Where do you rank them?

[Balljim55]

I don't see how you can pit one against the other with any confidence considering all the other factors necessary for a QB to be successful. You have to have receivers, a running game, a quality O-line - good coaching, a good defense etc etc.
At best you put them in tiers. I put Brady, Rodgers and Brees in the top tier based on their play and accomplishments over an extended period. I would put Eli and Ben in the next tier and Ryan would go with the next group.
If I had to pick a QB for a must win game right now I would take Mr. Rodgers

 

[packerzrule]

It's whatever Hank. Ryan played great . The team lost because NE controlled the ball, as they had to, and because Shanny didn't coach to game situation . Blaming Ryan is weak , inaccurate and just trying to troll . But proceed

you know what is weaker?

failing to admit your star QB choked when it mattered most



EOT

 

[Great Dayne]

Rodgers is the best QB in the NFL IMO.

Thanks John Madden

 

[Hank Kingsley]

It's whatever Hank. Ryan played great . The team lost because NE controlled the ball, as they had to, and because Shanny didn't coach to game situation . Blaming Ryan is weak , inaccurate and just trying to troll . But proceed

Saying otherwise is the inaccurate thing.

I saw that 2nd half.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Saying otherwise is the inaccurate thing.

I saw that 2nd half.

Its amazing to me the lengths we will go to defend our QB's, yet have no problem throwing EVERYONE else under the bus........

 

[Great Dayne]

Honestly yes . I've never thought much of Bennett

I agree with you. He's a backup TE with a big mouth. Pats would've paid him if he was that good. Jarred Cook was a monster for us when healthy and I was shocked we let him go. Rodgers had a better connection with him than he ever did with Finley.

Packers running game will improve with Ty having a full off season to prepare and a bunch of young talented RB's to back him up. As far as the passing game the Pack added two young rookies, Davis has a year under his belt, Jordy has 1-2 more solid years left, Cobb is out to prove last year was a down year, and Adams is on a contract year. The line should be top five again. There's no reason Rodgers shouldn't dominate the entire season if he starts off the way he ended last year in the reg season and stays healthy. There were no drastic improvements but it should be better with experience and more of a veteran offense with exception of RB.

 

[rmilia1]

you know what is weaker?

failing to admit your star QB choked when it mattered most



EOT

If Ryan had choked I'd be the first guy to say it. He just didn't so I'm not going to. Sorry

 

[packerzrule]

If Ryan had choked I'd be the first guy to say it. He just didn't so I'm not going to. Sorry

hahahaha


okay

 

[Hank Kingsley]

Its amazing to me the lengths we will go to defend our QB's, yet have no problem throwing EVERYONE else under the bus........

If your boy Tommy B had done similarly, it would have been his death knell....

 

[Hank Kingsley]

I agree with you. He's a backup TE with a big mouth. Pats would've paid him if he was that good.

No they wouldn't. They have Gronk. Can't have Bennett making more than Gronk. It creates a Butler/Gilmore situation.

 

[Great Dayne]

No they wouldn't. They have Gronk. Can't have Bennett making more than Gronk. It creates a Butler/Gilmore situation.

Gronk is more injury prone than CMIII and that's saying something. It's not often that the Pats decide not to return a player and that player becomes an all pro. One more major injury and the Gronk will be done. Meanwhile Martellous is backup TE for majority of his career but we paid him like a top 10 TE.

 

[NWPATSFAN]

...




Bennett will be a litmus quiz for Rogers ...

The Pat's won the SB without the best TE in the game and had to rely on Bennett ... we'll see what Rogers does with him ...


maybe McCarthy will write hail-Mary's into the playbook ...

I thought the hail mary had been in their play book since the days Farve was chucking and ducking the up. ARodg has just perfected it.

 

[NWPATSFAN]

For 2017

Brady
Ryan
Rodgers

 

[Hank Kingsley]

Gronk is more injury prone than CMIII and that's saying something. It's not often that the Pats decide not to return a player and that player becomes an all pro. One more major injury and the Gronk will be done. Meanwhile Martellous is backup TE for majority of his career but we paid him like a top 10 TE.

Regardless, no way they were going to give Bennett market value over Gronk.

 

[NWPATSFAN]

We got a BINGO

Its called "Brady ballwasher" disease thats made its way to Atlanta

When Tom loses, its the Oline, the defense, etc.etc.etc., never Tom

Hey don't forget to add how Eli won two SBs single handidly. You remember telling us how Brady sucked and it wasn't the NY D. So it had to be Eli right?
Now go wipe Eli's juice off your chin so he has a clean place to rest his nuts.

 

[jarntt]

...




Bennett will be a litmus quiz for Rogers ...

The Pat's won the SB without the best TE in the game and had to rely on Bennett ... we'll see what Rogers does with him ...


maybe McCarthy will write hail-Mary's into the playbook ...

Yup. Without that 33 YPG average and 0 TDs in the playoffs the Pats were screwed...

 

[RP-29]

Did anyone drop the Hammer on this poll yet? If not...

Case Keenum > Brady

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Hey don't forget to add how Eli won two SBs single handidly. You remember telling us how Brady sucked and it wasn't the NY D. So it had to be Eli right?
Now go wipe Eli's juice off your chin so he has a clean place to rest his nuts.

I posted Eli's 2007 and 2011 postseason numbers for you yesterday, squashing your never ending theory that Eli was just along for the ride

But the next time you admit the Pats may have lost because of Tom Brady, will be the first time ever

No one is holding their breath

 

[jarntt]

If Ryan had choked I'd be the first guy to say it. He just didn't so I'm not going to. Sorry

well, obviously not

 

[NWPATSFAN]

Exactly

Brady and the Pats were fantastic

Ryan and the Falcons also choked

Both are very true

When you are down 28-3 late in the 3rd, you need A LOT of help from your opponent, no matter how well you play

Not sure 8:31 seconds is late in any quarter