Trade question

[Bandit]

Okay guys I have a question for you. The guy in my big money league (my brother) that has David Johnson is really hurting at running back and he is inquiring about Dalvin Cook. He wants to trade me David Johnson and one of his receivers (I'm pretty sure any of them) for Cook. What would you guys do? Here are the rosters of both teams and we start one team QB, two RB, two WR/TE, two RB/WR/TE, 1 K, 1 IDP. It's standard scoring (no PPR points) Yes it's my league, hence not having to start a stupid tight end.

My roster

BC's Pocket Aces

TQB Falcons TQB TQB Draft
RB Ezekiel Elliott, Dal RB Draft
RB Todd Gurley, LAR RB Draft
WR/TE Doug Baldwin, Sea WR Draft
WR/TE Michael Crabtree, Oak WR Draft
FLEX Tyrell Williams, LAC WR Draft
FLEX Dalvin Cook, Min RB Draft
DP Alec Ogletree, LAR LB Draft
K Justin Tucker, Bal K Draft

Bench Paul Perkins, NYG RB Draft
Bench Greg Olsen*, Car TE Draft
Bench Eric Decker, Ten WR Draft
Bench Bills TQB TQB Free Agency
Bench Tarik Cohen, Chi RB Free Agency
Bench Javorius Allen, Bal RB Free Agency

His roster

ORANGE CRUSH (1-0)

TQB Lions TQB TQB Draft
RB Frank Gore, Ind RB Draft
RB LeGarrette Blount, Phi RB Draft
WR/TE Dez Bryant, Dal WR Draft
WR/TE Stefon Diggs, Min WR Draft
FLEX Keenan Allen, LAC WR Draft
FLEX Davante Adams, GB WR Draft
DP NaVorro Bowman, SF LB Draft
K Matt Prater, Det K Draft

Bench Sammy Watkins, LAR WR Draft
Bench Mike Williams*, LAC WR Draft
Bench Marlon Mack, Ind RB Draft
Bench Willie Snead, NO WR SSPD Draft
Bench Danny Amendola*, NE WR Draft
Bench Chris Johnson, Ari RB Free Agency
IR David Johnson*, Ari RB IR Draft

 

[SmokingMonkey]

DJ and Adams/Dez/Allen for Cook?

I'd prob do it. Vikes O will be stuck in neutral as long as Bradford is out.

I only mentioned the WRs that I would want

 

[SmokingMonkey]

in a similar spot in my standard keeper league - I have a lot of RBs, DJ owner hurting.

was going to offer him CJ Anderson, Joe Mixon (he has Hill), Adam Thelien for DJ and Corey Davis - what you think about that @Bandit and any others?

 

[Bandit]

DJ and Adams/Dez/Allen for Cook?

I'd prob do it. Vikes O will be stuck in neutral as long as Bradford is out.

I only mentioned the WRs that I would want

Which one would you go with? I already have Tyrell Williams, so Keenan Allen would mean two Chargers wide receivers. I already have Zeke, so Dez would mean two Cowboys.

 

[Bandit]

in a similar spot in my standard keeper league - I have a lot of RBs, DJ owner hurting.

was going to offer him CJ Anderson, Joe Mixon (he has Hill), Adam Thelien for DJ and Corey Davis - what you think about that @Bandit and any others?

The keeper part makes this trickier because it's what you value DJ at in the future. What other running backs do you have on your roster?

 

[SmokingMonkey]

Which one would you go with? I already have Tyrell Williams, so Keenan Allen would mean two Chargers wide receivers. I already have Zeke, so Dez would mean two Cowboys.

Adams with the Jordy/Cobb injuries should be heavily targeted, if you are gun shy about doubling up on the other teams.

 

[SmokingMonkey]

The keeper part makes this trickier because it's what you value DJ at in the future. What other running backs do you have on your roster?

a shit ton:

Shady/Tolbert, Anderson, Martin/Quizz, Henry, Mixon, Kamara, Carson

have Cooks, Allen, Crabtree, Thelien at WR

start 2 of each and a flex, which I prefer to use on RB since this is standard

 

[Bandit]

Damn that a lot of running backs. I would probably offer just Anderson and Mixon for DJ and Corey Davis although I'm not real big on Corey Davis to be honest with you. Mariota seems to be spreading the ball around a lot and he doesn't have much upside for this year. I wouldn't throw in Thielen unless he inquires about it though.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

With tyrell, I would definitely take Keenan Allen. You get a top 10 WR and you are not affected at all by the potential injury prone. As long as Keenan is healthy tyrell is at best a flex.

 

[Bandit]

With tyrell, I would definitely take Keenan Allen. You get a top 10 WR and you are not affected at all by the potential injury prone. As long as Keenan is healthy tyrell is at best a flex.

That's actually a good way of looking at it. I think I might go that route.