Which of the young Alabama/Oklahoma QBs in the NFL end up being the best over the course of their careers?

[PDay8810]

I assumed the same as you... and then saw this in the CFL thread that was bumped.

View attachment 284375

Too bad for Pep Squad

 

[Mebert]

I'm pointing out this other poster's claim implying that Hurts would have the lowest YPG is false. But then again, you are by far the dumbest poster on this board so no surprise you don't understand.

I did not imply he was lowest in any scenario. I was pointing put that you use cherry picked stats to try and make a point and literally everybody saw through it.

Since we ate cherry picking those specific stats itnis time to acknowledge that Stafford is one of the 15 greatest QBs of all time! 13th in yards and 12th in Touchdowns!

 

[RememberTheKoy]

I did not imply he was lowest in any scenario. I was pointing put that you use cherry picked stats to try and make a point and literally everybody saw through it.

Since we ate cherry picking those specific stats itnis time to acknowledge that Stafford is one of the 15 greatest QBs of all time! 13th in yards and 12th in Touchdowns!

Stafford is a career long loser.

What was cherry picked? What was your point? What is the YPG breakdown since you seemed to try to make a point about yards per game?

 

[Mebert]

Stafford is a career long loser.

What was cherry picked? What was your point? What is the YPG breakdown since you seemed to try to make a point about yards per game?

Wins mean nothing! It's all yards and touchdowns.

 

[tlance]

Stafford is a career long loser.

What was cherry picked? What was your point? What is the YPG breakdown since you seemed to try to make a point about yards per game?

So is Hurts.

His career just hasn’t been very long yet.

 

[RememberTheKoy]

Wins mean nothing! It's all yards and touchdowns.

Hurts will finish this season with more wins than the Lions had the past 3 season combined.

 

[Mebert]

Hurts will finish this season with more wins than the Lions had the past 3 season combined.

But less yards and touchdowns than Stafford

 

[Manster7588]

Hurts will finish this season with more wins than the Lions had the past 3 season combined.

No he won't. You willing to bet on that?

 

[Mebert]

No he won't. You willing to bet on that?

I would not bet against one of the great football minds of our generation. He was right about Fulgham, he was right about Smith, he was right about Hurts, and he will be right about whatever qb starts for the eagles next year when they move on from Hurts for not being good enough.

 

[RememberTheKoy]

But less yards and touchdowns than Stafford

Compared to Stafford's 1st and 2nd year as starter? No.

 

[Manster7588]

I would not bet against one of the great football minds of our generation. He was right about Fulgham, he was right about Smith, he was right about Hurts, and he will be right about whatever qb starts for the eagles next year when they move on from Hurts for not being good enough.

He may be but odds a very high Hurts doesn't have more Ws the Lions do over the past 3 seasons combined.

He wrote a check his ass can't cash.

 

[Mebert]

Compared to Stafford's 1st and 2nd year as starter? No.

Did you know that 100% of the time Hurts has not played the eagles have won? He must be the issue

Also that is a solid point that Hurts is slightly better than Stafford when Stafford has dislocated his throwing shoulder

 

[RememberTheKoy]

Did you know that 100% of the time Hurts has not played the eagles have won? He must be the issue

Also that is a solid point that Hurts is slightly better than Stafford when Stafford has dislocated his throwing shoulder

That's not true. They went 3-8-1 last season before he got to finally start.

 

[Maximus Rex]

Oddly enough their records are exactly how I would rank these guys too.
Kyler
Jones
Baker
Hurts and Tua will be gone within 3 years

My best guess is that this pretty much is the situation. Jones may overtake Kyler within a couple of years, but if I had to bet, I'd put money on both Hurts and Tua being gone from their teams in three years.

 

[NWPATSFAN]

Jones has the most potential.
Kyler currently though.

 

[NWPATSFAN]

Everyone leave RTK alone. You don't win fantasy leagues or Madden because your team won.

#somestatsmatter

 

[Mebert]

That's not true. They went 3-8-1 last season before he got to finally start.

Neat, Did you know in 1960 the Eagles went 10-2 and won the championship? Records before a player started are super neat.

 

[RememberTheKoy]

Neat, Did you know in 1960 the Eagles went 10-2 and won the championship? Records before a player started are super neat.

You're the one who brought up Eagles record without Hurts?

Was Hurts on the Eagles in 1960 and play that year? No. Was Hurts on the Eagles in 2020 and play that year? Yes.

 

[Mebert]

You're the one who brought up Eagles record without Hurts?

Was Hurts on the Eagles in 1960 and play that year? No. Was Hurts on the Eagles in 2020 and play that year? Yes.

You want to attribute almost an entire year where Hurts had never played to your argument. I just took it to the next logical step.

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

Okay so to sum it all up you made a claim I said something and it was completely made up.

Oh so now you're backing off your ridiculous comparison like it never happened?