't mean that I think he does the best coaching job every year. I think Pats fans would agree that some of Belichick's decisions down the stretch last year possibly cost them home field in the playoffs and a much better shot at the Super Bowl. So while he is great he is not perfect. Again I just think Garrett has done the better job especially when you look at the entire picture of both team's seasons.

Who's the other coach that has won on his level the last 3 decades? Clearly there must be someone since you aren't biased.

 

[Fountain City Blues]

If COY was literally the best coach, it would just be some hodge podge of Hoody, Reid, and maybe Carroll basically every year. With Hoody winning most of the time.

 

[NWPATSFAN]

Reading comprehension is a very underappreciated quality these days. Just because I believe he is the best coach in NFL history doesn't mean that I think he does the best coaching job every year. I think Pats fans would agree that some of Belichick's decisions down the stretch last year possibly cost them home field in the playoffs and a much better shot at the Super Bowl. So while he is great he is not perfect. Again I just think Garrett has done the better job especially when you look at the entire picture of both team's seasons.

Cd I agree with everything except the Garrett piece. We all know JJ coaches that team. Garrett for Assistant coach of the year.