Ranking these 20.....

[RaZon]

So someone who agrees with your opinion is called a friend. Someone who doesn’t agree with your opinions needs to think. Got it.

So where do you put Brady?

Nobody thinks of him as a Buc no more than Brees being a Charger or Peyton being a Bronco or Stabler being an Oiler.

Earl Campbell a Saint, really? Ronnie Lott a Jet, hahaha!!! Bob Hayes a Niner? Randy Moss a Niner? O.J.Simpson a Niner?

The guy said a dumb thing he knows it.

 

[RaZon]

Should have had Aikman but who does he replace?

 

[Clayton]

.....QB's down to the top 10

Tom Brady Michigan/Pats
Sammy Baugh TCU.Redskins
Drew Brees Purdue/Saints
Otto Graham Northwestern/Browns
Peyton Manning Tennessee/Colts
John Unitas Louisville/Colts
Aaron Rodgers Cal/Packers
Fran Tarkenton Georgia/Vikings
Brett Favre So. Miss/Packers
Roger Staubach Navy/Cowboys
Russell Wilson Wisconsin/Seahawks
Joe Montana ND/Niners
Big Ben Miami Ohio.Steelers
John Elway Stanford/Broncos
Dan Marino Pitt/Dolphins
Warren Moon Washington/Oilers
Philip Rivers North Carolina/Chargers
Eli Manning Miss/Giants
Terry Bradshaw La. Tech/Steelers
Dan Fouts Oregon/Chargers

I would eliminate Rivers for sure. Hall of the Very Good candidate imo but will likely be HOF. Had some really down seasons and struggled against better competition after starting off really hot.

Eli Manning and Big Ben also seem easy to eliminate.

From there, Terry Bradshaw looks like someone who wouldn't make the cut. Great player just not near GOAT QB status. Steelers were known more for their defense. I'm sure we'll get some disagreement there.

So I can get it down to 16 easy. Remove Russell Wilson because he isnt there yet (but he will be), Fouts for not winning enough. Probably Fran Tarkenton, too. 13. Last 3 cut would probably be Moon, Favre, and Elway.

 

[RaZon]

I would eliminate Rivers for sure. Hall of the Very Good candidate imo but will likely be HOF. Had some really down seasons and struggled against better competition after starting off really hot.

Eli Manning and Big Ben also seem easy to eliminate.

From there, Terry Bradshaw looks like someone who wouldn't make the cut. Great player just not near GOAT QB status. Steelers were known more for their defense. I'm sure we'll get some disagreement there.

So I can get it down to 16 easy. Remove Russell Wilson because he isnt there yet (but he will be), Fouts for not winning enough. Probably Fran Tarkenton, too. 13. Last 3 cut would probably be Moon, Favre, and Elway.

Great stuff dying to see your final decision, love to encounter someone who knows the game.

 

[Clayton]

Great stuff dying to see your final decision, love to encounter someone who knows the game.

Its not really something you can be 100% certain about because the game has changed too much. So ultimately everyone's list is just a guess outside of Brady, Peyton and Montana

 

[RaZon]

Its not really something you can be 100% certain about because the game has changed too much. So ultimately everyone's list is just a guess outside of Brady, Peyton and Montana

I do look at all pro, passer rating, playoff success, pro bowls. Was a guy considered to be among the best of his era?

Obviously we all have our thing but a few things simply can't be debated. Yes Tom Brady is THE GOAT, yes Lamar Jackson the fastest QB we have seen, yes Joe Montana will always be on that QB Mount Rushmore.

 

[RaZon]

How did I leave Steve Young off the list? EL DUHO!!!

 

[RaZon]

Check out Pac8/10/12 NFL QB's

Drew Bledsoe
Warren Moon
Mark Brunell
Dan Fouts
Jason Herbert
Aaron Rodgers
Steve Bartkowski
John Brodie
Jim Plunkett
Andrew Luck
John Elway
Carson Palmer
Troy Aikman
Danny White
Jake Plummer

Five HOFers up there, Rodgers a lock.

What other NCAA conference compares to that?

 

[SteelersPride]

Yep, SB wins meant everything that is why Brady is a Pat, think before posting, ok?

Pats a ton Bucs 1

Dude now thinking.......blew that all to hell......hahahaha!!!!!!!!!!!!! What a dumb thing to say, wow!

Curious how he ties to worm out of that DUH!

Brady is currently a buc. Perhaps you should think. You can google it. Hes not a patriot.

 

[jeep99tj]

So where do you put Brady?

Nobody thinks of him as a Buc no more than Brees being a Charger or Peyton being a Bronco or Stabler being an Oiler.

Earl Campbell a Saint, really? Ronnie Lott a Jet, hahaha!!! Bob Hayes a Niner? Randy Moss a Niner? O.J.Simpson a Niner?

The guy said a dumb thing he knows it.

How many times do you edit a post before you think you have what you wanna post?

 

[RaZon]

How many times do you edit a post before you think you have what you wanna post?

How many times do you hump on a leg in a 24 hour period? Dude, get a life pity is setting in,, yep, starting to feel sorry for you. Am I the best ya can do, hahahahaha!!!!!

 

[jeep99tj]

How many times do you hump on a leg in a 24 hour period? Dude, get a life pity is setting in,, yep, starting to feel sorry for you. Am I the best ya can do, hahahahaha!!!!!

Answer the question.

 

[SteelersPride]

How many times do you hump on a leg in a 24 hour period? Dude, get a life pity is setting in,, yep, starting to feel sorry for you. Am I the best ya can do, hahahahaha!!!!!

Your back to the humping thing again eh

 

[RaZon]

Your back to the humping thing again eh

How about, hey jeep99 what is wrong with you....well?

 

[jeep99tj]

Your back to the humping thing again eh

Hes got a very disturbing fixation on that.

 

[RaZon]

Answer the question.

When you start answering mine, so why no threads, why just leech off us?

 

[RaZon]

Hes got a very disturbing fixation on that.

Here you are doing nothing but me, that is a fixation.

 

[SteelersPride]

Hes got a very disturbing fixation on that.

Constant. Creepppppy. Guess thats why they call him princess.

 

[jeep99tj]

Constant. Creepppppy. Guess thats why they call him princess.

Boys track and leg humping.

 

[Wamu]

1. Russell Wilson


The rest don't matter because all QB's are now only judged by what they did their first nine years in the league.


So just ignore that TB12 won a Lombardi Trophy his first three trips to the playoffs. He wasn't even good enough to start as a rookie. What a chump.