Winston or Bortles long term

[Barilko]

Hey gang who do you feel is best if you were to keep a Qb long term in a Keeper

i have Bortles but if Winston struggles during the next few weeks of his tough schedule maybe he can be had

What say y'all

 

[TKOSpikes]

I think Bortles will be fine. Winston could be much more than fine. Higher floor because of the picks, higher ceiling is not crazy, as we saw Bortles ceiling last year.

 

[SoShady]

I would go with Winston. I think Bortles is a fine starter along the lines of a Ryan or Dalton. But think Winston's upside is just so much higher than Bortles.

 

[Barilko]

Thanks Shady Thanks TKO

 

[HaroldSeattle]

I like Bortles myself, he needs to cut down on the picks is all. Got to love his weapons.

 

[TREFF]

Winston for me. Once Ivory is healthy and banging away, the run game will be the offensive focal point whenever possible

 

[tlance]

I can't stand Jameis Winston, but I think he is going to develop into a really good QB. If he doesn't mess up off the field, he has top 3 upside in the future. Bortles is solid and perhaps safer, but will not ever be the league winner that I think Winston might develop into.

 

[richig07]

Long term, Winston is the better QB, IMO. Bortles (who I like too, for the record) had to throw a lot last season, because his team really hasn't had much of a rushing threat and has almost always been trailing. I think that changes, as they seem to be improving on defense and I imagine their running game will improve as well. Especially when Ivory is back.

Winston really has all of the tools, including the intangibles, that require a QB to really flourish in the NFL. They're also building a pretty solid team around him, which is obviously huge. In my dynasty league, you can keep one player every year, and you keep him in the round you drafted in. I took Winston in the 13th this season, which means if I want. I can have him in the 13th every season for the rest of his career. I'm pretty pumped about that.

 

[williewilliejuan]

Winston is the better NFL quarterback, but I think Bortles is the better fantasy QB. He has to put up a ton of yards because the Jags are always playing from behind.

 

[Hambombs]

Winston. Winstons playoff schedule week 14-16. New orleans, dallas, new orleans

 

[SteelersPride]

winston for reasons already stated

 

[Barilko]

Long term, Winston is the better QB, IMO. Bortles (who I like too, for the record) had to throw a lot last season, because his team really hasn't had much of a rushing threat and has almost always been trailing. I think that changes, as they seem to be improving on defense and I imagine their running game will improve as well. Especially when Ivory is back.

Winston really has all of the tools, including the intangibles, that require a QB to really flourish in the NFL. They're also building a pretty solid team around him, which is obviously huge. In my dynasty league, you can keep one player every year, and you keep him in the round you drafted in. I took Winston in the 13th this season, which means if I want. I can have him in the 13th every season for the rest of his career. I'm pretty pumped about that.

Now that sounds like a win win very nice and thanks for the insight

 

[richig07]

Winston is the better NFL quarterback, but I think Bortles is the better fantasy QB. He has to put up a ton of yards because the Jags are always playing from behind.

Except they're not a bad team now...