Top 25 Qb's Of All Time

[GNG]

All-time players in no order...

Jim Brown
Jerry Rice
Walter Payton
Lawrence Taylor
Reggie White
Tom Brady
Joe Montana
Barry Sanders

Weak.

 

[GNG]

Stop GNGing.

It's what I do.

 

[Shanemansj13]

1. Otto Graham
2. Bart Starr
3. Tom Brady
4. Joe Montana
5. Roger Staubach
6. Johnny Unitas
7. Aaron Rodgers
8. Brett Favre
9. Dan Marino
10. Peyton Manning

No

 

[GNG]

No

Yes.

 

[Schmoopy1000]

Starr has the best post-season record of any QB in NFL history. You need to get your facts straight.

pretty sure that is what he was eluding too.

 

[GNG]

pretty sure that is what he was eluding too.

No, he wasn't.

 

[Shanemansj13]

All-time players in no order...

Jim Brown
Jerry Rice
Walter Payton
Lawrence Taylor
Reggie White
Tom Brady
Joe Montana
Barry Sanders

No way Barry is in the top 8

My top 8....

Joe Montana
Tom Brady
Reggie White
LT
Jerry Rice
Ronnie Lott
Jim Brown
Walter Payton

I think after the top 7 there are a ton of players that are right there though...

Rod Woodson
Mean Joe Greene
Deion Sanders
Peyton Manning
Dick Butkus
Ray Lewis

 

[Shanemansj13]

Yes.

Nobody has Starr as the best QB except you. I could see putting him in the top 10 though

 

[richig07]

Starr has the best post-season record of any QB in NFL history. You need to get your facts straight.

Well, my facts are very straight. I mentioned his post-season success. He only played 10 games. Most of his titles required 1 or 2 post-season victories. It's one of the more impressive post-season resumes, to be certain. However, it's a small sample size and was during a very different time period.

If I were to use that as my lone (or at least a major) barometer for ranking all-time QB's. I would have to include Jim Plunkett, who went 8-2 to Bart Starr's 9-1. Along with other guys like Luckman, Morrall who went 5-1.

 

[Shanemansj13]

If you don't have Starr in your top 10 your rankings are not credible.

You have no clue man. Give up lol

 

[richig07]

No way Barry is in the top 8

My top 8....

Joe Montana
Tom Brady
Reggie White
LT
Jerry Rice
Ronnie Lott
Jim Brown
Walter Payton

I think after the top 7 there are a ton of players that are right there though...

Rod Woodson
Mean Joe Greene
Deion Sanders
Peyton Manning
Dick Butkus
Ray Lewis

Yeah, I thought about Butkus, Deion and Joe Greene. I should have possibly included Lott. If I were to do an even 10, two of them would be in there.

And I don't know... Barry was pretty fantastic. I suppose he wasn't the receiver or blocker that Payton was, though. Not as well rounded as Jim or Payton. You may have a point.

 

[Shanemansj13]

Starr has the best post-season record of any QB in NFL history. You need to get your facts straight.

You do know his team only made the playoffs in 6 years out of 16 he was in the league, you could say 14 bc he didn't play full seasons in two of those. Only had to win 2 games to win a Championship. Also, only 14-15 teams, half what they have now. Less competition. That doesn't mean he wasn't a great QB but dwindles that resume.

 

[broncosmitty]

EVER?

Did not follow his HS seasons closely.


But I do know, he was still short back then.

 

[broncosmitty]

Starr has the best post-season record of any QB in NFL history. You need to get your facts straight.

His regular season record isn't as good as Rodgers though.


Who I would take first tbh. Followed by Manning.

 

[Ricky Roma]

Interesting list.....obviously not how I would rank them but whatever. The first thing that did come to mind is that Drew Brees is simply way too high. I like the dude....been a great player. HOF player.....but he is not the 6th best QB in the history of the NFL. No way do I put him ahead of guys like Rodgers, Staubach, Marino...and maybe even guys who didn't even make this list.

Somewhere on a top 25 list of all time QB's, the name Dan Fouts should appear.

 

[BostonBlackie]

All-time players in no order...

Jim Brown
Jerry Rice
Walter Payton
Lawrence Taylor
Reggie White
Tom Brady
Joe Montana
Barry Sanders

That's a good no order list. I might stick Muñoz, Parker, or Hog Hannah in there to bring it up to ten.

 

[BostonBlackie]

Jim Brown
Reggie White
Lawrence Taylor
Don Hutson

Being partial to recievers I like seeing Hutson.

 

[Shanemansj13]

That's a good no order list. I might stick Muñoz, Parker, or Hog Hannah in there to bring it up to ten.

If you are gonna stick an OLineman in there why not stick the best ever...Bruce

 

[Wazmankg]

Jurgensen should be in there somewhere.

 

[BostonBlackie]

Jurgensen should be in there somewhere.

Jurgensen steps into the huddle, gives the play: "Nigge8s go long."