Top 5 QBs in the league by QB rating

[HammerDown]

"Hey fellas, I'm just curious. How do you feel about Tom Brady being #5 in QBR? Do any of you fellas think he could be considered the GOAT? I'm just curious!!!" - rmilia

 

[GNG]

Replace Roethlisberger with Brees and this would be the least surprising list of all time.

Only if you count Brees stats versus Green Bay. Then he'd be #1.

 

[broncosmitty]

But Palmer sucks!

This is true.

 

[Scooby-Doo]

This is true.

Now smithy. You remember what happened last time you started with that lip. I know you don't want Palmer whooping up on the Lions again.

 

[broncosmitty]

Now smithy. You remember what happened last time you started with that lip. I know you don't want Palmer whooping up on the Lions again.

Hahahaha, why what do you mean Scoob?

Only two or three weeks before he gets another chance.

 

[HammerDown]

Tom Brady has a QBR slightly higher than Kyle Orton.

rmilia celebrates wildly.

 

[Nosferatu]

Kinda surprised Luck isn't top 5... Doesn't surprise me Brady is top 5, when you throw 35 three yard passes per game it's tough to throw a lot of INT's or have many Incompletions.

 

[Inimical]

1. Manning
2. Rodgers
3. Rivers
4. Roethlisberger
5. Brady

- Surprised about Ben, I knew he had a HUGE week last week but didnt know he was having such a great year. Otherwise list looks about like I figured. Thoughts??

Manning better pad those stats because Rodgers will smash them all.

 

[mr.hockey4242]

Luck throws too many picks.


Brady, Rodgers and Manning know how to sling it around without being careless.


I like Luck a lot but he's gotta fix that part.

 

[mr.hockey4242]

Manning better pad those stats because Rodgers will smash them all.

Rodgers started too late.

I saw some thing with everyone projected ages to catch the record and Rodgers has to play into his mid 40s.

 

[GNG]

Manning better pad those stats because Rodgers will smash them all.

Only if he plays 10 more seasons.

 

[HubertJubberman]

ben gets no respect.........and i dont care..........he wins

Ill take Ben over Brady

 

[GNG]

Luck throws too many picks.


Brady, Rodgers and Manning know how to sling it around without being careless.


I like Luck a lot but he's gotta fix that part.

He'll learn as he gains more experience. Rodgers, Manning and Brady have been in the league awhile.

 

[Inimical]

Rodgers started too late.

I saw some thing with everyone projected ages to catch the record and Rodgers has to play into his mid 40s.

Yeah those 2 seasons fucked him.

 

[GNG]

Yeah those 2 seasons fucked him.

He sat on the bench for 3 seasons watching Favre throw pick 6's.

 

[Nosferatu]

Luck throws too many picks.


Brady, Rodgers and Manning know how to sling it around without being careless.


I like Luck a lot but he's gotta fix that part.

Luck leads the league in attempts, completions, yards and td's. He threw 9 int's last year in 570 passes. Manning threw 58 int's his first three years in the league, Luck will need to throw 22 more int's in the Colts last 8 games to do that. He's only 25, there is not a QB in the league I would rather have than Luck...

Rodgers will not sniff 500.

 

[broncosmitty]

Crazy to think Rodgers was almost traded to Oakland for Randy Moss.

That'a been nice, for me and ever other non-GB NFCN fan.

 

[Moab]

Just think if he had all the weapons Manning has.....

Didn't Tebow have most of those guys too?

 

[Scooby-Doo]

Hahahaha, why what do you mean Scoob?

Only two or three weeks before he gets another chance.

Remain humble. We'll heat up the conversation when the game gets closer.

 

[R.J. MacReady]

Is it still true that nobody knows the calculation of the QBR but ESPN?