about his incompletions:
Yeah, I don't know about that... just from watching the game live, it didn't seem like Smith threw it to Manningham because he saw the pass interference. (Plus, didn't the PI happen after Smith released the ball??) If that were the case, Smith would have exploded when they didn't throw the flag like most QBs do under those circumstances.
Before people go crazy on Harbaugh, these, unlike his unsolicited comments a few months ago, were answers to questions the media asked because of who we're playing this week. I still undoubtedly will see comments like, "OMG, why are we discussing this again?!!!" on boards.
I've read as much of your stuff as I can and I don't think you have a clear understanding of what Harbaugh and now Roman said and what is being said about their comments.
It would be nice if the story lost its momentum, perhaps we can help to facilitate that outcome? Just a thought.
I don't care what they said, I'm talking about what I think is the truth. That they evaluated him, wanted him here for the right price, and he didn't want to come for that. I have read and heard comments that interpret Harbaugh's words to say "no interest" when he didn't say that. I'm not making that up.
I've read as much of your stuff as I can and I don't think you have a clear understanding of what Harbaugh and now Roman said and what is being said about their comments.
It would be nice if the story lost its momentum, perhaps we can help to facilitate that outcome? Just a thought.
San Francisco 49ers video | CSNBayArea.com | CSNCalifornia.com Click on "Smith happy with decsions..."
Disclaimer: this doesn't make it true, just passing it along that it was said.
Alex said that he threw the ball because he saw the interference. That could be a lie, a truth, or just a factor in a throw he normally would have made anyway. It could have also been Manningham running the wrong route or Alex throwing it to an incorrect spot. My guess is a bit of the route and the interference, not just the interference giving the green light.
I'll post this on the other thread too just because it's about the other pass, but he said the Moss non-pass play was the correct read but the ball placement wasn't where it should/could be. He said that he should have led him on that play.
Roman said that he wasn't going to divulge the different reads of that play, but he was happy with the decision to throw to VD.
Then I'm really disappointed in Alex Smith's reaction to not getting the call. He should have been acting like a diva, throwing a fit and doing what all of the "star" QBs do to get those calls. I want to see him acting like a spoiled brat throwing a tantrum, the way Brady, Brees, and Rodgers act when they don't get the call they wanted.