Much prefer Peavy over Garza is Peavy is healthy. Peavy has a extra year if club control.
I agree. He was a very good pitcher last year (219 IP in 32 starts, 1.10 WHIP, 128 ERA+, 3.96 K/BB). The problem is, Peavy is very injury prone. Last year was his first year with 20+ starts since '08 (when he made 27).