"Who's your Top 10 NFL QB List?"

[skinsdad62]

rodgers
brady
manning
brees
ryan
Rg3
luck
wilson
kaepernick
big ben

flacco isnt in there because to me top 10 qbs dont post 11 qbr's in games
newton is oh so close but i gave a declining big ben the nod because of superbowl wins even though i shouldnt have
eli is inconsistant but is top ten caliber

 

[Warpath]

RG3 missed two of his top receiving threats last year. Fred Davis went out with an Achilles and Garcon had a foot injury that kept him out for a good clip, and he wasn't 100% the rest of the season. And RG3 still had a 4/1 TD to INT ratio. Give them the same amount of attempts and RG3 still wouldn't have thrown 20+ interceptions.

You can't detract against RG3 due to a running game, when the reason the running game was so successful to begin with was BECAUSE of RG3.

 

[ckhokie]

Tired of hearing excuses for Luck.

Not making excuses for Luck, just standing by my original point. If you ask fans who aren't Colts or Skins fans, (including this thread so far) the majority say Luck is better.

I have zero skin in this game. You can call me crazy, but there are portions of the fanbase here saying RG3>Brady I gave my top 10, and am probably out of this thread for now.

 

[Warpath]

Not making excuses for Luck, just standing by my original point. If you ask fans who aren't Colts or Skins fans, (including this thread so far) the majority say Luck is better.

Baseless unproven comment.

If that's the case RG3 wouldn't have won NFL rookie of the year and wouldn't have led all rookies in pro bowl votes on his way to being voted in to the pro bowl. Sorry, but your argument there is 100% bogus.

 

[ckhokie]

You're right, let me clarify:
*would rather have Luck. Not the same as having a better year.

 

[obxyankeefan]

You're right, let me clarify:
*would rather have Luck. Not the same as having a better year.

 

[Warpath]

You're right, let me clarify:
*would rather have Luck. Not the same as having a better year.

Cool, so you're wagering that Luck will eventually be better than RG3 someday. He definitely wasn't as a rookie.

Time will tell.

 

[SoCalWizFan]

Not making excuses for Luck, just standing by my original point. If you ask fans who aren't Colts or Skins fans, (including this thread so far) the majority say Luck is better.

I have zero skin in this game. You can call me crazy, but there are portions of the fanbase here saying RG3>Brady I gave my top 10, and am probably out of this thread for now.

No reasonable Redskins fan is saying that RG3>Brady. I already stated in another thread that there are 8 QBs that I believe are currently better than RG3. This could easily go either way based on RG3's progress & his health. I don't think that you really have a good handle on RG3. He is much more than simply a running QB. Time will tell.

 

[mcro_rave_2001]

Cool, so you're wagering that Luck will eventually be better than RG3 someday. He definitely wasn't as a rookie.

Time will tell.

RG3's health concerns me, and that is why i put Luck above of RG3.

 

[Warpath]

Health is a valid concern.

 

[martinez]

brady
manning
rodgers
brees
eli
ryan
rg3
big ben
luck
flacco

wilson
newton
dalton
cutler
romo
stafford
schaub
kap
...

 

[rmilia1]

Ryan is better then Eli?? really?? and Flacco for that matter who is always in the playoffs, wins those games, and an SB champ?? Really??? I have no problem wit the way you have your list escpt for Ryan.drop him 2 spots, and you wont look Loony yourself!!

Yes Matt Ryan is a better QB than Eli and Flacco right now. Flacco played GREAT in the postseason last year but his regular season was just eh and the guy is barely a 60% passer. Eli won 2 SB based off his defense being great. I could see an argument for those 2 guys ahead of Ryan though but not anyone else in the league.

 

[Lonewate44]

Yes Matt Ryan is a better QB than Eli and Flacco right now. Flacco played GREAT in the postseason last year but his regular season was just eh and the guy is barely a 60% passer. Eli won 2 SB based off his defense being great. I could see an argument for those 2 guys ahead of Ryan though but not anyone else in the league.

I didn't have a problem with their placement in realtion to your top QB's...Just had a problem with you putting Ryan ahead of them......

I'm not taking anything away from Ryan, im not...He has been great for your falcons....but the thing is....Eli won becasue of his defense?? I see, so scrambeling out of the pocket avoiding the sack and making a great throw to his receiver late in the SB was all defense??....I hate Eli, but he is clutch.....And Football is a team sport......When it comes down to it...for me...If I had to take Ryan or Eli...Im taking Eli....His postseason sucess is far superior to Ryan.....Flacco as you say is under 60%...OK....that may be bit the guy is a winner...and that is what matters....He wins in the regular season and wins in the postseason....

 

[Krusheasy]

1. Brees
2. Brady
3. Rogers/ Roethlisberger
4. E. Manning/ P. Manning
5. Flacco/Griffin/Ryan/Newton/Luck

 

[Warpath]

1- Peyton Manning
2- Brady
3- Rodgers
4- Brees
5- Roethlisberger
6- Ryan
7- Griffin
8- Eli Manning
9- Flacco
10- Wilson/Newton

 

[skinsdad62]

i left off stafford on my list

and i shouldnt have . the guy is averaging 5000 yds the past 2 seasons with about 60 tds for the lions

 

[Skin'EmAll]

10- Wilson/Newton

I think I've only seen a few(myself included) put Newton on the top 10 list.
You put this guy on any other team with a good defense he wouldn't be overlooked.
Unbelievable rookie year. I think his main flaw right now is still learning to lead/handle adversity.

 

[skins]

1. Brady
2. Manning
3. E. Manning
4. Rogers
5. Rapistberger
6. RGIII
7. Ryan
8. Flacco
9. Wilson
10. Kapernick/Newton

 

[martinez]

and i shouldnt have . the guy is averaging 5000 yds the past 2 seasons with about 60 tds for the lions

hes not a top ten qb. watch the first half of all of his games and you will think hes terrible. his accuracy is really bad. i watch all of his games and all of rg3s games and its amazing how much better rg3 already is than stafford. buuut stafford is good in the second half of games ( basically because they are down so he throws to calvin a bunch )

 

[Skin'EmAll]

hes not a top ten qb. )

Yeah Skinsdad, IMO you were right to leave Stafford off. It could be play-calling at this point but Stafford hasn't looked like a top-10 guy.

Plus he's not a winner.