The Wrong Steve Smith Nominated for the HOF

[shopson67]

but he has no statistical merit to be there. as was stated, all 12 other WR's listed did what smith did in his career in a couple of seasons.

my thinking is some idiot saw "steve smith" and pulled the trigger too quickly before realizing the gaff. some guy saw a name on a list and got confused. sure, smith is eligible...

they got the wrong smith, made a mistake, and wont own it. its what the nfl does. why havent other "no merit at all" guys ever been nominated before? i cant recall any. they usually are there for a reason.

i never saw my man marv cook on any lists.

They don't need to own up to anything; only 5 players at most will get in out of that 108. Somebody has to be the worst of that group of 108 and will never get nominated again, and that just may be that Steve Smith.

 

[shopson67]

so it was a freakin mistake. the fan voted for the wrong steve smith because of the photo error.

So it was the league's fault, not the HOF committee.

 

[Rock Strongo]

So it was the league's fault, not the HOF committee.

its what ive been saying for 4 pages.

the nfl never owns up to a mistake.

 

[shopson67]

its what ive been saying for 4 pages.

the nfl never owns up to a mistake.

Like I said though, someone has to be #108 who has no chance of getting in. With a new class available next year, that 108th guy will never be nominated again, even if he was more deserving than that Steve Smith.