Is Tom Brady really the greatest QB of all time?

[Ickey Shuffle]

Peyton Manning, then everyone else. He wasn't a system QB, he WAS the system. He controlled the entire NFL with his brain alone. The way he commanded the line of scrimmage was something magical. It didn't matter who was in front of him. A pass rush wasn't getting to him. Then his unhuman accuracy basically ended the game before it even started.

Added bonus, he wasn't a bitch. Tough as the next guy. He's sorely missed.

 

[flyingelvis]

Peyton Manning, then everyone else. He wasn't a system QB, he WAS the system. He controlled the entire NFL with his brain alone. The way he commanded the line of scrimmage was something magical. It didn't matter who was in front of him. A pass rush wasn't getting to him. Then his unhuman accuracy basically ended the game before it even started.

Added bonus, he wasn't a bitch. Tough as the next guy. He's sorely missed.

Oh please. All true, until the Lombardi was on the line. Then all the magic went up in a puff of smoke.

Manning is in the top 5 for his body of work but can't carry Brady's jock for what matters, winning when shit's on the line.

 

[SteelersPride]

Peyton Manning, then everyone else. He wasn't a system QB, he WAS the system. He controlled the entire NFL with his brain alone. The way he commanded the line of scrimmage was something magical. It didn't matter who was in front of him. A pass rush wasn't getting to him. Then his unhuman accuracy basically ended the game before it even started.

Added bonus, he wasn't a bitch. Tough as the next guy. He's sorely missed.

to bad his brain couldnt handle stress

 

[Mannyrules]

This thread sucks.

 

[Dude]

Playing in the Patriots system is the difference.

He is the system. You have a system within a system. Remarkable.

 

[steelerssb]

You had me at "You just can't go off Super Bowl wins...."

I just can't believe Philip Rivers and his never even appearing in a Super Bowl self would say that.

 

[Dude]

You don't even need to account for intangibles . He's the greatest because his resume is VASTLY superior to everyone else. There's no way to claim he's not the greatest unless you start randomly assigning cherry picked opinion based nonsense .

Brady is the only QB in history who doesn't need to change the definition of greatest in order to be considered the greatest . All other QBs need to utilize opinions instead of facts .

Yes. The accomplishments speak for themselves.

 

[steelerssb]

It’s the intangibles that put him ahead of other great QBs. Things the “eye test” does not see or measure.

I tend to agree here.

Peyton is probably the most technically sound QB I've seen (i.e. arm strength, accuracy, etc.) but Brady just does it time and time again when it matters and without the most talented groups around him.

 

[ellupo]

The best dont get suspended for cheating.

 

[Dude]

I tend to agree here.

Peyton is probably the most technically sound QB I've seen (i.e. arm strength, accuracy, etc.) but Brady just does it time and time again when it matters and without the most talented groups around him.

Yep. Discipline, leading by example, will to win, fire in the belly.

 

[NWPATSFAN]

Peyton Manning, then everyone else. He wasn't a system QB, he WAS the system. He controlled the entire NFL with his brain alone. The way he commanded the line of scrimmage was something magical. It didn't matter who was in front of him. A pass rush wasn't getting to him. Then his unhuman accuracy basically ended the game before it even started.

Added bonus, he wasn't a bitch. Tough as the next guy. He's sorely missed.

With all those acolades one would think he'd have a better record vs Brady. I mean 6-11 isn't bad right?
Maybe if all 17 meetings could've been played in a dome PayAton may have done better?

What do you think?

 

[Cave_Johnson]

Oh please. All true, until the Lombardi was on the line. Then all the magic went up in a puff of smoke.

Manning is in the top 5 for his body of work but can't carry Brady's jock for what matters, winning when shit's on the line.

Dude had a winning record against Brady in the post-season tho.

 

[NWPATSFAN]

Dude had a winning record against Brady in the post-season tho.

Let's not allow facts to get in the way

 

[Center Ice]

Philip Rivers explains why Tom Brady might not be the greatest quarterback of all time

Philip who?

 

[Cave_Johnson]

Let's not allow facts to get in the way
View attachment 214519

Cute meme. You could easily make one showing the opposite of what that one shows.

The claim was that Manning couldn't hold Brady's jock when shit was on the line.

Manning has a winning record against Brady in the playoffs. When shit is on the line.

 

[Southieinnc]

Philip Rivers explains why Tom Brady might not be the greatest quarterback of all time

Written by John BreecH?

"John Breech from CBS has picked 0 of 0 NFL games correctly. This is the 0th best out of all 0 experts.
John Breech has predicted the correct winner of NFL games 0% of the time."

"John Breech has been at CBS Sports since July 2011 and currently spends most of his time writing about the NFL. He's believed to be one of only three people in the world who thinks that Andy Dalton will win a playoff game some day. The Ohio native now lives in San Diego"

 

[NWPATSFAN]

Cute meme. You could easily make one showing the opposite of what that one shows.

The claim was that Manning couldn't hold Brady's jock when shit was on the line.

Manning has a winning record against Brady in the playoffs. When shit is on the line.

Fitting how Manning earned the nickname CPT One and Done.

 

[Southieinnc]

Rivers, of course, is spot on.

Rivers has as many Superbowl wins as his hero Marino.
No go figure why Rivers would downplay SB wins.....

 

[NWPATSFAN]

Rivers has as many Superbowl wins as his hero Marino.
No go figure why Rivers would downplay SB wins.....

^this guy gets it

 

[Cave_Johnson]

Fitting how Manning earned the nickname CPT One and Done.

Hey, he didn't get to play against a Brady-lead team in the first round every year.