IMO there will be plenty of spontaneous cheering in a home opener against a hated but respected opponent. Everybody worried about it being manufactured is full of it as far as I'm concerned.
I'm sure we at least came close at some point if we didn't break it, even if it was unofficial when we did it. I agree that it shouldn't have been announced to begin with. The focus should be on the 49ers, not some record. I see people complain occasionally about how cheering already seems more scripted and less spontaneous than it used to be because of the pleas for noise by the teams on their scoreboards/jumbotrons and the amped up party music that blares from the speakers all the time. This would seem to follow that pattern of "Okay... go ahead and cheer now". If they hadn't announced that this was happening, it would have been more of an accomplishment when we broke the record.
What if the time Guinness decides to measure the noise is just before the game starts, when they have some "official" standing at midfield with a microphone who says "Ok, everyone yell on 3....?" Are we full of it then?IMO there will be plenty of spontaneous cheering in a home opener against a hated but respected opponent. Everybody worried about it being manufactured is full of it as far as I'm concerned.
What if the time Guinness decides to measure the noise is just before the game starts, when they have some "official" standing at midfield with a microphone who says "Ok, everyone yell on 3....?" Are we full of it then?
I just think it's different to gauge a sound level like that from a spontaneous eruption like the Beast Quake as opposed to some moron saying "everyone yell as loud as you can."