Ranking these 20.....

[SteelersPride]

Why not enter a thread and talk about the topic?

So what is your top 10 QB;s?

You have no intentions at all of making that list so why are you here?

Watch, no list.

Who are my top 10 qbs? Id be happy to give you a list.

1) Thomas brady
2) Dan Marino
3) Otto Graham
4) Peyton Manning
5) Roger Staubach
6) Johnny Unitas
7)Drew Brees
8) John Elway
9) Brett Fav
10) Sammy Baugh

subjective list.

 

[RaZon]

Who are my top 10 qbs? Id be happy to give you a list.

1) Thomas brady
2) Dan Marino
3) Otto Graham
4) Peyton Manning
5) Roger Staubach
6) Johnny Unitas
7)Drew Brees
8) John Elway
9) Brett Fav
10) Sammy Baugh

subjective list.

No Joe Montana, really?

 

[SteelersPride]

No Joe Montana, really?

Ugh. I did forget joe. Too many good ones. Hinestly i hve to keep sammy . Put joe at 3 or 4. Keep sammy at 10. Drop favre

 

[RaZon]

Ugh. I did forget joe. Too many good ones. Hinestly i hve to keep sammy . Put joe at 3 or 4. Keep sammy at 10. Drop favre

Hinestly i hve to keep sammy .....need to learn how to type.

I do get the Sammy Baugh thing, he was the roots to the tree, As you know the guy could punt in the NFL right now today.

 

[SteelersPride]

Hinestly i hve to keep sammy .....need to learn how to type.

I do get the Sammy Baugh thing, he was the roots to the tree, As you know the guy could punt in the NFL right now today.

Those in glass houses shouldnt throw stones. See you ask for a list. I give it, but still gotta take some shots huh? There were not attacks in my post, merely the lists. And you attack. Again. You cant help yourself.

 

[RaZon]

Those in glass houses shouldnt throw stones. See you ask for a list. I give it, but still gotta take some shots huh? There were not attacks in my post, merely the lists. And you attack. Again. You cant help yourself.

Dude, it wasn't you who told me......learn to type over a misspelled word?

 

[jeep99tj]

Who are my top 10 qbs? Id be happy to give you a list.

1) Thomas brady
2) Dan Marino
3) Otto Graham
4) Peyton Manning
5) Roger Staubach
6) Johnny Unitas
7)Drew Brees
8) John Elway
9) Brett Fav
10) Sammy Baugh

subjective list.

Maybe drop Elway and put Joe number 2.

 

[RaZon]

Of all the great QB;s John Elways numbers are really weak.

A 79.9 passer rating, ouch!

A 56.9 comp %, ouch!

1 4000 yard season, never had 30 TD passes in a season.

Thank God for Terrell Davis..

 

[SteelersPride]

Maybe drop Elway and put Joe number 2.

I hate elway. He was damn good though. But its a subjective list , we can boot him

 

[jeep99tj]

I hate elway. He was damn good though. But its a subjective list , we can boot him

I guess it would depend on how you looked at it. Statistically he was ok. But the comebacks he had put him up there.

 

[navamind]

Elway's career rating doesn't look great, but 79.9 for his era isn't bad IMO. For instance, his 85.7 rating in 1994 (which would be considered horrible in today's game) was 4th among NFL QBs that year. His 87.5 in 1997 was 7th, and his 89.2 rating in 1996 was 4th. He only had one 4K yard season, but there weren't very many in NFL history at the time. Marino's record of 5,084 was surpassed 9 times in the last decade, one of those being a Jameis Winston season where he had a 33/30 TD/INT ratio. 56.9 completion percentage is pretty much in line with the league averages during his career...

NFL Season By Season Passing | Pro-Football-Reference.com

Check out the NFL Season By Season Passing Stats including league totals and averages and more on Pro-football-reference.com

www.pro-football-reference.com

I don't think he's top 10 all-time, but I don't think those are fair criticisms.

 

[RaZon]

Elway's career rating doesn't look great, but 79.9 for his era isn't bad IMO. For instance, his 85.7 rating in 1994 (which would be considered horrible in today's game) was 4th among NFL QBs that year. His 87.5 in 1997 was 7th, and his 89.2 rating in 1996 was 4th. He only had one 4K yard season, but there weren't very many in NFL history at the time. Marino's record of 5,084 was surpassed 9 times in the last decade, one of those being a Jameis Winston season where he had a 33/30 TD/INT ratio. 56.9 completion percentage is pretty much in line with the league averages during his career...

NFL Season By Season Passing | Pro-Football-Reference.com

Check out the NFL Season By Season Passing Stats including league totals and averages and more on Pro-football-reference.com

www.pro-football-reference.com

I don't think he's top 10 all-time, but I don't think those are fair criticisms.

Montana had a 63.2 comp%, a 92.3 passer rating.

 

[SteelersPride]

I guess it would depend on how you looked at it. Statistically he was ok. But the comebacks he had put him up there.

yeah its one of those how do you view it kinda things...Some guys just have an "it" . He had "it". I said for a long time, if i had 1 game to win, or 2 min left on the clock....the only qb i would take over ben, is brady.

 

[jeep99tj]

yeah its one of those how do you view it kinda things...Some guys just have an "it" . He had "it". I said for a long time, if i had 1 game to win, or 2 min left on the clock....the only qb i would take over ben, is brady.

Joe wasn’t bad in a pinch either.

 

[Clayton]

Of all the great QB;s John Elways numbers are really weak.

A 79.9 passer rating, ouch!

A 56.9 comp %, ouch!

1 4000 yard season, never had 30 TD passes in a season.

Thank God for Terrell Davis..

The end of Elway's career really elevates him. If the Chiefs choose Rich Gannon and the Chiefs beat that first SB team then we really aren't here talking about Elway near the top 10. TD really saved his career.

But 2:00 to go, 4th quarter, you're picking all time QBs you want to drive down the field and Elway is top 5 on QBs I'd want.

 

[sonnyblack65]

Who are my top 10 qbs? Id be happy to give you a list.

1) Thomas brady
2) Dan Marino
3) Otto Graham
4) Peyton Manning
5) Roger Staubach
6) Johnny Unitas
7)Drew Brees
8) John Elway
9) Brett Fav
10) Sammy Baugh

subjective list.

Real good list SP I might move one of the old timers or Brees to #11 and put Montana at #2 IMO. And I know you revamped your list with Joe Cool on there