POLL Andrew Luck: HOF?

[rmilia1]

Okay, name them...

Top of my head

Andersen
Stabler
McNabb
Kosar
Gabriel
Cunningham
Hart
Simms
Hadl
Conerly
Kilmer
Esiason
Plunkett
Brodie
Palmer
Testaverde

And that's without any serious thought . I'm sure I could come up with 10-15 more if I thought for 15 minutes .

 

[Lake Shore Drive]

Absolutely, easily a HOF career and first ballot too!!

Respectfully,
Mrs. Andrew Luck

 

[Clayton]

Only way he gets in is if he unretires in two years and lands on the Patriots as Brady's replacement

 

[Nosferatu]

Top of my head

Andersen
Stabler
McNabb
Kosar
Gabriel
Cunningham
Hart
Simms
Hadl
Conerly
Kilmer
Esiason
Plunkett
Brodie
Palmer
Testaverde

And that's without any serious thought . I'm sure I could come up with 10-15 more if I thought for 15 minutes .

Stabler is already in... And what no Steve Bartkowski?

 

[beardown07]

Only way he gets in is if he unretires in two years and lands on the Patriots as Brady's replacement

Who would want him? What a fucking bitch. Frank Reich prolly made him cry.

 

[rmilia1]

Stabler is already in... And what no Steve Bartkowski?

Lol no Bartkowski. Just missed . Of course there are also about 5-7 guys playing right now also more deserving than Luck ( aside from the guys we consider locks ). Basically Luck is an injury prone Kurt Warner without the MVPs and ring lol

 

[RememberTheKoy]

Depends on how his XFL career plays out.

 

[Nosferatu]

Lol no Bartkowski. Just missed . Of course there are also about 5-7 guys playing right now also more deserving than Luck ( aside from the guys we consider locks ). Basically Luck is an injury prone Kurt Warner without the MVPs and ring lol

Jeff George > Andrew Luck

 

[rmilia1]

Jeff George > Andrew Luck

Lol no . But better doesn't have much to do with the HoF. That's more a resume deal .

 

[UVA_Guy81]

If he could’ve stayed healthy for another 10 years give or take and put up similar stats as he has... possibly. But his career was way too short and injuries caused him to miss way too much time to even be considered for the Hall of Fame.

 

[megalodon30]

He retires with a playoff QB rating 17 points worse than Tim Tebow.

Not exactly a ringing HOF endorsement.

 

[broncosmitty]

Depends on how his XFL career plays out.

It'll be interesting to see which team he is placed on.

 

[Ojb81]

Heellll fucking no

Someone get a mod in here to delete this ridiculous thread

 

[Southieinnc]

Dammit, I don't care, I just wanted him to spend the time coming up with 30+ QB's and then laughing at his choices!

Oh, the things we do to each other.....

 

[megalodon30]

It'll be interesting to see which team he is placed on.

I'm betting he goes to the Portland Injured Reserves.

 

[broncosmitty]

Prolly deserves its own thread, but I do wonder which XFL team others think he plays for.



Houston Roughnecks imo.

 

[knowyourenemy]

There are literally 30+ guys not in the Hall with better cases than Luck ..so.... No

Luck has more career touchdown passes and more 4th quarter comebacks than Troy Aikman and he did it in like 3 seasons.

 

[knowyourenemy]

He retires with a playoff QB rating 17 points worse than Tim Tebow.

Not exactly a ringing HOF endorsement.

Hmmm.

Next thread...Tim Tebow: HOF?

 

[Tapey]

Hmmm.

Next thread...Tim Tebow: HOF?

Now that’s something I can get behind

 

[knowyourenemy]

donovan mcnabb. Yeah im serious

“I’m not hesitating on that. I am a Hall of Famer,” McNabb said. “My numbers speak for themselves.”

Donovan McNabb: 'I Am A Hall Of Famer'