Ok, Suspend disbelief/all of these teams go undefeated/who goes to the playoff ???

thunderc · Sep 16, 2019

Gatorchip said:
Oklahoma, Alabama, Clemson, and second place SEC.

I don’t see an unbeaten Ohio State getting left out.

tducey · Sep 16, 2019

Alabama
Clemson
Ohio State
Oklahoma

rmilia1 · Sep 16, 2019

A more interesting scenario is if Utah and ND are both unbeaten but Clemson , Bama, OSU and OU all have 1 loss as conference champs

Gatorchip · Sep 16, 2019

thunderc said:
I don’t see an unbeaten Ohio State getting left out.

Me neither... but think about how fun that would be here?

TheDayMan · Sep 16, 2019

Trench Mob said:
Lol come on now. They made Stanford looked completely out of their element.

Stanford is clearly not very good. Probably an unlucky year to have them on their schedule. But if Pac 12 teams aren’t gonna get any credit for beating them, UCF doesn’t either. If they turn around and look tough in conference after looking like dogshit for the start of the season, it’ll be worth noting.

Chewbaccer · Sep 16, 2019

The 4 teams with a P5 schedule and a 13th data point

Chewbaccer · Sep 16, 2019

Trench Mob said:
Lol come on now. They made Stanford looked completely out of their element.

So did USC

OregonDucks · Sep 16, 2019

outofyourmind said:
Utah
Ohio State
Oklahoma
Alabama
Clemson
Notre Dame
UCF

Which 4 go?

Who should? Ohio State, Alabama, Clemson, Notre Dame.

Who does? Alabama, Clemson, Oklahoma, Notre Dame.

BoiseMike19 · Sep 16, 2019

Gatorchip said:
Oklahoma, Alabama, Clemson, and second place SEC.

I could see this if an undefeated Alabama loses in the CCG to any team from the East and tOSU stumbles. Don't see the PAC or anyone from the BIG other than maybe tOSU fucking this up at the end of the day.

LawDawg · Sep 16, 2019

Its going to be UGA, Bama, tOSU and Clemson

or

UGA, tOSU, OU and Clemson.

dtgold88 · Sep 16, 2019

nathans8823 said:
I would still say no, our strength of schedule is lacking right now, and no conference championship for us.

Very true, but could end up with a couple nice road wins at UGA and UM.

If TAM falls off a cliff I could see Clemson getting left out.

Gatorchip · Sep 16, 2019

LawDawg said:
Its going to be UGA, Bama, tOSU and Clemson

or

UGA, tOSU, OU and Clemson.

In the OP scenario, you think undefeated Alabama get passed over for 2 loss UGA?

bamafan4evr12 · Sep 16, 2019

LawDawg said:
You really think ND is going to beat us this coming weekend? Because that's the only way what you say is most likely is happening.

OP said hypothetically all these teams go undefeated....

bamafan4evr12 · Sep 16, 2019

Blackshirts BLVD said:
I think we can agree that the teams that are blue bloods will get in first. Secondly, there is no denying the team that went undefeated last year and won it (regardless of not being a traditional blue blood)... BUT I don't think a 12-0 Notre Dame gets in over a 13-0 Ohio State. I just don't see it, nor do I think it should happen.

ND definitely has a brand name, but I don't think that is enough.

I agree, I just don't buy that they will keep ND out. I mean you could trade OSU and Oklahoma in that scenario...they would be the odd man out in that scenario

LawDawg · Sep 16, 2019

Gatorchip said:
In the OP scenario, you think undefeated Alabama get passed over for 2 loss UGA?

UGA won't have 2 losses, but I wasn't following OP's rules. Will show myself to the door.

bamafan4evr12 · Sep 16, 2019

Wild Turkey said:
1. No undefeated SEC or B1G team is going to get left out period.
2. If any undefeated team from a P5 conference gets left out then the playoffs will be expanded the next year. Until it happens it will be 4 teams.

And it'll happen eventually

dtgold88 · Sep 16, 2019

thunderc said:
I don’t see an unbeaten Ohio State getting left out.

Especially if it's UGA who, in this case, would have at least 2 losses.

963BUSC · Sep 16, 2019

In
Ohio State
Oklahoma
Alabama
Clemson

Rightfully pissed.
Notre Dame
Utah
UCF

Red_Alert · Sep 16, 2019

Wild Turkey said:
1. No undefeated SEC or B1G team is going to get left out period.
2. If any undefeated team from a P5 conference gets left out then the playoffs will be expanded the next year. Until it happens it will be 4 teams.

bamafan4evr12 said:
And it'll happen eventually

I don't think that's ever happened. Even before the days of expanded schedules and CCGs where it is now even more difficult.

Deep Creek · Sep 16, 2019

bamafan4evr12 said:
And it'll happen eventually

If it does, then those conferences will have let one team get way ahead of them...which shouldn't happen.

Wild Turkey · Sep 16, 2019

Red_Alert said:
I don't think that's ever happened. Even before the days of expanded schedules and CCGs where it is now even more difficult.

E

bamafan4evr12 said:
And it'll happen eventually

unlikely

Ok, Suspend disbelief/all of these teams go undefeated/who goes to the playoff ???

Well-Known Member

Sports discussion

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Day Butt Ass the sadgaydayboy

Illustrious Potentate

Illustrious Potentate

Oregon Is Faster

10 inch Member

Sic 'em Dawgs ... woof!

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Rising Tide

Rising Tide

Sic 'em Dawgs ... woof!

Rising Tide

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

^^ Privileged ^^

Well-Known Member

Sarcasm: Just one of my many services.

Similar threads