Top 25 Qb's Of All Time

[GNG]

I knew GB had 3 very good/great QB's , 3 in top 13 is impressive and you find the list funny?

Starr should have been rated higher.

 

[SteelersPride]

Hasn't missed a game.


Hasn't had a losing season.


That's a list that's hard to get on. There aren't 20 QBs I'd rather have.

EVER?

 

[SteelersPride]

How's that? Wilson hasn't had a running game or reliable line in years. He's not just who they run the game through. He's basically all they have. The guy has kept that team a contender on his lonesome over the past couple of years, IMO.

You said it right there, and also state no running game or line. SO no line, no running game, and you dont run the offense through an all time talent? something is up

 

[Shanemansj13]

Move Steve Young and Favre up.
Graham and Elway down.

1. Brady
2. Montana
3. Manning
4. Marino
5. Young
6. Rodgers
7. Unitas
8. Brees
9. Favre
10. Staubach

Just a quick list. 7-10 are close and any order doesn't bother me.

 

[ATL96Steeler]

Top 25 quarterbacks of all time: Patriots' Tom Brady leads list


This list seems pretty accurate ... I know it's always a matter of opinion, but I'm cool with Wilson at 18 even though I think he sneaks up a bit by the end of his career... Brady has earned the GOAT, and I think Montana and Manning are in the right spots...

Yeah, these all-time lists are always a little shewed one way or the other depending on the writer I guess. I have no issue with the 25, but how he's got them ranked I might move a couple of players around.

 

[Wamu]

1. Tommy Boy
2. Tommy Boy
3. Tommy Boy
4. Tommy Boy
5. Tommy Boy
6. Tommy Boy
7. Tommy Boy
8. Tommy Boy
9. Tommy Boy
10. Tommy Boy
11. Tommy Boy
12. Tommy Boy
13. Tommy Boy
14. Tommy Boy
15. Tommy Boy
16. Tommy Boy
17. Tommy Boy
18. Tommy Boy
19. Timmy Boy
20. Tommy Boy
21. Tommy Boy
22. Tommy Boy
23. Tommy Boy
24. Tommy Boy
25. Tommy Boy

fuck meeeechegan!

 

[BostonBlackie]

Actually after the top 4 to 5 what difference does it make? It's like the top players of all time.

No particular order.

Jim Brown
Lawrence Taylor
Tom Brady
Jerry Rice

Now what?

 

[boogiewithstu2007]

Not that bad a list. A few things I'd change. Notably Young and Favre in my top 10 ahead of Graham and Staubach but still a good list.

That's fair.....

 

[boogiewithstu2007]

Actually after the top 4 to 5 what difference does it make? It's like the top players of all time.

No particular order.

Jim Brown
Lawrence Taylor
Tom Brady
Jerry Rice

Now what?

Steve #@$% phuccing Largent !!!

 

[GNG]

Move Steve Young and Favre up.
Graham and Elway down.

1. Brady
2. Montana
3. Manning
4. Marino
5. Young
6. Rodgers
7. Unitas
8. Brees
9. Favre
10. Staubach

1. Otto Graham
2. Bart Starr
3. Tom Brady
4. Joe Montana
5. Roger Staubach
6. Johnny Unitas
7. Aaron Rodgers
8. Brett Favre
9. Dan Marino
10. Peyton Manning

 

[GNG]

Actually after the top 4 to 5 what difference does it make? It's like the top players of all time.

No particular order.

Jim Brown
Lawrence Taylor
Tom Brady
Jerry Rice

Jim Brown
Reggie White
Lawrence Taylor
Don Hutson

 

[GNG]

I have Staubach as the best QB from the teams he roots for and that's not gnging it

I have Starr ahead of Staubach.

 

[GNG]

His Boyfriend isn't #1.

I rated Otto Graham number #1 and don't have Rodgers in my top 5. You sure are a stupid mofo.

 

[GNG]

1. Brady
2. Montana
3. Manning
4. Marino
5. Rodgers
6. Brees
7. Unitas
8. Graham
9. Staubach
10. Favre

10 could go to Young, Favre, Starr, etc. I did this very fast.

If you don't have Starr in your top 10 your rankings are not credible.

 

[Manster7588]

I rated Otto Graham number #1 and don't have Rodgers in my top 5. You sure are a stupid mofo.

Stop GNGing.

 

[richig07]

If you don't have Starr in your top 10 your rankings are not credible.

Gee, I wonder if that has to do with him being a Packer. lol

Sorry, a guy who was never top 5 in TD's (or TD%) in any single season, was only top 5 in yardage once and only an all-pro once isn't exactly "auto" top ten for me.

His 3 seasons being 1st in INT% and CMP% are what boost him up to the fringe for me. Along with, of course, his post-season success.

 

[richig07]

I rated Otto Graham number #1 and don't have Rodgers in my top 5. You sure are a stupid mofo.

Graham is a great under the radar pick for "GOAT". I approve. He has a tremendous argument.

 

[richig07]

All-time players in no order...

Jim Brown
Jerry Rice
Walter Payton
Lawrence Taylor
Reggie White
Tom Brady
Joe Montana
Barry Sanders

 

[broncosmitty]

I gave up on the whole "Wilson is overrated" thing in the middle of Super Bowl 51 vs NE. The guy is simply great.

You don't even realize how good he is until your team plays against him either. He's such a pain in the fuckin ass.

I wrote an apology to Seahawk fans at one point.


Dude is an incredible football player.

 

[GNG]

Gee, I wonder if that has to do with him being a Packer. lol

Sorry, a guy who was never top 5 in TD's (or TD%) in any single season, was only top 5 in yardage once and only an all-pro once isn't exactly "auto" top ten for me.

His 3 seasons being 1st in INT% and CMP% are what boost him up to the fringe for me. Along with, of course, his post-season success.

Starr has the best post-season record of any QB in NFL history. You need to get your facts straight.