Chris Harris said Wilson is better than Luck

[dkmightyhammer]

I thought this thread would die over the weekend, but since it's still alive and kicking I may as well toss some more fuel on the fire.


Peter King's article today has Wilson 4th in the MVP race. He mentions Luck but Manning beats him out for the 5th spot.


DeMarco Murray, Philip Rivers lead NFL MVP race; Steve Smith Sr., more | The MMQB with Peter King

 

[bksballer89]

Who cares about some mvp race 4 weeks into the year? This is like mentioning baseball cy young race at the end of may. Luck has been sensational and this will be by far his best season

 

[BoBlake]

I have zero doubt that if Luck was on the Seahawks his numbers would be more impressive than they are while playing for a mediocre team. Luck has been forced to carry the team for the majority of his 2+ seasons with lesser talent while Wilson hasn't for the most part hasn't had to. You really can't compare the stats when their situations are totally different.

You may be right.

When you compare Luck's team to Tannehill's team, they are very similar. As such, Tannehill has better numbers than Luck does.

Tannehill > Luck (in real numbers, not potential)

 

[Mondo Jay]

Luck put up vastly superior numbers to Wilson this past weekend.

 

[BoBlake]

Luck put up vastly superior numbers to Wilson this past weekend.

LOL, fact.

 

[bksballer89]

Tannenhill is better than luck? What numbers arr you looking at?

 

[bksballer89]

Tannenhill
2012- 58% comp, 3294 yds, 6.8 per throw, 12tds, 18 turnovers.
2013- 60% comp, 3913 yds, 6.6 per throw, 24 tds, and 23 turnovers
2014- 60% comp, 902 yds, 5.8 per throw, 6 tds, & 4 turnovers

Luck

2012- 54% comp, 4374 yds, 7 yds per attempt, 23 tds, & 27 turnovers
2013- 60% comp, 3822 yds, 6.7 per attempt, 23 tds, & 14 turnovers.
2014- 69% comp, 1305 yards, 7.8 per attempt, 13 tds, & 4 turnovers.

Tannenhill was never better than luck. The only year you can debate were their rookie years but luck still win that battle when you analyze the numbers

 

[sonnyblack65]

Tannenhill is better than luck? What numbers arr you looking at?

Someone was being sarcastic Tannenhill couldn't shine Lucks shoes. There only a handful of QB's that are currently better but that can change in future seeing this is only his 3rd season.

 

[Desean12345]

Someone was being sarcastic Tannenhill couldn't shine Lucks shoes. There only a handful of QB's that are currently better but that can change in future seeing this is only his 3rd season.

As of now, there are about 5-6 quarterbacks who are better than Luck. After this year, there will probably only be 2.

 

[Manning2Luck_uJelly]

As of now, there are about 5-6 quarterbacks who are better than Luck. .

....and one of them is not Russell Wilson

 

[sonnyblack65]

As of now, there are about 5-6 quarterbacks who are better than Luck. After this year, there will probably only be 2.

I can agree with that Rodgers will be one and Manning if he can keep it up . I think Brady and Brees might be on back 9

 

[BoBlake]

As of now, there are about 5-6 quarterbacks who are better than Luck. After this year, there will probably only be 2.

Luck does have a pretty cake schedule. I could see some of his numbers being in the top 3.

That team has basically no chance at the Lombardi this year though, so whatever.

 

[flyerhawk]

Luck put up vastly superior numbers to Wilson this past weekend.

No doubt. It was like Wilson wasn't even playing.

 

[Cyder]

No doubt. It was like Wilson wasn't even playing.

He still had better stats than Gino Smith. Then again, so did I

 

[flyerhawk]

....and one of them is not Russell Wilson

For a guy that doesn't care about this debate you seem quite determined to make sure everyone agrees with you.

 

[flyerhawk]

He still had better stats than Gino Smith. Then again, so did I

Smith looked really good, I thought, last week. This week he went back to being dreadful.

 

[Cyder]

Smith looked really good, I thought, last week. This week he went back to being dreadful.

Smith was terrible last week too. His turnovers are obscene. Leads the league in pick 6's the last 2 years. He's a lot like Russell Wilson if you removed Wilson's brains, talent and ability to scramble

 

[Manning2Luck_uJelly]

For a guy that doesn't care about this debate you seem quite determined to make sure everyone agrees with you.

I just find it amusing how easy it is to get under the skin of Hawk fans....lol

 

[flyerhawk]

I just find it amusing how easy it is to get under the skin of Hawk fans....lol

So you freely admit to being nothing more than a troll. I have to admire the honesty I guess.

 

[Manning2Luck_uJelly]

So you freely admit to being nothing more than a troll. I have to admire the honesty I guess.

we're all trolls